Mike Shenk’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Added Support”—Jim’s review
Theme answers are familiar phrases that have an added OW at the end. The revealer is ENDOW (66a, [Support with funding, and, if reparsed, a hint to this puzzle’s theme]).
- 17a. [“D’oh!” from Homer Simpson?] DUMB BELLOW. Dumbbell.
- 29a. [Porthole at the back of the plane?] TAIL WINDOW. Tailwind.
- 43a. [Grassy expanse by the water?] LAKE MEADOW. Lake Mead.
- 58a. [Come-on offered to a nursery customer?] FREE WILLOW. Free will.
I was expecting the revealer to be something like BACKACHES. I think I would have enjoyed that a little more. Otherwise it’s a solid add-some-letters theme.
In the fill, those two 8-letter Across entries seemed like theme answers at first, but the lack of question marks in the clues ensured they weren’t involved. I see MESS MATE gets some hits on online, but I have to wonder if it’s a phrase people actually use. It never came up while I was in the military, but then my experience was far from extensive.
The real highlights in this grid are those long Downs, especially the two corner stacks: ISLAND TIME with “THAT DOES IT!” as well as DELTA FORCE with ICE SKATERS. Lovely! Honorable mention to VAN HALEN and SABBATHS in the other corners.
Clues of note:
- 19a. [Hand-to-hand contact]. CLAP. I wonder if some solvers read the last word as “combat”.
- 24d. [City south of Puget Sound]. TACOMA. Hmm. Not really. Olympia’s at the southern end of the Sound, but you can go west and even southwest from TACOMA and end up getting wet.
- 39d. [“Dance the Night Away” band]. VAN HALEN. I didn’t recognize the title, and going by that alone, it sounded more apt for a motown hit than a 1980s rocker. But of course I’ve heard the song before. Let’s check it out below.
Solid theme, but the fill steals the show. 3.75 stars.
Casey Callaghan & Will Nediger’s New York Times crossword—Amy’s recap
The theme here involves the Rome tourist attraction, THE SPANISH STEPS, and there’s an Italian thing I’d never heard of, 17a. [House of worship at the top of 67-Across], TRINITA DEI MONTI. The circled squares in the grid’s center spell out the Spanish numbers UNO DOS TRES CUATRO in a stairstep pattern. I see the architectural vibe of having the “Spanish steps” of numbers climbing up towards that church, but the payoff for the climb is reduced if you’ve already had to work the crossings for all 15 letters of that church name.
Fave fill: PITMASTER, HOME ALONE, SCHOLARS. “TRADESIES” doesn’t ring a bell to me. Maybe it’s a generational thing?
Did not know: 42d. [Linux software packages, informally], DISTROS.
Three stars from me.
Bill Conner’s USA Today Crossword, “Floor Plans” — Emily’s write-up
It’s always good to be prepared.
Theme: each themer in the downs ends in a word that can be added before “plans” to make a new phrase
Themers:
- 4d. [Shenanigans], FUNNYBUSINESS
- 6d. [Quickly get started], SWINGINTOACTION
- 18d. [Speak convincingly (though perhaps not truthfully)], TALKAGOODGAME
FUNNYBUSINESS, SWINGINTOACTION, and TALKAGOODGAME. Also, the title is a great clue since “floor” is below or on the bottom and in the themers are in the downs today so the bottom word is the one used for the theme. With the theme, we get BUSINESS PLANS, ACTION PLANS, and GAME PLANS.
Favorite fill: SEGA, AMINO, TOOLBAR, and MWAH
Stumpers: RAISECAIN (tricky for me since Raisin’ Canes is a restaurant chain here), HORNEDIN (uncommon to me to needed crossings), and NORTE (new to me)
A lovely puzzle overall with a great theme and themer set. Lots of wonderful fill including some lengthy bonus fill. It took me a bit longer than usual though there were many entries that I didn’t know or had trouble even with their crossings, especially in the left side of the grid with the NW and W sections being the hardest for me. No entries were super hard so other solvers may have an easier time, depending on your knowledge. Give it a try and let us know!
3.5 stars
Paul Leistra’s Universal crossword, “Semifinals” — pannonica’s write-up
Circled squares at both termini of the theme answers.
- 61aR [Hair problems … or a theme hint] SPLIT ENDS. Those letters spell synonyms for ‘end’.
- 17a. [“Who’s on First?” comic] BUDD ABBOTT (butt).
- 29a. [Part of a mortgage check] INTEREST PAYMENT (intent).
- 36a. [Benefit from nepotism, perhaps] START AT THE TOP (stop).
- 46a. [Where team teaching may occur] DOUBLE CLASSROOM (doom).
I appreciate the variety of senses for ‘end’ used. And also that the ‘ends’ appear on the ends.
- 4d [Attempt to bring up the passed?] SÉANCE. The question mark in the clue isn’t to signal misdirection—the clue itself doesn’t make much sense. Rather, it’s there to demonstrate that ‘passed’ is not a spelling error for ‘past’.
- 9d [Lovable figure] BODY TYPE. Now, I feel there should be a question mark here too, acknowledging the positivity mantra to love one’s body. Without it, the clue/answer combination feels off.
- 13d [Yonge __ (main road in Toronto)] STREET. Can’t help but think there’s a personal connection to the constructor here. Why else mention that unusual locale, unless perhaps to introduce the crossword-friendly YONGE to audiences?
- 40d [Stench] ODOR. You know my spiel.
- 60d [Freezer cubes] ICE. I’ve recently started making clear ice, with a specialized tray.
- 1a [What Blue Jays often have on their heads] CAPS. Note the capitalized name, which counteracts any potential misdirection.
- 53a [Cosmetics brand] OLAY. This is incorrect. They offer skin care products.
- 68a [Rod’s partner] REEL. It isn’t technically a duplication with 6d [Yank who retired in 2016] A-ROD, but if it were me, I’d have chosen to clue REEL differently anyway.
Billy Bratton’s AV Club Classic crossword, “AV Classic Themeless #78”–Amy’s recap
Lots to like here in this medium-ish difficulty (between a Friday and Saturday NYT level) themeless.
Fave fill: The well-named brand EMERGEN-C, COOKIE JAR (nice clue, [Gingerbread house?]), BREASTFED, MEATSPACE, WORK IT OUT, DOVETAILS, REPO MAN, EXTREME MAKEOVER, BRUSH UP. Meh: DEAR ONE, LIKE NOW. Suspect the LIKE NOW/REKT crossing has wrecked some solves.
Did not know:
- 54a. [Currently prominent characters and strategies], META GAME. I have encountered the concept of “useful in the meta” in Pokémon Go, and I guess that’s related?
- 11d. [Depeche Mode hit with the line “words are very unnecessary”], ENJOY THE SILENCE. Depeche Mode is from my generation, not Billy’s. Back in the 1980s I did have a goth friend at Carleton who was into the band, but I was more new wave and indie rock then. Didn’t know this song at all. Please enjoy the inscrutable video!
3.5 stars from me.
Larry Snyder’s LA Times crossword – Gareth’s theme summary
Larry Snyder’s theme consists of four words with meanings that are “Briticisms” and another that is not. The phrases use the non-Briticism meaning, but are clued using the Briticism. Such themes are always personally jarring as they mix words that sound normal to me, and others that sound foreign. In this case only “jumper” sounds specifically British to my own ears:
- [Arugula researcher at Cambridge?], ROCKETSCIENTIST
- [Pristine field for Manchester United?], PERFECTPITCH
- [Sweater for a thrill-seeker’s leap off Tower Bridge?], BUNGEEJUMPER
- [Pure sausages at the Rose & Crown pub?], ABSOLUTEBANGERS
Gareth
Does today’s LAT have a theme? Or is it themeless?
One word in each theme entry is British English for a word in the clue — e.g., a sweater [40A] is a jumper.
I didn’t see how scientist is a Britishism. Certainly, scientists do research, but do the Brits call someone who does research. a scientist?
Plus, rocket science is a common US term.
Really did not like this theme.
This one really confused me, but google tells me that Brits call arugula “rocket” (from the french roqette for the name of that lettuce). So that was the british part I guess.
Exactly. As I said, “one word” is a Britishism. Hence, not scientist but arugula/rocket. Lovely puzzle.
NYT: I classify this one as clever construction, not so great for the solver. No real payoff, but we have to put up with ORANG, DISTROS and TRADESIES.
ORANG is a pretty common word for ORANGUTAN. But I never heard the other two before.
Programmers, especially in the Unix/Linux world, use “distro” in everyday speech.
I’ve never seen ORANG outside of crosswords. And programmer jargon is a pretty specialized niche.
Courtesy of Merriam-Webster:
Hopefully, the connection is made that kids can do their part to save wild orangs by coming to understand that purchasing products made with sustainable palm oil will help save these habitats.
—Jennifer Diliberti-Shea, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, 5 Mar. 2018
The global adventure series sends Josh to the islands of Indonesia in search of the elusive orang pendek.
—Chuck Barney, The Mercury News, 19 May 2017
The announcement did not list the number of orangs born in zoos last year.
—Doug MacCash, NOLA.com, 7 June 2017
But I agree DISTROS seems too niche for a mainstream puzzle. The Wordplay comments include several in which people are arguing as to whether the clue is wrong or close enough.
I did a google ngram search for orang, orca, tradesies, distro, pitmaster+pit master. Orang, orca, coati, and opaki
https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=ORANG%2CDISTRO%2CTRADESIES%2Cpitmaster%2Bpit+master%2Corca%2Ccoati%2Cokapi&year_start=1800&year_end=2022&case_insensitive=true&corpus=en&smoothing=3
Orang and orca are the clear winners
Not sure what I did with the first sentence. The search was for orang, orca, tradesies, distro, pitmaster+pit master, coati, and okapi
AVXC: Not particularly fast for me, possibly because I was falling asleep (I left it 90% finished last night).
It didn’t help that I put BanaNA for 1D, figuring that bananas often get spotty as they ripen (or over-ripen). When I came back to the puzzle just now, IN ERROR was obvious from just a few letters. That led me to PURINA and a quick completion.
Nicely clued puzzle. MEATSPACE is new to me, as was the Depeche Mode hit. I remember the band but never knew much of their music.
WSJ: I only knew MESS MATE right away because it’s the name of someone’s pony in one of the Jill books, my very favorite series as a kid.
New Yorker: That’s the most challenging “beginner-friendly” puzzle I’ve seen in a long time. LAHAINA is not something I expected to see in an easy puzzle. (I don’t mean to sound dismissive of the tragedy of the Maui wildfires, and probably knew the name a year ago.)
I might have heard of MONOGAMISH relationships before, but if I have, it didn’t stick.
But what really killed my time at the end was seeing “Console” in the 59A clue and plopping in Sega based off the S. Crossword puzzles have taught me more than I ever wanted to know about video games, but sometimes what I think I know is wrong. The overly detailed clue for “The MALTESE Falcon” should have kept me from trying Sega, but I didn’t see it until I got the message that there was a mistake in the grid.
I did like seeing OOH SHINY in the grid, even though I needed a lot of crosses to get it.
Re: Sept 18, 24 Universal crossword … I get the ‘split ends’ part, but could someone explain what that has to do with theme ‘semifinals’? Thanks
I hadn’t thought of it but I’ll guess it means the “finals” (butt, intent, stop, doom) have been halved. But that’s just a guess
USA: The reviewer is confused by 28D’s answer. It is “Notre”, not “Norte”. The puzzle grid as displayed shows the correct spelling.
TNY: I must give this puzzle a 4.5 because two answers cracked me up. “Day Drink” and “Ooh, Shiny” both made me laugh out loud. Kudos to constructor Kate Chin Park for a humorous puzzle!
LAT: This puzzle was confusing and not fun for me. Why would the editors decide to run such a puzzle unless there was a reference to “Britishisms” in the clues or answers. (With apologies to the constructor, I’m giving this puzzle one star.)
Thanks PJ,
You made me think of something else. ‘Semi’ meaning ‘half’. Finals being ends.
‘Half the two ends’?
Who knows?