Muller Music Meta, September

puzzle — 7:33; meta — 75 minutes (Matt) 

muller sept

Season 4, Episode 9 of the Muller Music Meta, and it’s another tough one. Ten hours before deadline as I write this, and just 77 correct answers showing on the leaderboard.

Our title is “Digital Remastering,” and our prompt tells us we’re looking for a well-known composer. Our five theme entries, helpfully identified by their parenthetical numbers, are:

17-A [“Romeo and Juliet” composer (-2)] = SERGEI PROKOFIEV
27-A [“Manon” composer Jules (-8)] = MASSENET
39-A [Diva Rise whose voice was insured by Lloyd’s of London (-3)] = STEVENS. Never heard of her, but if her voiced needed an insurance policy she was probably pretty good.
50-A [Finnish basso and Grammy winner Matti (-2)] = SALMINEN. Also unfamiliar, but if you’re dealing with a Finnish surname there’s a good chance it ends in -inen.
63-A [“Martha” composer whose name usually includes “von” (+9)] = FRIEDRICH FLOTOW. Whoa, needed every crossing for that surname.

The first two are very famous but the last three are much less so, leading me to think that these five were chosen based on very specific and limiting criteria.

The first quirky thing I noticed while free-scanning the grid is that each of the five theme entries contains a palindromic trigram: OKO, ENE, EVE, NEN, and OTO. I gave this about a 20% chance of being meta-relevant, and a few minutes of playing with it dropped that number down to less than 5%. Time to look for another angle.

As with many of Pete’s grids, this one is so wide-open and tightly-packed with theme that I figured it was unlikely there’d be much more to the meta than those five theme entries, which turned out to be the case. But another half hour of poking around didn’t turn up any red flags besides the three-step staircase of OX in the middle-left. Another dead end, so I put the puzzle down for a while.

On my second pass, I had the brilliant notion to look at the puzzle’s title. Digital remastering…maybe we’re anagramming numbers? My eye darted to the first theme entry, and the FIEV at its tail jumped off the page. That’s an anagrammed FIVE!

Adrenaline flowing now. MASSENET’s tail anagrams to TEN. Heart pounding, prey very close at hand, nerd very excited. Last five of STEVENS anagrams to SEVEN, last four of SALMINEN to NINE, and now we see the reason for invoking Mr. von Flotow’s name, since his last three letters rearrange to TWO.

Now what? Let’s perform the arithmetical operation in parentheses on each theme entry:

sergei prokoFIEV = 5 minus 2 = 3
masseNET = 10 minus 8 = 2
stEVENS = 7 minus 3 = 4
salmINEN = 9 minus 2 = 7
friedrich floTOW = 2 plus 9 = 11

This must be right, since none of the four subtractions goes to zero or negative numbers. Has to be just one more step here, but what is it? Are those emboldened numbers above the letters of the alphabet? That yields CBDGI, which doesn’t look like anything. How about the grid boxes with those five numbers? That gives us MOBWM, also nonsense.

A few minutes later I had the head-desk moment: these numbers indicate the letter you extract from each theme each entry. So meta! So you take the third letter in SERGEI PROKOFIEV, the second in MASSENET, the fourth in STEVENS, the seventh in SALMINEN, and the eleventh in FRIEDRICH FLOTOW, and you get your meta answer, Maurice RAVEL.

Very nice! Pete had to find five names that 1) ended with an anagrammed numeral, 2) contained the right letter of RAVEL, and 3) fit into the grid symmetrically. I’m betting this took a while. Bravo.

Complex and fun, 4.55 stars. I love the thrill of the chase in these, and I love being 9-for-9 in 2015! See you right here next month.

This entry was posted in Daily Puzzles. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Muller Music Meta, September

  1. Pete Muller says:

    Thanks Matt

    81 correct this month.
    I love your solving play by play.

    I’m throwing down the gauntlet next month. October’s MMMM will be the toughest of the year, with a great aha moment for those that get it.

  2. Shawn P says:

    Dang it. I was so close! I thought the numbers 2 3 4 7 11 seemed to follow a pattern and went with Ennio Morricone (1). Plus, once I thought of him, I couldn’t get The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly theme out of my head.

  3. Pete Muller says:

    I could have spelled out the name of a different composer if I had used the same grid but different numbers in the parentheses. Can you find the composer?

  4. jefe says:

    Loved the mini-tribute to Merl at 2- and 3- down.

  5. Paul Coulter says:

    I got the answer right, but had to backsolve since I couldn’t find the number trick. Searching various lists for five letter composers, I came up with Ravel and Satie that would work from the available letters. I guessed Ravel since he’s more widely known. Did anyone else do this? I was very pleasantly surprised to be right, since I’ve missed four straight MGWCCs over the years under similar conditions. Great meta, Pete. Thoroughly enjoyed it. 4.5 stars from me.

  6. Kman23 says:

    I got the numbers at the ends and the 3 2 4 7 11, but was stumped after that…I put Brian Eno

  7. Percy says:

    Spot on with this write-up, I truly assume this website needs far more consideration. I’ll in all probability be again to read much more, thanks for that info.

Comments are closed.