untimed (Evad)
Matt Gaffney’s Wall Street Journal contest crossword, “Continental Drift”—Dave Sullivan’s write-up
Welcome back from a two-week holiday hiatus to the weekly Wall Street Journal crossword contest. Biweekly constructor Matt Gaffney is up again and he’s offering us a geographical meta this week. We are asked to name a proper noun, which could be pretty much anything, so let’s see where the theme entries (instructions) lead us.- 17a. [To get the contest answer, start with one of these], BIG CITY IN AFRICA – with the Y in place, I threw in COUNTRY. Given that (as we’ll see later on, *SPOILER ALERT*), he’s going for a capitol city, I wonder why the seven-letter CAPITAL (corrected, thanks Amy!) wasn’t used here instead. Would that have given too much away?
- 25a. [Then do this to your result from 17-Across], CHANGE ONE LETTER – funny how instruction puzzles all tend toward 15-letter entries; I guess since there’s so much latitude in how one describes an instruction step, constructors aim for the longest entries possible.
- 41a. [Then do this to your result from 25-Across], TURN IT BACKWARDS
- 53a. [Now you have the answer, one of these, and without leaving the continent in 17-Across], NATIONAL DEMONYM – from the Greek dẽmos, or tribe, a “demonym” is what a group of people call themselves, taken from the name of where they live, such as Cantabrigians or Cardiffians.
Until next week!
This was a fun puzzle and a nice degree of difficulty for me.
Evad: You mixed up CAPITOL (word for a building) with CAPITAL (word for a city).
It wasn’t just “nice” that the demonym and city reside on the same continent. The clue required it. I assume Matt didn’t want Iberian as the answer.
Looking at the comments over on the WSJ site, some solvers submitted IBERIAN despite the instructions. It never even crossed my mind as I was concentrating on African demonyms. Also, can Iberian be considered a “national” demonym in the sense Ivorian can?
Dave S. — I think Evad was just saying that it tightened the meta up.
Yes, that too.