Natan Last, Finn Vigeland, and J.A.S.A. Crossword Class’ New York Times crossword—Erin’s write-up
Today the NYT brings us a collaboration between constructors Natan Last and Finn Vigeland and the crossword construction course they teach at the Jewish Association Serving the Aging (JASA). Their theme involves increasing numbers of rings visually represented by Os and tied together by 15 hours of epic opera:
- 16a. [Place to find one O] THE HOBBIT
- 22a. [Place to find two Os] VENN DIAGRAM
- 28a. [Place to find three Os] CIRCUS TENT
- 40a. [Place to find four Os] AUDI DEALER
- 45a. [Place to find five Os] OLYMPIC FLAG
- 59a. [Wagner work … or a possible title for this puzzle] RING CYCLE
I found the theme quite enjoyable, from the One Ring found in THE HOBBIT to the three-ring CIRCUS to the timely five interlocking rings of the OLYMPIC FLAG. AUDI DEALER as opposed to the Audi logo isn’t wonderful, and VENN DIAGRAMs can have more than two overlapping circles, but the theme carries a nice aha moment and feels fresh for the NYT.
The fill skews towards the younger side, with BOOYAH, GIGLI, DJANGO, “That’s what SHE said!” (most recently popularized by The Office, and why can’t he say most, if not all, of the things she said, anyway?). KITED [Floated, as a bad check] is a new term for me, and between that and YUBAN Coffee, the top center was the last of the puzzle to fall for me and took guessing YAK over GAB to complete the grid. NO I and AÑO/ANO (the longer I know what the word means without the tilde, the less I can unsee it) are the clunkiest fill entries, but forgivable compared to the grid as a whole.
Finally, we have CORGI. If I could give stars based on whether a puzzle contains Corgis, I would. Instead, here is a video of Corgis having a pool party.
Steven E. Atwood’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Adverbialization” — Jim’s review
Solid wordplay today from Mr. Atwood. Past tense verbs are combined with their sound-alike adverbs.
- 20a. [Patched a leaky roof after a downpour?] TARRED TARDILY. At first I had SHOT for 9d [Jab], so this led to TARRED TARTILY. I wasn’t getting it. I finally made the change and I still wasn’t sure. Just because you patched the roof after the downpour, you’re tardy? Maybe you didn’t notice the leak until the downpour. But I guess if you were a proactive homeowner, you would have caught the leak sooner.
- 33a. [Ornamented excessively, to one’s shame?] GILT GUILTILY. I have trouble seeing GILT as a past tense verb, but that’s what it is.
- 43a. [Made like a morose milker?] MOOED MOODILY. Favorite theme entry.
- 58a. [Felt the absence of, with emotion?] MISSED MISTILY. This will be me on Saturday as we get on a plane and leave our current home and fly off to a new one.
These latter two entries shine and make up for my trouble with the first two. So overall, this puzzle scratched my wordplay itch nicely.
The rest of the puzzle is good, too. I especially like PONYTAIL at 11d [Feature of Comic Book Guy on “The Simpsons”]. And those NW/SE corners are nice, especially the NW with MAYTAG, ICE AGE, and CHARON running Down. Also, RAY GUN in the SE.
Not a fan of KERR [Golden State Warriors coach Steve] and AREEL [Visibly stunned] and OLES and ARTOO and ALUG. But those kinds of entries are spread out and not too distracting.
Given that all the theme answers are at least 12 letters long and that the four of them have to be squeezed together in the center of the grid, the compromises are really few and far between. Mostly I was focused on grokking the theme and that’s as it should be in a themed puzzle.
So overall, a very satisfying puzzle. See you tomorrow!
Kameron Austin Collins’s AVCX crossword, “AVCX Themeless #8” — Ben’s Review
Someday I’m going to crack 15 minutes on one of Kameron’s themelesses, but I’ll settle for finishing in under 20 today. Two lovely sets of three-stacks frame the puzzle, along with an immediate understanding of why Ben Tausig included a quick writeup on the AVCX policy on puzzles passing the “Breakfast Test”:
- 1A: “That’s life!” — SHIT HAPPENS
- 15A: Factory worker in lederhosen — OOMPA LOOMPA
- 17A: Extra cheese? — MONEY TO BURN
- 59A: Miranda Priestly’s interns in “The Devil Wears Prada”, e.g. — ERRAND GIRLS
- 63A: Nonviolent gathering — PEACE SUMMIT
- 65A: Mouthy decline — HELL TO THE NO
I don’t mind my crossword being a little crass (have you seen my coffee mug? I clearly have different standards for the breakfast test), so as with Kameron’s past puzzles, I dug this, vulgarity and all. If 1A wasn’t your bag, maybe don’t dwell too much on 22D (FUCKBOY, although I usually see it spelled with an i at the end when the teens use it on Twitter/Tumblr) then? Or look up what 16A‘s ODB is an abbreviation of? It’ll be fine. This is a lovely themeless grid.
A few other solve notes:
- I kept trying to make “Factory worker in lederhosen” some sort of German brewmaster position, only for my brain to immediately snap to OOMPA LOOMPA once enough of the downs were filled in.
- 4D: Gave a roll, briefly? — TPED (Loved. This. Clue.)
- 9D: Sources of a medicinal oil used to treat cholesterol, obesity, and sore muscles — EMUS (Who knew? I tried to make this ALOE at first b/c that pops up in crosswords all the time and seems to have umpteen and twenty uses)
- 40D: Knee injury common among athletes — TORN ACL (On my first pass through the clues, I nailed that this was a torn ACL, but wasn’t sure enough where the ACL was to fully put that in the grid. Committed to a TORN something or other and came back for the rest later. I should trust myself more!)
- 45D: Uh, what is it, you know — THINGY (Also loved this clue.)
- 47D: Network of spam-infested machines — BOTNET (“Network” made me think this couldn’t be a BOTNET at first, so I spent a little too much time trying to figure out if there was a spambot version of a ratking. Enjoy that mental image.)
(Rihanna’s ANTI pops up at 56A)
A few tiny quibbles, but as usual, I love when the AVCX goes themeless. 4.25/5
Jeffrey Wechsler’s LA Times crossword – Gareth’s summary
I’m not in the best place – physically or emotionally – at the moment, but here goes… The theme is simple, and yet surprisingly limited theme. All the phrases begin with OO…
- [Butterfingers’ comment], OOPSYDAISY
- [Comet-filled region of space], OORTCLOUD. OORT appears surprisingly rarely in puzzles considering…
- [Chinese beverage literally meaning “black dragon”], OOLONGTEA
- [Plays it like Cary Grant], OOZESCHARM
- [Wonka worker], OOMPALOOMPA. Quite racist when you think about it, but then Dahl was definitely a bigot… Still a great children’s author!
- [Expressions of delight], OOHSANDAAHS.
Not too much more to remark on. I believe [Soda purchases], COKES will confuse some Americans, who use the words as synonyms… I have no idea what [“Care to take a stab at the answer?”], ANYGUESS is supposed to be. ANYGUESSES surely? [“… just as I am”], LIKEME evokes this, though probably unintentionally…
There is an indie puzzle by Neville Fogarty from two years ago with similar theme elements to today’s NYT (spun a completely different way). It was a nice bit of nostalgia for me to remember his meta puzzle while enjoying Finn and Natan’s current work. Check it out if you’re interested:
Does anyone know if KAC (who wrote today’s AV Club crossword) is still doing his HIGH:low puzzle? I’m subscribed to it via e-mail and I don’t think I’ve gotten one for a few months.
i don’t think he announced anything all official like, but he got a job writing for theringer.com so i think HIGH:low is on hiatus for the meantime.
The AVCX is probably going to get a few dropped monocles today, and maybe a threat of cancellation or three. I’m not against the swears myself, but I imagine the older crowd might not appreciate it.
Fun puzzle for me, even if I got clipped on SOMATA and AHYES. Thanks Cameron!
The hard-copy version uses an actual ⃘ shape, not a letter O, for each of the theme clues – including the central Down clue “A ⃘ doesn’t have one” for 30D: END. As for the central Across 37A:AÑO, it’s used for the 61A:ENERO clue, but aside of that it might have been clued thematically as “an ⃘”. I doubt that Willz would allow “Spanish ⃘” to clue ANO . . . (the actual word for ring is “anillo”, diminutive of “ano”, as with our annulus/anus).
Meanwhile I’m surprised that a community normally sensitive to “spoilers” dies not flag this clue for 45D:OGRES. Not everybody has seen the first Shrek movie.
*does not flag (not “dies not”). argh . . .
Re: 45D – I’m not sure what the standard amount of “spoiler space” for a movie is (or if there’s even a general standard), but at this point I think a movie that’s been out for 15 years (!!!) is no longer within that standard.
The AVCX has always done things a bit differently. I enjoyed the puzzle. KAC’s puzzles are consistently more difficult for me than most, but not in a frustrating waty.
loved the KAC themeless. also wanted 22D to end in I.
I’m usually pretty tuned in to KAC’s wavelength, it’s gotta be the name.
Gareth: How are we suppose to respond to “I’m not in the best place – physically or emotionally – at the moment, but here goes…”
O my…or better yet OH MY
NYT O< OO< OOO< OOO< OOOO< OOOOO
LAT is OO all the way
Gareth hope you are feeling better
NYT: loved the Corgi in the puzzle and the corgi pictures. About KITED, the general public’s understanding of the action is reflected in the clue, but the original meaning of KITING, is a different maneuver that involves opening a string of bank accounts beginning with worthless checks and cashing them in turn. Since this is no longer possible in our electronic world, KITING became a more generalized term.
Sorry for the delayed comment.
Hope I’m not too late. I still don’t get how in 47D, how BOTNET is allowed with Network in the clue. Doesn’t “botnet” mean a network of bots?