Friday, December 16, 2016

CHE untimed (pannonica) 


CS 6:31 (Ade) 


LAT 4:45 (Jenni) 


NYT 5:10 (Amy) 


Martin Ashwood-Smith and George Barany’s New York Times crossword—Amy’s write-up

NY Times crossword solution, 12 16 16, no 1216

The Friday puzzle’s got a quad stack in the middle and another pair of 15s. SERVICE PROVIDER, solid if dull. “HOTEL CALIFORNIA,” fun (and one of several pop music clues). ARRIVES ON THE DOT, feels slightly awkward. LAID IT ON THE LINE, solid. TRAINING SEMINAR, solid/dull. HAD THE LAST LAUGH, solid and properly placed in the bottom portion of the grid.

The other longish answers are also of variable quality. MARMALADE, COCA-COLA, EGG NOODLE (I think of egg noodles as the yellowish, flat noodles used with, say, Polish or German food, and the “pasta” of the clue as Italian noodles generally consisting of durum/semolina and water, no eggs), TRIAL JUDGE, COPACETIC, and LA VIE BOHEME were good. OF THE PAST seems entirely contrived to me.

Five more things:

  • 5d. [Ivanka’s younger brother], ERIC. Really?!? Twice in one week, you go with a Trump for your ERIC clues? Those of us who didn’t like it on Monday really weren’t expecting to see it again on Friday.
  • Butterfly pair at the Notebaert yesterday. Who knows what kind they are?

    25d. [“Fooled Around and Fell in Love” hitmaker of 1976], ELVIN BISHOP. I know the name, but not the song. Apparently Bishop was inducted into the Rock HOF last year.

  • 51d. [Michelle of “Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon”], YEOH. She’s going to be on the new CBS streaming show, Star Trek: Discovery. She’ll play the captain, but the show will take the perspective of a crew member played by The Walking Dead’s Sonequa Martin-Green. Woman star, woman captain!
  • 60a. [Flower known to attract butterflies], PHLOX. Not sure whether there was any phlox in the butterfly haven at the Peggy Notebaert Nature Museum yesterday, but there was heat, there was humidity, there was butterfly action.
  • 47d. [Compact item], ROUGE. Makeup from the ’70s. Everyone calls it “blush” now. (Please, Herbach, don’t rebut this.)
  • 45d. [___ Balbo, right-hand man to Mussolini], ITALO. I know this because there’s a statue of him near Balbo Drive in Chicago’s Grant Park. Why on earth Chicago has been honoring Mussolini’s buddy for decades, I can’t say.

3.4 stars from me. Bits like ADAIR, ETH, RIA, ORARE, I’M ON/ONS, IN A near HAD A HAND IN crossing two 15s that contain IN (and there’s another HAD in 55a) lowered this one in my estimation.

Martin Ashwood Smith’s CrosSynergy/Washington Post Crossword, “Hideaway” —Ade’s write-up

CrosSynergy/Washington Post crossword solution, 12.16.16: “Hideaway”

Good day, everyone. Today’s crossword puzzle, brought to us by Mr. Martin Ashwood-Smith, is somewhat of an inspiration to to try and find some warm place to nestle in while finding shelter from the cold. Each of the first four theme answers are multiple-word entries in which the letters N-E-S-T span the two words in each of them. The final theme entry, NEST, also acts as the reveal to the theme (71A: [Hideaway hidden inside 17-, 29-, 47-, and 63-Across]).

  • ONLINE STORE (17A: [Amazon, for one])
  • DRONE STRIKE (29A: [Unmanned aerial attack])
  • STONE’S THROW (47A: [Short distance])
  • WINE STEWARD (63A: [Sommelier])

Tried to solve this puzzle as fast as I could so I can get to solving Martin’s puzzle that he created with George Barany in today’s New York Times. (I’m currently printing it out as we speak.) I’m pretty sure my first two athletic shoes that I wore when I was starting to realize that I liked playing sports were shoes made my REEBOK, and I totally remember the red-and-blue shoe boxes that featured the Union Jack that they came in (15A: [Shoe named for an antelope]). Looking outside and feeling the chill from the freezing temperatures, definitely wouldn’t mind being in BANGALORE right now (54A: [City west of Madras]). Two of my friends live in southern India and have told me how nice the weather is all year around over there. Wouldn’t mind being there for that as well as watching some top-level cricket matches. Not the biggest fan of WAS A (51A: [“I _____ Teenage Werewolf”]) in the grid, but I don’t want to come off as a nag…or NAG NAG about it (36D: [Response from the henpecked]). I’ll just nag about something else, like the fact that the ink is running out of my printer. Well, that’ll be more money coming out of my pocket pretty soon!

“Sports will make you smarter” moment of the day: SKELETON (10D: [Anatomy class teaching aid]) – A spinoff of a British sport called Cresta sliding back in the 1880s, the winter sport of SKELETON, involves a single rider sliding down a frozen track head first on a small sled. Before 2002, skeleton only appeared in the Winter Olympics twice, both being in the games held in St. Moritz, Switzerland in 1928 and 1948. The 2002 Winter Olympics in Salt Lake City saw the return of skeleton, with a women’s skeleton being added as well that year, and has been a staple in the winter games ever since.

Thank you for the time and have a good weekend!

Take care!


David Steinberg’s Chronicle of Higher Education crossword, “Top-Down Design” — pannonica’s write-up

CHE • 12/16/16 • “Top-Down Design” • Steinberg • solution

It’s a Hanukkah theme, with a few interconnected parts.

In addition to grid art (with detached entry) and circled letters, the Note reads, “Fill in the three isolated central squares with the same letters as the squares numbered 52, 55 and 61 in the main part of the grid. This will spell the fourth possible result of 11 Down.”

With that preparation, 11-down is [Hanukkah activity suggested by the circled letters in 3, 21 and 23 Down] DREIDEL SPINNING.

  • 3d. [Incredulous query?] HOW IS IT POSSIBLE? containing HE. “A great miracle happened here”?
  • 21d. [Dated descriptor often applied to Truman Capote’s Holly Golightly] GOOD-TIME GIRL containing GIMEL. Little bit of Christmas seeping in with holly? See also 22a [Literally anointed one] MESSIAH, which is a Hebrew word and has pre-Christian significance.
  • 23a. [“Doesn’t that prove the point?”] SEE WHAT I MEAN? containing SHIN.

And the fourth “possible result” is NUN, (those squares labelled 52, 55, 61).

Not part of the theme: 14a [Over] ATOP. Dupey (title). 25a [Grain in some gluten=free challah] OAT.


  • 20a [Morsel] SMIDGEN, which looks like the name of another Hebrew letter. (etymology: “probably alteration of English dialect smitch soiling mark”)
  • 2d [Bohr found them far from boring] ATOMS. Speed-solving might result in both missing the pun and filling in NEILS.
  • Something ominous about the side-by-side arrangement of 8d [Pre-eruption warning] TREMOR and 9d [Peaceful] SERENE.
  • In the same place: 5a/10a [Sports-betting figures] STATS, ODDS. 10d [They’re often put into shells] OARS, 60a [It’s often put into shells] RICOTTA.
  • 34a [Screen idol who portrayed Myra Breckenridge] WELCH, atop (14a) 38a [Slashed pronoun] HE/SHE, giving it perhaps a temporal dimension. Still, risky.
  • 44a [Mushroom feature] STEM, not STIPE.
  • 52a [Cat or dog tail?] NAP. I’ve long found it fascinating how divergent in meaning the various cat/dog compound terms are. Catnap/dognap, catfight/dogfight, catfish/dogfish, cathouse/doghouse.

A fine diversion, not so complex so as to leave one spinning.

Gail Grabowski’s Los Angeles Times crossword—Jenni’s write-up

I’m filling in for Gareth, and I don’t regularly do the LAT puzzles. I was surprised to find such an easy puzzle on a Friday. This is not a complaint; it’s a lovely smooth puzzle with consistent fill and an amusing theme. I’m a big Gail Grabowski fan, and she did not disappoint.

We get a revealer as our very last clue: 71a [Sport that hints at this puzzle’s theme]. I finished the puzzle without sussing the theme, and then I went back and figured it out. The answer is POLO. Let’s see how it applies:

  • LAT 12/16 solution grid

    17a [“Don’t waste your money on that pendant”?] is a LOCKET VETO. If we swap the LO for PO, we get the POCKET VETO. Aha! PO-LO. Got it.

  • 23a [Spinner in a numbers game?] = LOTTERY WHEEL (pottery wheel).
  • 51a [Hammock?] = LOLLING PLACE (polling place). I’d rather have a lolling place, to be honest.
  • 64a [Pruning ideology?] = LOP CULTURE (pop culture). This could also be how you grow rabbits.

The original phrases are all solid and the theme is consistent; I needed the revealer and I far prefer it when the revealer is at the bottom of the puzzle. Nice.

A few other things:

  • 1d [Vegetation in underwater forest] is KELP, which always reminds me of the Monterey Bay Aquarium.
  • 6d [Comforter] is DUVET. I seem to remember a long thread on the old NYT Forum about whether a duvet and comforter were the same thing. My research suggests that a duvet is intended for use on its own, while a comforter is placed on top of a top sheet and a blanket. Hence the need for an easily washable duvet cover. The terms are used interchangeably in the US, so the puzzle is OK.
  • 9d [Henry Ford, e.g.] is an interesting clue for EPONYM. My mind goes immediately to medical eponyms, of course. Henry Ford is more likely to make me think of epithets than eponyms.
  • 10d [Excavating aid] is a BACKHOE. I did Google image search for “front hoe” and “backhoe” and they look the same to me.
  • We get PALE ALE and OPEN TAP  but they’re not cross-referenced. Too bad.

What I didn’t know before I did this puzzle: that ELM was [Split-resistant wood].

This entry was posted in Daily Puzzles and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

23 Responses to Friday, December 16, 2016

  1. Thanks, Amy, for the link to the ELVIN BISHOP song, which I clicked on, and wouldn’t you know it, the very next song YouTube’s AutoPlay feature recommended was HOTEL CALIFORNIA. What are the odds of that?

    Curiosity question — would you have preferred an ETH clue that referenced the legendary Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule Zürich (ETH), home to over twenty Nobel laureates including Albert Einstein? Or would that just be betraying my academic prejudices?

  2. Martin says:

    I was bothered a bit more about calling rouge an “item” in a compact. Rouge or blush, it’s powder which I wouldn’t call an item. The compact is an item. The stuff in it, not so much. But neither of these nits rise to the level of “wrong,” in my opinion.

    Your butterflies are Heliconius of some sort, probably Heliconius melpomene or Heliconius erato. Their erotic pose doesn’t have anything to do with erato.

  3. . says:

    Stunning accomplishment, four stacked 15s plus two more! Disagree with the idea that rouge is not an item in a compact… even if a collective, like a pair of shoes in my closet.

    • Amy Reynaldo says:

      But would you call water or wine an “item” in a drinking glass? “Item” connotes something that can be counted, that can take an indefinite article. “A rouge” sounds wrong to my ear.

      • David L says:

        On the other hand, water or wine could be items in a picnic basket… Well, arguably.

        • David Phillips says:

          I think Amy’s point still stands…

          I’m guessing that you would have a bottle of water, a bottle of wine, or some other container of those liquids. Oui?

          Btw…I love the name. You’re a prime candidate for the “David Army” in that you’ve met our only membership requirement. Davids unite!

  4. Steve Manion says:

    I thought this was an excellent puzzle. I was on the right wavelength for almost all the tricky clues. Only ARRIVES ON THE DOT seemed a little off. ON THE DOT is excellent, but I doubt that ARRIVES would precede it in any normal context.

    Despite being on the right wavelength, I found it somewhat harder than a normal Friday because I did not know ELVIN BISHOP, LA VIE BOHEME, or PHLOX (had the L and thought it would be TULIP. Embarrassingly, I had to go through the alphabet to get the W in HEW/WEE.


  5. David L says:

    Nitpick alert: it doesn’t seem right to clue BCE as the counterpart to AD. The pairings are either AD/BC or CE/BCE.

    The justification for CE/BCE has never made sense to me. Yes, I know the idea is to refer to a ‘common era’ so as to avoid connection with a specific religious calendar. But to whom is the common era common? People in the Christian tradition, that’s who. Or people who were colonized by countries with a Christian history. Putting a new name on it doesn’t change the foundation.

    • Martin says:

      Observant Jews don’t say “Christ” or derivatives, since it implies acceptance of Jesus as Messiah. “Jesus” is not a problem, since it’s just the Anglicization of a name, and a Jewish name at that.

      Recognizing that the calendar is based on the birth of Jesus is not an issue for Jews. Saying or writing a reference to “Christ” is. That’s why BCE is very different from BC for observant Jews. For Christians the “common era” is since the birth of Christ; for Jews it’s since the birth of Jesus. So many Jews have died for refusing to accept that Jesus is Christ, it tends to be a big deal.

      Since BC and BCE are synonyms, I don’t see a problem with the clue. It’s very common to use a synonym to avoid a clue that is similar to an entry.

    • Papa John says:

      I find it hard to nitpick any clue that provides a gimme answer. It just has to be right.

  6. sparto says:

    NYT: The clue for 33D TRIALJUDGE (“One calling the shots on court?”) just seems grammatically off to me. I can’t think of a context where a trial judge would be calling the shots on court. Was this intended to be a misdirection to make the solver think of another kind of court — say, a tennis court or a basketball court?

    • Amy Reynaldo says:

      When the defendant opts for a bench trial, the judge is not only ruling on admissibility, objections, etc., but deciding the verdict too. Of course, they’re IN court rather than ON court, so it’s one of those iffy misleads that I am not a big fan of.

    • Sbmanion says:

      I thought ON was iffy. One rationalization is that a judge decides when a motion will be heard, when someone must testify and other aspects of how the case will be conducted timewise

  7. golfballman says:

    Pants part? Knee, why not shin or thigh? It’s a pant leg period. Just wrong.

  8. placematfan says:

    Would love to see someone clue FIONA as the Shameless lead.

  9. Bruce N Morton says:

    My recollection from my days teaching at Touro Law School is that “messiah” is not actually a Hebrew word. The actual Hebrew would be would be transliterated as “mashgiach,” with the stress on the ee sound.

  10. Happymac says:

    TATER for four bagger? Still can’t get there….

Comments are closed.