Friday, November 3, 2017

CHE tk (pannonica) 


LAT 7:38 (Gareth) 


NYT 4:21 (Amy) 


Kameron Collins and Brendan Quigley’s New York Times crossword—Amy’s write-up

NY Times crossword solution, 11 3 17, no 1103

Of course the two themeless constructors with 7/6/7 names needed to pair up on a puzzle, just to elongate the byline. If it’s kosher to have three constructors collaborate, I’d like to see Narayan Venkatasubramanyan join forces with Kameron and BEQ.

So, what have we got in this 68-worder? The showier material is BEAT A DEAD HORSE (such gruesome imagery, really), GOOGLE HANGOUTS (I have never once participated in one), ROB REINER, PLUS ONE, MARLOWE (I realized earlier today that if I’d ever had a daughter, Marlowe, sounds like Marlo but is cooler, would have been a great name), and my favorite entry, UGLY CRY.

Seven things:

  • Sure, ANNES looks like a dreaded plural name entry, but you clue it as 27a. [Auntie ___ (pretzel chain)] with its implicit apostrophe, and you’ve got me thinking of cinnamon and sugar pretzel bites and all is good.
  • 57a. [English headwear with a short visor], ETON CAP. Meh. Put this in the same category as SAND DAB, ENCASES, and SEEDPOD: dull 7-letter answers.
  • 62a. [Like many of the Minions in “Despicable Me”], ONE-EYED. I assume I’m not the only one here who’s never seen any of the movies with Minions? (*ahem* Note PLUS ONE/ONE-EYED grid repetition.)
  • 25a. [“___ the Agent” (old comic strip)], ABIE. Who? Never heard of this strip, but apparently it was launched in the 1910s and helped introduce America to Jewish people beyond the stereotypes that were out there.
  • 51d. [Tequila chaser], AGUA. Wait. Is that a thing? Drink tequila, then water? I’m all about hydration, but this doesn’t ring a bell. (Note: Drinking straight liquor is not a thing I do.)
  • 48d. [God father?], TITAN. Ah, Greek mythology. Neat clue.
  • 49a. [Word after who, what, where, when, why or how], ELSE. I had the E and filled in EVER, which slowed my progress in this corner. Anyone else?

3.75 stars from me. Not as zippy as I expect from either of these constructors. Makes me wonder if there’s some interesting angle or constraint that I missed seeing.

Daniel Nierenberg’s LA Times Crossword – Gareth’s summary

LA Times

In a world so ignorant of biology that baseless GMO fearmongering can exist and not just be laughed out of the room, this theme uses remarkably technical language. On the other hand, the fact so many of the phrases used are so similar could be also be racked up to that fact. GENEEDITING is, loosely, a technique where the DNA an organism’s genome is broken at a specific point, altered, and then rejoined. Here it is taken as: “other phrases with gene are changed by one letter and clued wackily”. Let’s look at the theme phrases, because it’s here where this theme gets messy. GENETHERAPY is the use of GENEEDITING therapeutically; GENEEDITING is a (controlled) form of GENEMUTATION; GENESPLICING is similar, but involves breaking one organism’s genome and harvesting a gene and then inserting it into another organism – called recombination. This essentially makes a GMO, but although most modern cheese and insulin, for example, uses recombinant technology, none of the anti-GMO people have their undies in a bundle because it isn’t named. And only the proteins are harvested and they’re molecularly identical.

But this puzzle is stillborn. Should have been sent back with a note saying it was a clever theme idea, but you can’t have four theme answers that are so similar to each other in meaning…


This entry was posted in Daily Puzzles and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Friday, November 3, 2017

  1. Penguins says:

    Kameron Austin Collins puzzles always feel like quizzes.

    Found the LAT tougher than usual.

  2. MattF says:

    I found the NYT to be difficult, particularly for a Friday. That’s not a bad thing, necessarily– and I did finish it– but there was a ton of semi-obscure trivia that I think I’ve already forgotten.

  3. Papa John says:

    The NYT went smoothly for me, but the LAT and WSJ gave me fits. Almost DNF with the LAT.

    • Brian says:

      Same with LAT for me, couldn’t break into the northwest. I wanted MAXIM at 14a, and couldn’t see around that. Really enjoyed 2d and 3d once I got there though.

      Opposite experience on WSJ though…

  4. Zulema says:

    GOOGLE HANGOUTS was a completely unknown thing to me.

  5. Bencoe says:

    Hey, Gareth! Just stopping by and saw your comments about GMO fearmongering. Thank you for that. I have been arguing with my friends over that issue for a while. I have always believed in my uncle who is a Ph.D. horticulturist and has created some of the world’s best tomatoes. Better produce and more production is a good thing. World hunger can be solved by technology. I know that sounds scary because of paranoid dystopian science fiction, but it is true.

  6. Noam D. Elkies says:


Comments are closed.