Taylor Johnson’s New York Times puzzle – Sophia’s write-up
Theme: Each theme answer contains an ingredient in pizza.
- 18a [High-society, metaphorically] – UPPER CRUST
- 28a [Something unimpressive, slangily] – WEAK SAUCE
- 48a [“Smi-i-i-i-le!”] – SAY CHEESE
- 62a [Social event hinted at by the ends of 18-, 28- and 48-Across] – PIZZA PARTY
Very cute theme today! I went to a new pizza place today so this theme was incredibly timely for me and me alone (and not only that, I had a Margherita pizza, so BASIL was basically a bonus theme answer).
I like how the toppings are added in order, from CRUST to SAUCE to CHEESE. Do people still say WEAK SAUCE? It feels very mid-2000s slang to me.I’m not sure exactly how the “party” in PIZZA PARTY affects the theme, but hey, it’s a fun phrase and much more exciting than if the revealer had just been “pizza”.
It’s interesting how short all the theme answers are – only 9 and 10 letters each, so not too much theme material in the puzzle. It’s also interesting how sectioned off the top right and bottom left corners are – the first down answer that breaks into the top left is in the 11th column of 15! That means it might be harder to break into those corners if you can’t get an answer in them off the bat (although this puzzle played very easy to me, so maybe that’s less of an issue today).
The upshot of everything I mentioned in that last paragraph is that Taylor’s created a grid with a fair amount of flexibility, and a lot of long slots for great extra answers. I love all of ANTIMATTER, SCREENSHOT, SPIN MOVE, TIME BOMB. There are also a lot of fun shorter pieces of fill, which is a place that the Monday crossword can sometimes feel stale. Not so today – GEN Z-ER, YOSHI, and TL;DR are highlights. The biggest stumbling point for me was right out of the gate at 5a, where I confidently put in “Niner” instead of L.A. RAM for 5a [West Coast N.F.L. player, informally].
Hope everyone had a relaxing weekend! Congrats to Taylor on a great NYT debut!
Josh M. Kaufmann’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “In a Tight Spot”—Jim P’s review
Theme: MIDDLE SEAT (62a, [Likely spot for a procrastinating traveler, and a feature of the starred answers]). Each theme answer is a familiar phrase hiding the word SEAT within.
- 17a. [*How to summon a childhood fairy] LOSE A TOOTH.
- 24a. [*Unexpected ambush] SURPRISE ATTACK.
- 40a. [*Atticus Finch, for one] DEFENSE ATTORNEY.
- 50a. [*Crush or Squirt, in “Finding Nemo”] GREEN SEA TURTLE.
Nice choices in theme entries and a breezy, accessible theme for a Monday. When a theme is based on the word “middle” though, I always check to see if the keyword is in the exact middle of its phrase. That’s not the case in this puzzle, however. It’s an elegant touch when it is, but it’s not a dealbreaker. It’s better to have common in-the-language phrases than to have to adhere to an added constraint that’s not an essential part of the theme.
Not much in the way of long fill, only LATRINES and TED TALKS. And some tough-for-Monday entries in ITALO and ETATS, but the crossings are fair.
Clue of note: 11d. [Fill in the ___]. BLANK. Apt clue. We would have also accepted [___].
Ed Beckert’s Los Angeles Times crossword — Stella’s write-up
This puzzle has a revealer in the center, although I think the theme is straightforward enough that it doesn’t need one. 38A [Envelope-slicing tools, and what the answers to the starred clues literally have?] is LETTER OPENERS, which is to say that each theme entry is a hyphenated word or phrase with a single letter in front of the hyphen:
- 18A [Chophouse selection] is a T-BONE STEAK. It’s common to clue T-BONE with references to steakhouses, and interestingly, I can’t remember the last time I went to a steakhouse and saw the word T-BONE on the menu. Porterhouse, yes; T-BONE, not so much.
- 24A [Wayfair and Amazon] are E-TAILERS.
- 54A [Army fare during WWII] is C-RATIONS.
- 60A [Moving-day rental, for some] is a U-HAUL TRUCK.
I wanted something more out of this theme. I’m not sure “words and phrases that start with a single letter” is enough of a unifying factor to be satisfying; I would’ve loved to see some other connection between the entries (perhaps there are other food-related hyphenations that could go with T-BONE STEAK and C-RATIONS?), or if the hyphenated letters made a word.
The grid is mostly smooth — one quibble is that the MAE/SEAN crossing at 51A/41D was clued too hard for a Monday. If a solver doesn’t know either name from the clue alone, as I didn’t, it’s not terribly hard to figure out what it must be by running the alphabet. But running the alphabet is not something one expects to do on Monday!
Liz Gorski’s New Yorker crossword–Amy’s recap
Difficulty level: Around a Sat NYT, suitable for Mon TNY. An awful lot of music stuff in the first batch of Across clues meant a very slow start for me, though. Liz’s forte, not mine!
Fave fill: SIX-FOOT SUB, QUIXOTIC, FIRSTLING (which feels more fantasy-fictionesque to me than biblical), astrology STAR CHARTS, OPEN SECRET, BIRTHPLACE. Less keen on CORRUGATES (when do you ever use that -S form of this word? and it’s spotlighted at 1-Across), A PIE, EFS, TELE- and ECO-, AGUE, GUAR gum, and the SIT AT/TUG ON pair. Sure didn’t know that an OBOE SONATA is a thing, but can’t begrudge Liz her music content (she plays viol and violin).
3.25 stars from me.
Lisa Senzel and Jeff Chen’s Universal crossword, “Dietary Changes” — pannonica’s rite-up
Theme here is food items spelled correctly, altered from the commercially ‘creative’ spellings. I’m not looking up the ‘real’ spellings, so I’ll probably only get some of them correct here.
- 17a. [Naturally spelled cereal brand?] FRUIT LOOPS (Froot Loops).
- 24a. [Naturally spelled donut brand?] CRISPY CREAM (Krispy Kreme).
- 32a. [Naturally spelled soft-serve brand?] TASTY FREEZE (Tasti-Freeze).
- 49a. [Naturally spelled powdered candy brand?] PIXIE STICKS (Pixie Stix).
- 56a. [Healthy eating store that could aptly carry 17-, 24-, 32- and 49-Across] WHOLE FOODS.
Not really buying that as a revealer here, but the theme itself is novel.
- Just going to list some UPS. Make of it what you will. 7d [Grown-up tadpoles] FROGS, 14a [Barely winning] UP ONE, 26d [Stocking-up period?] YULE (nice clue!), 40d [Psyched] FIRED UP.
- 24d [2019 live-action film that critics pounced on] CATS. ISWYDT
- 33d [Half of seis] TRES, 51a [Half of hex-] TRI-.
- 43d [Kicks out of a country] EXILES, crossing 52a [Kick out of an apartment] EVICT.
- 16a [Sharpen] HONE, 63a [Sharpen] WHET.
- 20a [Arial, for one] FONT. Akshually, it’s a typeface.
- 23a [Brand for a hopeful couple, perhaps] EPT. Better than the jokey back-formation derived from inept. 50d [Wishful phrase] I HOPE.
- 60a [“Democracy Dies in Darkness” paper, briefly] WAPO. My counter to that, since its recent inception there, is that democracy dies in broad [expletive] daylight.
Brendan Emmett Quigley’s Themeless Monday puzzle – solution grid
Brutal workday, so I’m going to stop pretending I can get a review written and just get this grid up. Interesting shape–on his site BEQ shares that he feels it’s a pretty grid. I’m often cautious around right angles like this rather than a more offset stack, but I quite liked this puzzle, which played easier for me than the last month or two from BEQ, though I can see (former? current?) Cowboys QB DAK PRESCOTT being difficult for non-football fans.
NYT: I enjoyed this Monday puzzle. No complaints.
Just wondering if ATE RAW is a thing or is it in the ‘GREEN PAINT’ category??
I paused a second at ATE RAW for the reason you stated. At least I don’t recall it as a stand alone phrase.
It isn’t a big deal and I did enjoy the puzzle.
There’s what I would call a “fad diet” out there that involves eating only raw foods. I know a couple of people who’ve tried it, and at the time, they would say “I’m eating raw.” So I suppose that ATE RAW is a bit better than green paint. The way the clue is worded, I think it’s alluding to people on this type of diet.
NYT was okay but I thought the 10/19 Universal “Pizza Making 101” pulled it off better with five ingredients.
Thanks for finding that. I thought I’d seen this theme recently and you saved me some time.
I’m a man of simple taste, what can I say? ;)
BEQ: Finished eventually, but boy, that was a whole lot of proper names.
That BEQ is extra pretty because of the super symmetry (I think–I get confused sometimes) and absence of 3-letter words.
I’m often so on Elizabeth Gorski’s wavelength that I wouldn’t have known she could pull off the difficulty of this Monday TNY, but she did, always fairly. I struggled but got through.
I never felt I had to know more, even in music, where I’m sure she knows more but also where I’d have thought I knew something. But I didn’t recognize OBOE SONATA but also didn’t feel I had to know it. I needed one more crossing once I got SONATA to come up with the four-letter instrument, but there it was. My favorite Monday in a long time.
Because there are no words with three letters in it, plus it has amazing symmetry that BEQ stands out from the throng.