Sunday, February 12, 2023

LAT untimed (Gareth) 


NYT 18:16 (Nate) 


USA Today 3:39 (Darby)  


Universal (Sunday) 10:59 (Jim P) 


Universal 3:36 (norah) 


WaPo 5:22 (Matthew) 


Christina Iverson and Samuel A. Donaldson’s New York Times crossword, “Cheap Thrills” —Nate’s write-up

02.12.23 Sunday New York Times Puzzle

02.12.23 Sunday New York Times Puzzle

24A: CUTTING CORNERS [Economizing, as represented by the circled squares?]
Circled SAW and AXE literally cut the NW and SE corners off the grid

– 40A: PINCHING PENNIES [Economizing, as represented twice in 12-Down?]
– 12D: BI(CENT)ENNIAL (CENT)ER [Former name of a Kansas arena that commemorated a 1976 U.S. anniversary]

“Cent” is rebused (pinched) twice in BICENTENNIAL CENTER

– 94A: STRETCHING A BUCK [Economizing, as represented in 58-Down?]
– 58D: SSIINNGGLLEE [Not in a relationship]
“Single” is stretched by doubling each letter.  I genuinely don’t know if “single” being the stretched “buck” here is meant to stand in for stag (deer/buck, as in someone single is “going stag”) or xwordinfo seems to suggest the “single” is a $1 bill / buck?  Either way, it feels like one leap too many and not as satisfying a click for me as the other themers.

111A: MAKING ENDS MEET [Economizing, as represented by the shaded squares?]
CAN, BUM, ASS, and BUTT (ends) all meet in the shaded squares in the middle of the grid

In the puzzle, four idioms that mean “economizing” are represented literally elsewhere in the grid, each in its own way. I appreciated the inventiveness of the overall theme, even if some executions (like that for CUTTING CORNERS) felt more successful than others (I’m still not 100% sure I understand the STRETCHING A BUCK execution correctly). How neat that the idioms were nicely symmetric in length – the constructors must have pumped their fist at that!

I struggled to finish this puzzle because the theme and its execution seemed to result in a few tougher crossings like EGIS crossing INDIC and MARTEN crossing ANI. Immediately after the solve, I would have also argued that a bunch of the fill felt gluey too but, looking back, I think perhaps the cluing just wasn’t on my wavelength. I’m curious to hear how other people felt about the cluing vs. the fill in this puzzle.

Other random thoughts:
26D: ELON [Name hidden in “before long”] – Did anyone else originally have OREL here?
– The puzzle certainly felt like a collaboration, given the simultaneous inclusion of entries like BOPS and SAY LESS alongside NO BIG and DEALIO. At the very least, it felt like slang across multiple generations.

What did you think of the puzzle? Let us know in the comments section below. Have a great weekend and, if you observe the occasion, happy Super Bowl!


Universal Crossword, “Middling” by Fred Piscop — norah’s write-up

THEME: The revealer, CENTERPIECE, clues us into the fact that each themer has a PIECE in their centers.


F.Piscop 02-12-2023

F.Piscop 02-12-2023

  • ICESCRAPERS 17A [*Winter windshield clearers]
  • KEGPARTIES 11D [*Frat blowouts]
  • HABITAT 38A [*Native environment]
  • AUDIOTAPES 29D [*Cassette player inserts]
  • CENTERPIECE 61A [Decoration on a dining table, and what’s in the exact middle of each starred clue’s answer?]


Another rare themed Sunday from the Universal crew. We have SCRAP, PART, BIT, and IOTA at the center of the theme entries. And thank goodness they are at the true centers, with an matching number of letters on either end. HABITAT is a bit (heh) of an odd one out, being only one word. All in all, a solid theme.

The grid structure doesn’t allow much space for any long bonus entries – the best we get is RUSTIER and DISTURB, but more importantly it’s filled relatively cleanly. We have PDA, IPO, ESC, STP, SOS, and ENE among the three-letter fill and all are clued in a friendly way and crossed fairly.

Thanks Fred and the Universal team!

Sam Koperwas and Jeff Chen’s Universal Sunday crossword, “Split Peas”—Jim P’s review

Theme answers are paired phrases (two per row) that share a subset of letters. These letters end one phrase and begin the other. Rather than have the duplicated letters existing separately in each entry, there is only one instance of the shared letters, and these are identified by circles which help the solver locate the end and beginning of the two phrases. A block (black square) is placed between the double-P which appears in each group (hence the title).

Universal Sunday crossword solution · “Split Peas” · Sam Koperwas and Jeff Chen · 2.12.23

  • 25a. [*Holiday retail positions] GIFT WRAP(PERS).
  • 27a. [With 26-Across, hip-hop classic by the Sugarhill Gang] (RAP)PERS DELIGHT.
  • 43a. [*Semiaquatic pet given to President Coolidge] PYGMY HIP(PO).
  • 45a. [With 44-Across, rear pouch on pants] (HIP) POCKET.
  • 61a. [*Jesus’ final meal] LAST SUP(PER).
  • 64a. [With 62-Across, high society] (UP)PER CRUST.
  • 74a. [*Bumble, Muzz or Tinder] DATING AP(P).
  • 78a. [With 76-Across, small fruit pastry] (AP)PLE TART.
  • 97a. [*Backyard fryer?] BUG ZAP(PER).
  • 100a. [With 98-Across, relates (to)] (AP)PERTAINS.
  • 112a. [*”Forget it!”] “NOT GONNA HAP(PEN).”
  • 116a. [With 115-Across, horns, tails and such] (AP)PENDAGES.

Well, this was confusing at the start…and even at the finish. Two main reasons contributed to the confusion for me.

First, each right-hand entry’s clue starts with “With xx-Across…” This goes against the crossword convention where the “With” indicates that what we find at that cross-referenced entry comes after what is in the current entry we’re looking at. Instead, what’s there actually comes before the current entry. Also, there really are no xx-Across entries at all. For example, 27a says “With 26-Across…” but there is no 26-Across. There’s a square marked 26 which is the start of the phrase that is clued at 27a, but if you’re looking through the clue list for 26-Across, you won’t find it. This means that the constructors had to put a block above each such start of the second phrase in order to ensure there was a number in that square. Kind of a crazy constraint. I get it. I see why they did it, and I’m okay with it. It just took a while to sort it out.

Second, it sure seemed like the circled letters were spelling out words. For the first 2/3 of the puzzle, they were. And then they weren’t. When I finished the grid, I was scratching my head and asking “What’s APPER? What’s APPEN?” So again, it took a few beats for me to realize that the circled letters simply indicate what’s shared between the two entries. It just so happened that in the first four pairs of entries, the circled letters spelled a word that belonged to one of the phrases. In the final two pairs, the circled letters are parts of other words for both phrases.

Okay? So all confusion aside, it’s a nifty theme, and the theme entries themselves are all pretty fun (except for APPERTAINS—APPERTAINS can just eff off; we’re all doing perfectly fine with “pertain,” thank you very much).

What’s really impressive here is the dense amount of theme material plus those extra necessary blocks I mentioned above all adding to constraints on the grid, and yet there’s a still plenty of juicy long fill. Highlights for me include: AMARETTO, BENTLEY, ARAPAHO, RIVIERA, “EN CHANTE,” SYRIANA, AGED OUT, DEAD HEAD, TAMALES, USA TODAY, FINE TUNE, and PANATELA (didn’t know it, but it makes for nice fill). The only one I question is VAPE HITS since I wouldn’t know if that’s a colloquial phrase or not.

Clue of note: [46d. Money’s equivalent?]. TIME. At first I thought this was something to do with magazines. It’s not. It’s from the phrase “Time is money.”

Interesting theme, and I like that our constructors aimed to do something different, but it was still confusing. Loads of fun fill. 3.75 stars.

Evan Birnholz’s Washington Post crossword, “Team Picture” —Matthew’s write-up

Evan Birnholz’ Washington Post crossword solution, “Team Picture,” 2/12/2023

We’re prompted with a meta this week, and told the answer is “an NFL team.” I flailed for quite a while at each step of the way here, and Evan’s own weekly review at the Post might have a bit more clarity than mine. It’s an intricate puzzle that comes together nicely:

Seven themers contain the singular form of NFL teams, and have two enumerations in their clues:

23a [Revolver inventor (9) (4)] SAMUEL COLT
34a [Student newspaper at a Southern university (4) (5)] THE DAILY TEXAN
44a [Cry of encouragement at a rodeo (4) (5)] RIDE EM COWBOY
71a [Francis of Assisi or Catherine of Siena, to Italy (5-2-3) (8)] PATRON SAINT
98a [Device that powers up an Android (9,4) (7)] PHONE CHARGER
106a [Amphibious aircraft that sounds like a vacation spot for Blackbeard’s crew (6,4) (4)] LAKE BUCCANEER
126a [“Iron Chef America” host (6) (4)] ALTON BROWN

And I suppose 135a [Picture designed for an NFL team, say] LOGO.

Given enumerations like (5-2-3), I figured at least the first set of enumerations didn’t point to extracting letters from words. A little help from got me FLEUR-DE-LIS, which is happily a description of the Saints’ logo. That explains the first number in each clue: HORSESHOE, BULL, STAR, FLEUR-DE-LIS, LIGHTNING BOLT, PIRATE FLAG, HELMET

HELMET is curious, reminding me of the odd clue at 132a [Protective cover at a stadium] DOME. Turns out each of the logo descriptions we’ve got in the previous step can be a second answer to another clue in the puzzle:

HORSESHOE: 1A [Item tossed at a stake] RING
BULL: 21A [Beast with horns] ELAND
STAR: 37D [Night sight] DREAM
FLEUR-DE-LIS: 57A [Symbol historically associated with the French monarchy] BASTILLE
PIRATE FLAG: 76D [Where you might see a skull] RUIN
HELMET: 132A [Protective cover at a stadium] DOME

I got stuck again here trying to make the second number in each theme clue work with these answers, but turns out they just indicate the length of these other answers in the grid, while the first letter of each answer spells out REDBIRD, which describes the logo of the Arizona Cardinals. Funnily, the Super Bowl is taking place in the Cardinals’ stadium.

It’s only been a few months since I took over from Jim on the WaPo reviews, so I don’t have a ton of experience with Evan’s metas, but this was certainly a step or two beyond what I’m used to (Evan to his credit did warn me it was a bit tougher). The first few steps are clear in retrospect, and the LOGO clue at 135a was a solid point in the right direction. But I found the second set of numbers in each themer a bit distracting — looking for clues in the grid that might fit the words you’re working with is a common enough tactic that I wasn’t expecting to have a helping hand there.

I’m late enough with this as it is, so will stop there.

Amie Walker’s LA Times crossword, “Ten Minutes to Win It” – Gareth’s theme summary

LA Times

I heard a rumour there is some sort of splendid bowl on offer tomorrow… Amie Walker gives us eight answers with two OTs in them to commemorate this, revealed at DOUBLEOT:

  • [Cheap digs], POTSHOTS
  • [Rip-roarin’], ROOTINTOOTIN
  • [Kiosk at some wedding receptions], PHOTOBOOTH
  • [“Changing the subject … “], LETSNOTGOTHERE
  • [More than a little mentally fatigued], TOOTIREDTOTHINK
  • [Staley Da Bear, for one], FOOTBALLMASCOT
  • [Blank expression?], IGOTNOTHIN
  • [Slow-moving tree-dweller], TWOTOEDSLOTH


Zhouqin Burnikel’s USA Today crossword, “Outside Child”—Darby’s write-up

Editor: Erik Agard

Theme: Each theme answer spells out TOT in its outer letters.

Theme Answers

Zhouqin Burnikel's USA Today crossword, "Outside Child" solution for 2/12/2023 UST

Zhouqin Burnikel’s USA Today crossword, “Outside Child” solution for 2/12/2023 UST

  • 17a [“Internalized”] TOOK TO HEART
  • 28a [“‘That was really helpful,’ sarcastically”] THANKS A LOT
  • 47a [“T.C. Bear, for the Minnesota Twins”] TEAM MASCOT
  • 61a [“Something staked in a garden”] TOMATO PLANT

Who doesn’t love a TOT-themed puzzle? It’s a fun word for a kiddo, so I was delighted in realizing that TOT would bookend each of the themers. These all fell into place pretty easily, and I sped through, finishing under 4 minutes (which is fast for me!). TEAM MASCOT was my favourite, though I also liked the invocation of sarcasm in the clue for THANKS A LOT.

For a puzzle with four themers, there was also a lot of other long fill that was run. I took longer than I should have with FUNNEL CAKE, calling it FRIED DOUGH at first. I KID YOU NOT was also particularly fun, given the kid-friendly nature of the grid itself. SKI RESORTS and HITS A NERVE were also very fun. Also, I don’t think I’ve seen 4d [“Drinking vessel for nigori”] SAKE CUP or 46d [“Empathetic phrase”] I FEEL YA very much, making them feel very fresh for this grid.

A few other faves:

  • 23a [“Like a just-picked Zestar”] – Zestar apples look amazing CRISP and tasty, and their mention was one of many food-related words in this puzzle, including 26a [“Moo ___ pancakes”] SHU, OKRA, 6a [“Chamoe or cantaloupe”] MELON, TARO, and FIG 11a [“___ Newtowns”], not to mention TOMATO PLANT.
    66a [“Country with teh world’s oldest capital”] – I didn’t know this about Damascus, in SYRIA.

The child-oriented theme also is a good reminder about Grids for Kids, if you haven’t donated already!

This entry was posted in Daily Puzzles and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

30 Responses to Sunday, February 12, 2023

  1. JohnH says:

    The puzzle made me feel on the wrong wavelength, too, a shame given an interesting theme. Agreed on, say, the due E with the unusual clue for ANI and the unusual spelling EGIS, although surely there the Hebrew would also not be familiar to many.

    But my toughest spot was above that in the NE, with BOPS (where I wasn’t sure I had it right) and DIANA, while I couldn’t have sworn to I FEAR and SAY LESS as idiomatic and matching the clues. Hardly helps that the key to the sector was an arena name new to me, although the clues does its best to give it away. Let’s just say that it’s one of those times when I wanted to like the puzzle and wanted it to be better.

  2. JP says:

    It was a major slog for me.

  3. Rich says:

    The puzzle was a constructors puzzle and not a solvers puzzle. The construction was unique, clever, and cutting corners…er I mean cutting edge. This forced a large dose of nasty tasting medicine in the form of esoterica and abbreviations which like castor oil gags you out. This puzzle was a chore to solve as opposed to being a joy to solve.

  4. Eric H says:

    NYT: I enjoyed much of it, except perhaps when I was trying to make sense of a word that begins SSI-.

    The MAKING ENDS MEET appealed to my inner pre-adolescent, though I understand that some people see that part of the grid as a more graphic anatomical representation than I did.

    I interpreted the STRETCHING A BUCK/SSIINNGGLLEE as a one-dollar bill being stretched.

    The only thing that bothered me about ANI is that I have seen a similar clue before but couldn’t remember the answer.

  5. huda says:

    NYT: I had to cheat in a couple of places, but I still thought it was great fun. I just loved the expressions and the way they were brought to life. The English language paints a picture of human ingenuity in trying to survive on limited resources, and the puzzle captures that imagery. Many points for creativity and playfulness!
    Didn’t know “SAY LESS”. I guess it’s a play on Say No More? But it sounds harsher… Or is it to be taken tongue in cheek?

  6. Jenni says:

    I liked the NYT theme! Muliple aha! moments and a lot of fun stuff to figure out. AcrossLite didn’t translate the shaded squares, so I missed that – I’m traveling so I didn’t get to do it on paper as I usually do. Agree with Nate that the fill was problematic. YOGISM? It didn’t ruin my experience of the puzzle and overall I feel good about it.

  7. sanfranman59 says:

    Uni large-grid Sunday … There’s a lot of good stuff here and I generally enjoyed the solving experience, but the theme seems like a fail to me for the reasons Jim mentions in his review. I’d also have preferred a little more variety in the themers than half of them involving PPER. Maybe the constructors did, but I’d have tried very hard to swap out APPERTAINS for something else since that’s basically an obsolete word these days. Is there a situation where simply ‘pertains’ can’t be used instead.

  8. Karen says:

    NYT: 5 stars from me! Loved the many clever layers and the multiple “aha” moments. Should be an ORCA nominee. The only minor challenge was BOPS in the NE. Also, since I live in Margarita country (NM), we don’t refer to salt as a garnish for a margarita, as a lime is; rather a condiment added for taste. Nonetheless, a great puzzle!

    • Mr. [just a bit] Grumpy says:

      A very nice puzzle. One example of each of four types of common schemes combined into one puzzle with a unifying theme. My only gripe is the NYT’s practice of trying to force you to use their annoying app, since the shaded squares did not transfer into circles in Across Lite the way they usually do, which I suspect is a sneaky bit of coding from the Old Gray Lady. She and Will Shortz should play fair.

      • Karen says:

        I did it in the dead tree edition, (only on Sundays) so perhaps that’s why it seemed easier. During the week, I use Crossword Scraper to do it in Across Lite software, never use the NYT app, it’s terrible.

  9. Doug C says:

    NYT: I guess this was meant to be the Superbowl of Sunday puzzles, but it was literally just too much: foreign words, made-up words, var. spelling, abbr. words, slang, rebuses, circled squares, shaded squares, sports arenas that no longer exist… The approach here seems to have been “throw everything in the pot and see what happens.” That third-grade visual BUTT joke staring out of the center of the grid pretty well sums it up for me, and fails the breakfast test too.

    • Papa John says:

      You said it — one of the most disappointing Sunday puzzles in a long while. I never appreciate having to figure out how to do the puzzle, rather than solve it. The hodge-podge of gimmicks was tiresome. I didn’t catch the “third-grade visual BUTT joke ” until I read the comments. “Good grief, Charlie Brown.”

  10. David L says:

    I’m curious to see if anyone has figured out the WaPo meta. I feel like I’m on the right track but have got stuck for how to proceed.

    • Eric H says:

      I’m stymied by it, too.

      The numbers in the clues for the theme answers would seem to be the logical place to start, but if those numbers refer to the letters in the theme answers, I’m getting nowhere with it.

      The puzzle title includes “picture.” That had me looking up the logos for the teams in the grid, but again that’s gone nowhere.

      My experience with this one was typical of my experiences with Evan Birnholz’s meta puzzles: Filling in the grid was pretty easy (though today’s was harder than some), but figuring out what to do with the meta is beyond me.

      At this point, I don’t really care what the answer is. It’s one of 32 teams in a sport I don’t care about (actually, I assume we can eliminate the seven teams that appear in the grid).

      But I am curious about the process by which one gets to the answer.

      (I’m lousy at meta puzzles. Of the last three I’ve tried to solve, I’ve gotten one.)

      • PJ says:

        The first set of numbers seems to be the number of letters in each word of the teams’ logos. Colts – HORSESHOE. Saints – FLEUR-DE-LIS.

        I haven’t figured out the next step yet.

        • Eric H says:

          Thanks. That makes some sense.

          I tried to read Evan Birnholz’s post about the puzzle solution, but I didn’t feel like creating a WaPo account.

    • David L says:

      I got as far as figuring out that I needed to look at the team logos. First problem was that it wasn’t obvious to me how to describe a couple of them. Is the Texans’ logo BULL or HORN? And the Cowboys’ logo is a LONE STAR, presumably, both of which have 4 letters.

      Then I didn’t know what to do with the second numbers in each clue. For HORSESHOE (9 letters) I took the fourth letter, which is an E. But that doesn’t work when the numbers are (4) and (5).

      That was when I ran out of ideas.

      Now that Matthew has explained it I see how it works, but I agree with him that the second numbers in each clue were more of a distraction than a help.

      • Eric H says:

        I’d describe the Texans’ logo as a bull.

        As I said before, I don’t care a bit about football. But I often see that logo pasted on cars, and I’ve gotta say it’s effective. Simple, colorful, and once you know what it stands for, hard to conflate with any other logo.

      • The second numbers were operating the same way as the first numbers: They were telling you the word length of the key answers that you needed to find.

        And LONE STAR wouldn’t work because then the enumeration for that would have been (4,4).

  11. Dallas says:

    NYT was a serious slog; nearly twice my usual Sunday time. I, too, felt like I wasn’t on the same wavelength for the clues. I liked MAKING ENDS MEET, but not sure it was worth it… not my favorite Sunday. Will have to tackle the Wash Post later to make up for it.

  12. Eric H says:

    WaPo: Thanks, Matthew, for the explanation of the meta. I always forget to see if whatever words the meta turns up (in this case, the team logos) fit as answers to other clues.

  13. Pilgrim says:

    re WaPo: I mentioned this in a comment on Mr. Birnholz’s blog, but I would not have thought the Cleveland Browns’ logo was a helmet. I thought logos are what goes on a helmet, not the helmet itself.

    I got stuck because the Browns’ helmet is “orange” and “ORANGE” (6 letters) works for 95D “__ butter (skin care product ingredient)” (and SHEA has 4 letters). I couldn’t make any sense of the resulting first letters, so I gave up.

    • Copying and pasting what I wrote on that blog:

      The ORANGE/SHEA thing is an unfortunate and unintentional red herring, although if you found the other six correct grid entries, using either thematic order or grid order you should have ended up with REDBIRS — not right, but perhaps close enough for you to spot what the correct phrase was going to be and then backsolve it from there.

      And the Cleveland Browns logo is a helmet. If you look at all the NFL logos, the Browns show a helmet where other teams do not. That’s just their logo.

  14. steve says:

    well, i differ
    to me the best sunday nyt in ages

  15. Seattle Derek says:

    I enjoy EB’s WaPo puzzles, and this one was no different (except for the convoluted slog-of-a-meta).

  16. CrotchetyDoug says:

    WaPo – Kudos to Matthew for persevering through that intricate jungle. Way past my pay grade. Admiration for all of you

  17. Lloyd Miller says:

    If my first Sunday crossword puzzle was February 12, it would be my last. This one was a struggle, and unpleasant at that. The creators put in their two “cents” worth which I did not pick up on, since there weren’t any other similar answers. Egis is arcane, and Bop may be known to younger people who won’t be solving the puzzle. And a minipig? Got it, but didn’t like it. So upon looking at the answers, the across suggest the downs (stretching a buck and SSIINNGGLLEE) Very clever and intelligent. But this was a bit of crossword overkill, and, in my view, infradig.

Comments are closed.