BEQ 6:54 (Eric)
[2.83 avg; 3 ratings] rate it
Fireball 10:24 (Amy)
[2.88 avg; 4 ratings] rate it
LAT tk (Gareth)
[2.75 avg; 4 ratings] rate it
NYT 9:16 (ZDL)
[4.05 avg; 21 ratings] rate it
Universal 6:31 (Eric)
[2.50 avg; 4 ratings] rate it
USA Today 6:18 (Emily)
[2.50 avg; 2 ratings] rate it
WSJ 9:05 (Jim Q)
[3.50 avg; 4 ratings] rate it
Aidan Deshong’s Universal Crossword Puzzle “Bad Actors” — Eric’s Review
Today’s puzzle features a grid with vertical symmetry and four movie-based theme answers:
- 17A [Hunter of “The Hunger Games”] KATNISS EVERDEEN
- 27A [Faith of “The Exorcist”] CATHOLICISM
- 39A [Ivy of “Legally Blonde”] HARVARD
- 51A [Hope of “E.T.”] GETTING HOME
I spent far longer pondering this theme than I did solving the puzzle. I saw a backwards “bad act” — SIN — in KATNISS, but none of the other theme answers held anything similar. I looked at the clues for the theme answers (which are consistently and a bit oddly worded). The KATNISS EVERDEEN clue uses “Hunter,” which made me think of the 1950s movie hunk Tab Hunter (who I misremembered as being fairly incompetent as an actor). But “Faith,” “Ivy” and “Hope” didn’t lead to any second-rate thespians.
I Googled “Hunter Faith Ivy Hope” and found to a 2009 YA novel Faith, Hope, and Ivy June by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor, but that was clearly irrelevant.
I finally gave in and contacted the friendly editors at Universal. David Steinberg’s explanation is that the theme riffs on the common crossword clueing convention whereby a clue like [Harrison of “Star Wars”] leads to the answer FORD. The trick/joke here is two-fold. First, none of the ambiguous words in the clues (Hunter, Faith, etc.) is to be read as a name (though it could be), they’re to be read as regular nouns. Second, none of the answers is an actor’s surname. There are, however, several other straightforward clue/answer pairs of that sort (described below).
The theme works, but I think a different title or some sort of revealer in the grid would have helped me figure it out on my own.
Other stuff:
- 42A [Long of “The Best Man”] NIA More movie trivia.
- 64A [Hoss of “Tar”] NINA And more movie trivia.
- 47A [Met expectations?] OPERAS As in New York’s Metropolitan Opera company, of course. Cute clue.
- 58A [From ancient Scandinavia] NORSE/53D [Telecom giant headquartered in Espoo, Finland] NOKIA I like this pairing.
- 69A [Mr___ (most-subscribed-to YouTuber)] BEAST I’d not heard of this channel, which Wikipedia says features “fast-paced . . . videos built around elaborate challenges and grandiose philanthropic efforts.” From the little I watched of one video, it’s not for me.
- 5D [Gore of “One Night in Miami…”] ELI Movies again.
- 28D [Fiona, for one] OGRE From the animated movie Shrek. I like movies a lot, but by this point, the puzzle seemed a bit heavy on the movie clues. None of the movie answers were gimmes, though I had a pretty good idea about OGRE even without any crosses.
- 37D [California county known for its cabs?] NAPA As in Cabernets, natch.
Peter Gordon’s Fireball crossword, “Baseball Tradse”–Amy’s recap
Aww, it’s a shame Jenni’s on vacation and isn’t blogging this one, because the theme is right up her alley. The revealer is 57a. [White elephant gift exchanges … and a hint to this puzzle’s theme], YANKEE SWAPS. (Note: I bet a lot of us, maybe most?, don’t live somewhere that uses the Yankee swap term.) The theme answers swap letter strings that spell out the last name of a former member of the Yankees:
- 17a. [Feature of modern cars], DMARISSSIST. Pull out Roger MARIS and put in Mariano RIVERA to get driver assist.
- 23a. [Aioli or marinara, often], CALARIVERAAUCE. Trade MARIS and RIVERA the other way to get calamari sauce.
- 36a. [They have excellent returns], SBERRAVESTMENTS. Pull out Yogi BERRA and put in MARTIN (Billy??) for smart investments.
- 48a. [Threat of military force], SAMARTINTTLING. BERRA comes in for saber rattling.
It was tricky to piece the theme answers together sincce there were crazy letter strings to work with. ISSSIST? AAUCE? SBERRA? TINTTLING? Especially where the crossings were borderline hostile. 46d. [Brand of birth control pill], ALESSE? That brand wasn’t around when I was using the pill, and it was taken off the market “for business reasons” at some point, so not a good entry at all. 47d. [“Keep on finishing” sloganeer], MINWAX? It’s a brand of wood stains. I’ve not needed to stain any wood so this was unknown to me.
I liked the theme after I finally grasped what was going on, but overall not a particularly fun solve for me. 3.5 stars from me.
Kareem Ayas’s New York Times crossword — Zachary David Levy’s write-up
Difficulty: Easy (9m16s)

Kareem Ayas’s New York Times crossword, 10/16/25, 1016
Today’s theme: NEAT (How whiskey might be served … with a hint to the answers to the seven starred clues)
- NOT(ice)ABLE
- BEN(ice)TO
- OFF(ice) HOURS
- PR(ice)Y
- SL(ice)R
- APPEND(ice)S
- D(ice)ROLL
Bonus themer — ROCKS OUT (Enjoys oneself uninhibitedly … or a punny title for this puzzle). Though I’ll say, there’s something aesthetically pleasing about a glass of whisky/bourbon/whatever with one of those giant square-shaped ice cubes. Also goes down smoother. Also, nothing about me or my immediate surroundings is NEAT.
Cracking: SET IN STONE, it is written
Slacking: WEND this become an actual word?
Sidetracking: FAUN
Morton J. Mendelson’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Language Barriers” — Jim Q’s write-up
THEME: Phrases (*having to do with ROADs) are interrupted by a pesky black square

WSJ • 10/16/25 • Thur • “Language Barriers” • Morton J. Mendelson • solution • 20251016
THEME ANSWERS:
- 16A [City strays] ALLEY / CATS
- 30A [Hot rod contests] DRAG / RACES \
- 36A [Practical knowledge] STREET / SMARTS
- 46A [Be defensive in traffic, e.g.] DRIVE / SAFE
- 62A [Barricade… or something present in five answers (including this one)] ROAD / BLOCK
*Okay, confession: I didn’t catch the ROAD connection until embarrassingly late in the solve (i.e. just now). I originally thought, “Oh, neat, two-word phrases split by black squares,” even with the ROAD BLOCK revealer, but now that it suddenly clicked, it’s much more satisfying than I first realized.
Really fun concept, and I appreciate how the second words are clued independently rather than with a lazy dash. I’ve never been a huge fan of those “–” clues—they telegraph too much and kill the mystery.
It took me about half the grid before realizing something was up, mostly because I solved the east side first, where everything looks totally normal (since the “split” word sits to the west). I even convinced myself DRAG was a plausible plural for [Hot rod contests]. So when the revealer dropped, it was one of those genuine “Ohhhhhh” moments—exactly what a Thursday should deliver.
OTHER STUFF / HANG-UPS:
- [One part of a temperature oscillation] LA NINA. Until now, I was reading it as LANINA and had no clue what it was. Victim of the lack of a tilde in crosswords, I suppose.
- [Mercurius et Mars, e.g.] DEI. Conspicuously clued as a Latin word rather than the acronym that was, until quite recently, not very controversial.
- [Talk about this, that, or the other] IDLE CHAT. “Talk” being a noun here. Nice deception.
- [It might result in a TD or an int.] ATT. Guessing “attempt”? Football still not my home turf.
- CARLOS Alcaraz- new for me! But I’m sure tennis folks had a gimme here.
- [Opening in a theater] TRAP DOOR. Great clue. Hopefully the cast knows when it’s open. Best onstage use of one: Life of Pi. That “dive” scene? Unreal.
- [Bar candidates?] DRINKS. Cute, but seems like the clue is tying a bit too hard.
Clever and fun Thursday with some playful bite. 4 stars.
Brendan Emmett Quigley’s Crossword #1827 “The Consequences” — Eric’s Review
An new-to-me acronym hints at the two-word theme answers, each of which has a first word beginning with FA- and a second word beginning with FO-:
- 17A [Look to what’s ahead of you] FACE FORWARD
- 25A [DoorDash delivery, often] FAST FOOD
- 37A [Dream team game?] FANTASY FOOTBALL It’s sobering to realize that the original Dream Team — the United States men’s basketball team in the 1992 Olympics, which was the first to feature professional athletes — was half a lifetime ago.
- 48A [Accordion-style pleats] FAN FOLDS
-
59A [What a leaf peeper peeps] FALL FOLIAGE My husband and I drove up to Telluride, Colorado, last week and saw some nice color along the way.
- 1D [Acronym that means foolish actions will lead to negative consequences, and the theme of this puzzle] FAFO Fuck Around and Find Out It’s a parenting style that’s the opposite of helicopter parenting, though there are probably other usages.
I like this simple theme, though it took me a bit to get FACE FORWARD because I hadn’t yet figured out the FA-/FO- pattern. FAN FOLDS is not exactly a common phrase, but the other three are all nice, well-known phrases/compound nouns.
Other stuff of note:
- 5A [Govt. testing site for green policies] EPA LAB Do we still have an Environmental Protection Agency?
- 11A [Brazilian musician Gilberto ___] GIL A pure gimme that makes me miss Horizontes, a weekly radio program I used to listen to in the 1990s on Austin’s NPR affiliate. An hour of Brazilian music and an hour of music from other countries in Latin America. I first heard a lot of good artists on that show.
- 15A [Big name in baseball caps] NEW ERA I don’t remembered where I learned that that company makes all the MLB caps. It doesn’t matter, as the name didn’t stick in my head.
- 68A [It’s almost always right] EAST Cute clue.
- 4D [Gregg specialist, for short] STENOG When I worked in an office supply store in the mid 1980s, we sold both Pitman and Gregg shorthand pads. I never really knew the difference, but I figured that anyone who ordered steno pads knew which kind they wanted.
- 12D [Bruneau Dunes State Park state] IDAHO I’d never heard of that park, but IDAHO seemed a likely answer even without the I from GIL.
- 13D [Like brains and leaves] LOBED “Some leaves” would be better, no?
- 24D [Slightly drunk] TIPSY Such a nice feeling. Too bad it’s so easy to take it too far.
- 25D [Unauthorized stories of well-known characters] FAN FICS I could do without the S here.
- 31D [Establishment with a TouchTunes machine, maybe] BAR I’ve never heard of a “TouchTunes machine,” but this was an easy guess.
- 32D [Childish and inexperienced] SNOT-NOSED To me, SNOT-NOSED connotes brattiness more than inexperience.
- 35D [Cheer during El Clásico] OLÉ You don’t need to have heard of the rivalry between the Spanish soccer teams Barcelona and Real Madrid to be able to guess this.
- 45D [1996 Beck album with a nonsense title] ODELAY A gimme.
- 49D [2025 Best Picture winner] ANORA I needed the first A to remember that title.
John McClung’s USA Today Crossword, “It’s a Setup” — Emily’s write-up
Watch out!

USA Today, October 16, 2025, “It’s a Setup” by John McClung
Theme: each downs themer contains –TES– (aka “set” going up)
Themers:
- 4d. [Ocean predator with around 300 teeth], GREATWHITESHARK
- 10d. [Gooey sundae topping], CHOCOLATESYRUP
- 17d. [Vessels with cannons in a Disneyland water ride], PIRATESHIPS
Today’s themer set almost reminds me of a day at an amusement park with a GREATWHITESHARK, CHOCOLATESYRUP, and PIRATESHIPS. As it was in the downs, all were filled in for me by the time I got to them, as I always solve acrosses first and everything filled in easily for me today.
Favorite fill: VAMPIRE, ATBAY, and FIASCO
Stumpers: SOYOUSAY (needed crossings), BUNGLES (only “messes up”, “ruins”, and “fails at” came to mind), and SPOTON (kept thinking of terms related to grading such as “aced it” or “passed”)
A super smooth, quick solve for me today. How’d you all do? The cluing overall just clicked and the majority of acrosses filled in for me on the first pass. Not quite my fastest time but certainly one of them. Fun fill and I enjoyed the grid design.
4.25 stars
~Emily




Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 4.5 stars
Smooth, neat, lovely- puzzle.
Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 4 stars
Good stuff today. I mentioned the other day that I don’t mind if answers in grids like this end up being gibberish, but it certainly does help the solve when they’re not. Also ABSCOND is just a fun word.
I wonder if the constructor has heard that “Too Sweet” song by Hozier as many times as I have lately. Mostly against my will, I might add.
Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 4.5 stars
NYT 4.5 stars. went down like a smooth shot.
just a pleasure
I entered all of the ICE words and ended up with 7 mistakes! Oh well…
NYT: I enjoyed the puzzle and the theme. My only tiny quibble is that I believe APPENDS and APPENDICES have a similar etymology, which is not ideal for this type of puzzle. But that’s a small nit. The overall puzzle is great!
Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 5 stars
I was going to say “doesn’t NOTABLE mean the same thing as NOTICEABLE” but upon checking the dictionary, they do have some subtle difference. Good job concealing the theme there.
WEND/READE and PANKO/CANASTA are two bad crosses but otherwise the grid is light on names. Well done!
I had the same thought on NOTABLE. Had filled in NEAT and was confused. “Well I see the letters of NEAT in NOTABLE, but how is that a theme’?? Then it sunk in.
Fine Thursday puzzle!!
Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 4 stars
I came here to see if any other people had this thought. It was the very last word I solved for in the puzzle even though I thought it was heading for ‘notable’ earlier, but I was sure it couldn’t be that because where was the ice taken from!
I think of NOTABLE as having a connotation of being remarkable, and NOTICEABLE is more that something is visible to the eye. So the clue of “conspicuous” is a better fit for NOTICEABLE IMO, although if this had been a themeless, I would have filled in NOTABLE without a second thought and moved to the next clue. As you say, the difference is fairly subtle.
Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 4.5 stars
Very good puzzle. It’s one of those that you admire even more after you finish solving, and also makes you go “wait, this wasn’t done before?” Smooth execution with some Thursday-level tricky clues as well.
NYT: Huh! I find myself in the minority again – like a couple of weeks ago when folks here raved about the “Minesweeper” puzzle. I thought this was a perfectly fine Thursday puzzle. The theme made itself clear well before I ran into the revealer – and that helped with the rest of the solve. Fill was solid. But 4.5- and 5-star ratings? Feels like grade inflation to me.
I’m with you in the minority. I have to think that a lot of the high scores are for the “no ice” message, which says more about the times we’re living through than about the puzzle itself. I don’t disagree with that sentiment, but I also didn’t think the puzzle offered much challenge for a Thursday. I found this considerably easier than yesterday’s puzzle.
NOTABLE/NOTiceABLE fit the clue either way, so that was a rather week theme entry. BOOR and “brute” are not the same thing in my book. DRE, IVES, LEO, HEGEL, and READE for names. Does anyone still read READE? I give this puzzle a solid 3.0, and hope for a more challenging Thursday come next week.
Cute NYT, but I have one small peeve. There seems to be a trend of cluing BOSS a lot lately with reference to video games. I recognize the connection, having seen it so often, but I have no idea what it means. There are plenty of other ways to clue BOSS, surely, and some variation would be welcome.
Fireball: gibberish answers requiring knowledge of sportball player names I’m not super familiar with, and a revealer including a phrase I’ve never heard of, making the “swap player names to remove gibberish” instruction basically invisible (especially with the 2 weird down entries obscuring the SW in “swap” — “what on earth is a YANKEE XXAP?!”). Definitely a frustrating solve.
Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 4 stars
I liked today’s NYT. As someone on Rex’s blog pointed out “Abolish ICE” was also there for the taking.
This puzzle also shows that the old crossword rule about dupes is less important than the enjoyment of puzzle overall. “IN” not only shows up three times (trips instead of dupes?) but actually crosses ASKIN / INHD.
Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 5 stars
NYT: What a timely puzzle. No ICE. I love it
“No ICE.”
I love it.
I have no use for The Donald’s version of ICE. I’m all in favor of legal immigration – we need it! But we also need to control our borders.
Puzzle: WSJ; Rating: 4 stars
Why doesn’t the link to the WSJ puzzle work today (10/16/2025)? Is it just me? And while I am asking, why is there never a link to the WSJ puzzle on Fridays? Giving it a 4 so it doesn’t bring the average down too much, but I haven’t been able to get the link to work which is the reason for my post.
If by “link to the WSJ” you meant the jump link that takes you to the review, a bit of coding was left out (which is easy to do). It’s fixed now. (If you meant the link to the puzzle itself, that’s not something I know how to fix.)
There’s never a review of the Friday WSJ puzzle until the contest closes on Sunday night.
Boo to WSJ’s new number puzzles.
BEQ: Also FAb FOur
Good catch! I saw that when I was solving, but didn’t connect it to the theme.
Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 4 stars
Now here is a puzzle that was more difficult for me than usual but that I think was pretty great! My brain could not figure out ICE was what was being removed even though in retrospect it’s plainly obvious. I first tried ROCK then started thinking about various types of rocks. Way overthought it!