LAT untimed (pannonica)
[3.00 avg; 4 ratings] rate it
NYT 6:58 (Amy)
[3.89 avg; 18 ratings] rate it
Universal 6:46 (Jim P)
[3.50 avg; 5 ratings] rate it
USA Today tk (Emily)
[4.00 avg; 1 rating] rate it
Joyce Keller’s New York Times Crossword — Amy’s recap
There’s an ACPT guideline of “check your crossings. I did check the crossings for what looked like RESTIAN BAR, but I neglected to check the crossings’ crossings. D’oh! 1d [Completely convinced] isn’t SURE, it’s SOLD. Yes, ERE is a legit answer, but not when the clue is 19A. [“Black-ish” patriarch], DRE. I do love the clue for LESBIAN BAR, [She’s out there!]. That section also slowed me down where UH PUHLEEZE sat in place of OH PUHLEASE. I also hid 54a. [Apt ryhme for “pads”] (ADDS) by viewing 44d. [Tip] as a verb, LEAN, rather than the detective’s noun, LEAD, and then the 49D. [Texter’s “ciao”] is CYA? I had CYL as a “see ya later” thing; not sure I’ve see a 3-letter text abbreviation where “you” becomes the 2-letter YA. CUL and CYL are both used for “see you later, as is CYA, apparently (just “see ya”), but I know that one much better as a non-texter’s “cover your ass.” These areas probably ate up a good 3 minutes of my nearly 7-minute solve.
Fave fill: CREATIVITY, BEDROOM EYES, PRESS-ON NAILS, CPARE CHANGE, MILESTONES.
I questioned whether the CIARA clue, [Grammy-winning R&B singer named for a Revlon fragrance], was for real. It’s mentioned in her Wikipedia page with a link to a fashion magazine story about her becoming a Revlon spokeperson.
Anyone else try TONSIL instead of TONGUE, [Mouth organ]? What are the odds that a small part of the body would have two different 6-letter organs?
Four stars from me.
Jeff Stillman’s Los Angeles Times crossword — pannonica’s write-up

LAT • 1/23/26 • Fri • Stillman • solution • 20260123
Today we’re adding a B-sound to the ends of familiar phrases to wacky effect and adjusting the spelling as necessary.
- 20a. [Add to one’s ear piercings?] HIT A NEW LOBE (hit a new low). This is fine technically, but I’m not completely convinced it makes sense practically. Perhaps we’re considering the tragus and antitragus as mini-lobes? Or are we reading this from the perspective of a professional ear-piercer, who may have performed this service on countless lobes belonging to other people?
- 27a. [“There’s nothing like the feeling of posting a vlog!”?] I LOVE YOUTUBE (I love you, too).
- 46a. [Trio trying to sneak past the guard at a sauna] THREE IN A ROBE (three in a row). A variation on the old three-in-a-trenchcoat trope.
- 55a. [“Get your own die, pal!”?] THAT’S MY CUBE (that’s my cue).
(28d [Two-finger sign] VEE.)
Should I rate it a B-plus?
- 4d [Motivation for seeking counsel] LEGAL ISSUES. Seems borderline greenpainty?
- 5d [“Heaven forbid!”] HOPE NOT.
- 8d [Comics canine] SNOOPY. With the first two letters in place I was all set to put in SNERT but quickly realized it didn’t have enough letters.
- 10d [Peach or plum] HUE. Mild misdirection.
- 12d [“The King and I” setting] SIAM. 39a [“The King and I” role] ANNA.
- 26d [Seafood dish that turns from blue to orange during preparation] STEAMED CRABS. East Coast blue crabs, I would imagine.
- 31d [Out of shape] BENT. Does that make “bent out of shape” redundant? I don’t think so.
- 34d [Fragrance] ODOR. Thank you!
- 44d [Period of invincibility in video games] GOD MODE. Possibly somewhat obscure? Also, I think of GOD MODE being more of a cheat that’s enabled rather than a fleeting (?) period.
- 51d [Online cash-back offer] EBATE. Stands to reason that this is legit with all the other e-formations out there, but I’ve never encountered it.
- 53d [Wagon part] AXLE. Okay, sure.
- 15a [Bread maker] OVEN. Okay, sure.
- 18a [Mallet game] POLO.
- 25a [Seed cases] PODS. In my lexicon, seedcase is a compound word.
- 65a [Utah home of Sugarloaf Mountain] ALTA. Not the one in Brazil.
- 67a [“Holy moly!”] YIPE. I use this, but am a little surprised it’s legit enough for a primetime crossword.
- 68a [Existed] BEEN. Feels glancingly apt as a final entry in this B-laden affair!
*I believe seven embeds is a record for me on a daily 15×15 crossword write-up.
Howard Neuthaler’s Universal crossword, “Grid Over Troubled Water”—Jim P’s review
Theme: Circled vertical words spell out types of sharks. The crossing word at the top letter of each shark is clued while replacing the shark’s first letter with the one letter above it. The revealer is JUMPING THE SHARK (38a, [Reaching a point of decline, in TV lingo … or the key to interpreting 17-, 25-, 51- and 53-Across]). The crossing entry using the first letter in the shark is still a valid (though unclued) crossword entry.
- 17a. [*Polynesian country] SAM(O)A jumping a BLUE shark from 4d “GO BLUE!”
- 25a. [*Lets go] FI(R)ES jumping a NURSE shark from 19d OR NURSE.
- 51a. [*Turn to mush] PUR(E)E jumping a SAND shark from 45d “YES AND“.
- 53a. [*Swallows] E(A)TS jumping a MAKO shark from 46d BAMAKO.
Fun theme, well executed. As it should be, I was a little befuddled for a while until the penny dropped and I enjoyed my aha moment. The “jumping” letters spell out OREA which isn’t anything unfortunately. It would’ve been cool if the spelled out FONZ or something.
I will pick some nits though. Both SAND and MAKO are hidden in their respective entries while BLUE and NURSE are not. I would’ve liked more consistency there. That bottom right corner was tough with BAMAKO [Mali’s capital] probably not in most people’s wheelhouse and with crossing BAND clued opaquely [Stripe], EMTS not clued at all, and AKITA clued via trivia [Helen Keller described hers as “an angel in fur”]. It was all gettable but a good deal tougher than any other section of the grid.
In the fill, I enjoyed POOH-POOH, CELLO CASE, SIR PAUL, and AUTO LOANS. There are a fair amount of “cheater” squares as well as crosswordese (UM NO, I KID, NENA, NO MSG), and IN LEFT [Where Fenway Park’s Green Monster looms large] is kind of a stinker. So…hits and misses in the fill.
Clue of note: 34d. [Demonstrated sound judgment?]. TSKED. This clue is doing a lot of work, but on the whole it gave me a smile.
3.5 stars from me.
In case you were wondering about the origin of JUMPING THE SHARK, here’s the inanity that started it all:


Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 4 stars
NYT: No mention of the clue for 29A? It’s only January 23 but that has to be on the Best Clue Orca shortlist.
Made pretty much all the same mistakes as Amy in the NYT, took me a lot longer than seven minutes to make those mistakes. Good puzzle, in retrospect.
Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 3.5 stars
Speaking of cluing: It took me so long to figure out why ADDS is apt as a rhyme for Pads. I kept think of either apartments or walking a certain way…
I had all the same mistakes up top, plus GREY before GRAY. But I was luckier down in the south. So I finished in 2X Amy’s time – which I use as a benchmark for a stellar solve.
I wasn’t fond of AS A TREAT as an entry, but lots of good clues in this one.
Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 4 stars
In addition to the rest, I managed to have RUB and not NUB, making SCANT basically invisible to me.
+1. Keller is one of the best cluers in the game right now
Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 4.5 stars
As a gay woman, I sometimes think that gay-related clues can be somewhat gratuitous. But I loved the cluing and use of lesbian bar.
NYT: the LESBIANBAR clue took me a while to figure out, but it was a good one.
The CIARA/FREE got me. Had ‘L’ in there. Though the perp was FLEEing the joint. Never heard of the fragrance.
Solid puzzle!
I had NUT instead of NUB for “Essence of the matter,” and it took me a very long time to figure out what LESTIANBAR was supposed to be. I knew it was wrong, but all of the down answers seemed correct.
Same!! I could not figure out what “lestianbar” was!!
NYT was good. The only trouble spot for me was the SW corner. 48A was obviously COSY, I had trouble coming up with CIARA, and the clue for FREE was far from obvious. Took a while to sort all that out.
Since I don’t eat icecream, I would look ASKANCE at a hot fudge sundae, but that’s just me.
Puzzle: NYT; Rating: 4.5 stars
Much of the cluing in this one earned 4 stars, but 17A was just delightful enough to boost it to 4.5 stars. Fun puzzle!
NYT 28d [Peach or plum] HUE
LAT 10d [Peach or plum] HUE
I ran into the same difficulties as Amy and the comments, although I got GRAY correct quickly, banking on preferred American spelling. My last to fall, though was the NE, since I didn’t know PICO in that sense, was slow to think of PREEN ordinary in bird terms, and tried “eight” for OCTET at first. Nice traps throughout.
I had EIGHT too, and eventually took it out to drop in SMOG and get the rest of the NW corner. Reasonably tricky; I had THAT ONES ON ME which slowed me down till I took out THAT to fix it.
I use CYA all the time in text-based chat, so that one didn’t seem odd to me. Fun Friday—landed one second over my average.
Puzzle: Universal; Rating: 5 stars
I had some vague idea of what the theme was about, but the penny didn’t drop for me until I read Jim’s review – thanks, Jim!
Pretty complex theme, so I’m willing to forgive the nits Jim mentioned. ;)