Alex Eaton-Salners’s New York Times crossword—Andy’s review
Alex has been busy! He has today’s Fireball puzzle and the New York Times puzzle.
Today’s puzzle has two revealers, stacked on top of each other in the southwest corner:
- 69a, (IN)BOX [Where work piles up … with a hint to this puzzle’s theme].
- 72a, (OUT)BOX [Where finished work goes … with a hint to this puzzle’s theme].
In fact, the four longest entries in this puzzle contain an IN rebus square (an IN box, if you will), followed by an OUT rebus square (an OUT box):
- 18a, CARP(IN)G AB(OUT) [Finding fault with]. Crossing:
- 9d, ER(IN) [“Dancing With the Stars” co-host Andrews], and:
- 12d, ST(OUT)ISH [Somewhat stocky].
- 30a, THE FOUNTA(IN) OF Y(OUT)H [Goal for Ponce de León]. Crossing:
- 33d, (IN)TENTLY [One way to stare], and:
- 11d, CUB SC(OUT) [One in a blue-and-yellow uniform].
- 47a, FROTH(IN)G AT THE M(OUT)H [Incensed]. I’ve heard “foaming at the mouth” more often than FROTHING AT THE MOUTH, but it’s got dictionary support. Crossing:
- 21d, YOU AGA(IN) [Question to a returning pest], and:
- 42d, SN(OUT)S [Features of tapirs].
- 60a, RA(IN)BOW TR(OUT) [Colorful food fish]. Crossing:
- 49d, ONE (IN)CH [Three barleycorns, as defined by Edward II], and:
- 62d, (OUT)RÉ [Weird].
This one came together relatively quickly for me, but it still has that nice layered aha of “Oh, this is an IN rebus!” and then “Oh, it’s an IN and OUT rebus!”. Elegant to always have the IN box come first, then the OUT box, and also elegant to have the two revealers stacked on top of each other (even if it produced the ugly LXX [70, in old Rome]).
I really liked seeing YOU AGAIN?, MAITRE D’, and KEFIR. Elsewise, there was an unusual amount of ugly fill by AES’s standards in this one, which I found distracting: there was URSI on LLCS, ETRE in the NE to facilitate the Q/Z/J up there, OST, the aforementioned LXX. Very strange to have the bad partial KEMO crossing MIME when KENO/MINE (or even KETO diet / MITE) would’ve been a big improvement. Not sure why that happened.
Solid Thursday offering. Until next time!
Alex Eaton-Salners’s Fireball crossword “Cue the Finale” —Jenni’s write-up
It’s September! Better than pumpkin spice: the Fireball Crossword is back. (I know it was back last week, but the contests are Laura’s jam).
This one felt like it took even longer than the digitally alliterative time posted. Once I figured out the theme, it fell a bit faster but there were a couple of clues that completely foxed me.
The grid is 15×18 with an arrangement that seems unusual to me. I don’t think it makes a picture. Does it?
First the theme: Take a word or phrase that ends in E. Find word or name ending in Q that can substitute for the E in a punny way. Clue accordingly.
- 17a [Answer to the question “Which brand of rum are we out of?”?] is WHAT’S DONE IS DON Q, from the base phrase “what’s done is done.” This would have been easier if I’d ever heard of DON Q. Nice touch: the crossing Q word is LIQUOR.
- 24d [Pluck out a root beer formulator’s eyebrow hairs?] is THREAD BARQ, from “threadbare.” I got THREAD right away and kept trying to get “A AND W” in there somewhere.
- 26d [Person with a J.D. in the Mekong Delta?] is VIETNAM ESQ, from “Vietnamese.”
- 45d [Actor La Salle after being made a general?] is BRASS ERIQ from “brasserie.” This time I knew the actor but could not figure out the base word for a looong time. I kept trying to see “brass ring” but when I finally figured out the Q for E swap, the light dawned.
- 46d [Alluring London mayor Khan?] is SEXY SADIQ from “Sexy Sadie.” Not to be confused with “Sadie, Sadie, Married Lady.”
- 70a [Sizing up “Party of Five” actress Paula?] is MEASURING DEVICQ from “measuring device.” Never watched the show, never heard of the actor. (Many women prefer “actor” and I use it by default unless the performer herself chooses the word “actress.”) My unfamiliarity with the names in the two 15-letter entries made for long, hard solve.
It was worth it, though. This is one of those puzzles that is both a feat of construction (all those Qs!) and a lot of fun to solve. Some of the crossing Q words are crosswordese or roll-your-own (I’m looking at you, ET SEQ and QUOS) and I really don’t care. This is an ORCA contender.
A few other things:
- 1d [Rapper with the album “Unleashed”] is BOW WOW. He dropped the “l’il.” His given name could give us another clue for “shad.”
- I’m not sure if ANODE crossing ANION counts as an etymological dupe. It surprised me.
- The last answer I filled in was 11d [Major in June]. I kept thinking it was a college major or an army major, neither of which made any sense. It’s a golf major: the US OPEN. Duh.
- 39d [Looks] stopped me because it’s not a verb. It’s a noun: MIENS.
- 74a [Unicycle on the highway?] is a SIDECAR. I don’t fully understand it, and it made me laugh anyway.
What I didn’t know before I did this puzzle: I am ashamed to admit that I did not know the Belmont Stakes are held in ELMONT, NY. I also didn’t know that INITECH is the name of the company in “Office Space.”
Frank Virzi’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Look Out Below!” — Jim’s review
Whew! That was a workout. I could not sort this one out for a long time. It didn’t help that I had the entire northwest of the grid filled in without even a whiff of what the theme might be (because there isn’t anything thematic in that corner, except for POL which I thought just had a bad clue). I had huge gaps of white space all over the place due to the theme, tough cluing, and some rough fill. Finally, I stared DIAL TONES into submission at 8d, and that broke open that corner and led to the theme answer at 18a.
The theme is LANDSLIDE (19d, [Decisive victory, and any of four features of this puzzle]). Each of the four main theme answers ends with -LAND, but those letters slide down and to the right.
18a [Out to lunch] IN LA LA LAND
- 27a [Its national anthem is “Mazurek Dbrowskiego”] POLAND. I really should have figured it out with this entry. But I thought the clue was just missing an “Abbr.” or similar.
- 45a [Cork setting] IRELAND. This one was evil because we’ve all filled in EIRE or ERIN for IRELAND in countless puzzles, and the four squares allotted to this answer seemed to want one of those two words.
- 54a [Sticks] HIINTERLAND. Love this word, but for a while, this entry looked like HIsToRy, though it didn’t make sense with the clue.
This was a wonderful theme that made completing this grid a good challenge, just what you want toward the end of the week. My a-ha moment was long-delayed but very satisfying. My only gripe with the theme is the inconsistency in having two countries, and two non-countries. But at least they are sort-of symmetrical in the grid.
A few things take away from the fun though, things like the crossing of uncommon proper names (in foreign languages no less) and a healthy dose of crosswordese. No doubt filling this grid was a challenge because of all the triple-checked squares.
First off is that central-west section where SWANN [“In Search of Lost Time” character] crosses WIEN [Capital on the Danube, to natives]. I don’t know the character nor the book, and I should know which capital is on the Danube, but, well, I just don’t. Plus, RUGGED fits the clue for RIGGED [Not fair, in a way], and ANIL [Dye-yielding shrub] hasn’t managed to find its place in my little gray cells just yet. (Is it ARIL? AROL? ANOL? Something else?)
Elsewhere, EDDS [TV’s Hall and Byrnes] is unfortunate fill, and the clue for ANS [Age units, in Arles] meant that I’m supposed to know that “an” is French for year. (I don’t.) I’d much rather have ODDS at 26d (giving TAKO a 23a which is [Octopus, at a sushi restaurant]) and a clue for ANS indicating that it was the abbreviation for “answer.”
But I’m starting to nitpick. In the end, once you include the sparkly long fill answers of DIAL TONES, ANGEL HAIR, PIT-A-PAT, and CANASTA, and the challenge of the theme itself, you can count this one in the win column. 3.7 stars from me.
Brendan Emmett Quigley’s website crossword – “Up for Debate” — Ben’s Review
I liked the theme on this week’s BEQ:
- 17A: Debate #1: Which characters should I use when answering “Sex:” on a questionnaire? — F OR M LETTERS
- 24A: Debate #2: What are the plot inconsistencies missed by Oliver Stone and Fritz Lang? — W OR M HOLES
- 33A: Debate #3: How should I say this keyboard costs $1000? — K OR G SYNTHESIZER
- 47A: Debate #4: What’s the value of an answer to a 50/50 question? — F OR T WORTH
- 54A: Debate #5: Which lowish grade should I drop from report cards? — C OR D CUTTING
Playing with the OR in the middle of FORM, WORM, KORG, FORT, and CORD makes for some fun here.
Other fill notes:
- I don’t know what “Adularescent” means but I figured it’s something that applies to OPALs.
- This was the second reference to The FAR SIDE I’ve seen recently in crosswords
- PROSPERO was a nice bit of fill. I recently read Margaret Atwood’s Hag-Seed, which re-interprets The Tempest in a fun way
- I liked that the clue for Marisa TOMEI mentioned her recent role in the latest Purge movie, but I would’ve known it was her more quickly if it mentioned her role as Aunt May in the latest Spiderman movies
- ONATOOT? ON A TOOT? I don’t get that one for “Getting blitzed”.
Joe Deeney’s LA Times crossword – Gareth’s review
A bit of a stealth theme today. At first, I noticed the repeated TTER letters, but then CIGARETTEBURN showed up and put a spoke in the works. Turns out it’s the old “scrambled letters spanned across two parts of a word” trick. The letters are BUTTER, as explained in the cryptic-style revealer BUTTERCHURN. You have to CHURN the letters in BUTTER.
- [Rolls off the alley], GUTTERBALLS. The clueing is peculiar. Either GUTTERBALLS is clued as a verb here, or Rolls is used as a noun. I think it’s trying to be clever, but the clue is just jarring either way.
- [Open event gold medalist in the 2016 Chess Olympiad] is a really long way to go to get to USA!
- [Window-switching keyboard shortcut], ALTTAB. I use this all the time. It’s very handy. If at least one person who didn’t know about it discovers its utility, this clue has done its job!