Michael Paleos’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Damn Crooked”—Jim P’s review
Looking at the circles in the blank grid, one can see that they sort of flow from upper left to lower right. So I was primed to be looking for a word or phrase that would run through the circled letters. And I was right. Each grouping is a euphemism for “Hell,” as revealed to us by 58a HELL BENT clued [Totally determined, and a literal description of this puzzle’s circled letters].
- Starting in 15a: LAKE OF FIRE. I don’t think I’ve ever encountered this phrase. Wikipedia tells me it appears in Egyptian and Christian religions as well as in Plato’s writings.
- Starting in 20a: UNDERWORLD. Not really knowing the first one and then encountering this one, I thought the theme might be about gangsters and the mob. Bzzt!
- Starting in 51a: INFERNO
- Starting in 58a: HADES, sharing the H with the theme revealer.
Nicely done. I like that each of the entries shares letters with some really nice fill like FACE-OFFS, UNDEAD, TIGER WOODS, HEADLESS, and SKINFLINTS. And the HEADLESS/UNDEAD/SEANCE collection makes for deliciously grim fare. This would have been a good one to save for Halloween.
But wait, there’s more: “I’M RUINED!” and “I CONCEDE” make a good matching set. And there’s also DR. RUTH and TED TALKS. Pretty DARN GOOD.
I will pick one nit, and that’s the crossing of GAIA and NIA. Checking the Cruciverb database, GAEA with an E outpaces GAIA with an I, two to one. (And I think I just saw it within the past week, but don’t ask me where.) So it’s reasonable to assume an E here. Crossing that with a character name [Nicole Maines’s “Supergirl” role] from a TV show (no idea if the character is major or not or how popular the show is), touches on the unfair. Granted, NIA is more of a name than NEA, but GAEA is more common than GAIA. Guess which direction I went. Also, I could do without CBGB which I only know from crosswords. That little section could be quickly fixed with CBER, which isn’t great, I know, but it’s better than CBGB (in my opinion).
Clues of note:
- 26a. [Champagne pop]. PERE. French for “father.”
- 45a. [Farriers’ tools]. RASPS. Why was I thinking “croupier” when I read this clue? Thus I put in RAKES, and the R gave me RASHAD and unlocked that corner. It’s nice when an error coincidentally helps you out.
- 57a. [Medium effort?]. SEANCE. Nice clue.
Enjoyable theme and plenty of juicy fill. 3.9 stars.
Peter Gordon’s Fireball Crossword, “Themeless 139”–Jenni’s write-up
And we’re back to our regularly scheduled male Fireball programming.
There were some fresh entries in this themeless. It was not blazingly hard. I couldn’t even have toasted a marshmallow over it. My husband and daughter made homemade marshmallows yesterday and OMG the deliciousness.
Back to crosswords. I enjoyed seeing KEN SALAZAR in the grid. I also loved HAVE KITTENS, partly because one of my friends told me his family has been playing “Exploding Kittens” during quarantine and loving it. The symmetrical answers, HUSH PUPPIES and NOODLERONI, were also fun.
Could have done without STORM FRONT. It’s clued as [Weather forecast line], which is of course entirely accurate. It’s also a white supremacy group and right now seems like a bad time to have that entry in a puzzle without acknowledging the association. Indie crosswords don’t have to worry about a “breakfast test.” They don’t have to abide by anyone’s ideas about where opinions belong and where they don’t. Indie crosswords can have an editorial position on issues of the day (see, for example, Queer Qrossowrds, the Inkubator and the AVCX, as well as Ross Trudeau’s Rosswords, and a bunch I’m missing). The world is burning. Black Americans are being murdered in our streets. Take a stand.
What I didn’t know before I did this puzzle: never heard of LUSAKA (it’s the capital of Zambia). Did not know that ODENSE is the largest city on the Danish island Fyn (didn’t actually know it was on the island of Fyn at all). Did not know that CUMULUS was Latin for “heap.” Also had not heard that J Lo’s daughter is named EMME.
Peter A. Collins’ New York Times crossword—Ben’s review
After two weeks of underwhelming themes, today’s NYT felt like a step back in the direction of what I look for in a Thursday NYT:
- 20A/22A: [M]id-20th-century giant in 59/62A — FRANK SINATRA/ELVIS PRESLEY
- 41A: Hit for 20/22A (1969 or 1977) — MY WAY
- 59A/62A — POPULAR/MUSIC
Both FRANK SINATRA and ELVIS PRESLEY need to be filled into 20A/22A for the down crossings to make sense – the print grid even has slashes in these squares to make that clear. While both artists released versions of “MY WAY” over the course of their respective careers, but I’m not sure that fact is really notable or crossword themeworthy, especially when the theme is rounded out by the stiff-seeming POPULAR MUSIC across 59/62A. There’s a lack of balance to the way this theme is laid out, though I feel like I’d be more forgiving if the theme felt more interesting to me.
“My Way” is based on the French song “Comme d’Habitude”, written by Jacque Revaux and performed by Claude François. Its eventual English lyrics were written by frequent crosswordese Paul ANKA and have nothing to do with the original French lyrics.
Elsewhere in the grid, given the double-letter squares you’ll need to remember the last name of swimmer Gertrude EDERLE, the first woman to receive her own ticker tape parade in 1926, cake mix brand Duncan HINES, and that SATAY SAUCE is a Thai dip.
Be well, all!
Steven Atwood’s Universal crossword — “A-cue-stick”
THEME: “Ooo” sounds are switched to “You” sounds in common phrases to create wackiness.
- 16A [Dr. Seuss book about synesthesia?] HORTON HEARS A HUE. HUE instead of WHO. “Synesthesia” is a new word for me. I would’ve preferred a more familiar term in the clue for the first theme.
- 24A [Trial venue for long-running disputes?] FEUD COURT. Not FOOD COURT.
- 49A [Alcohol content of gasoline?] FUEL PROOF. Instead of FOOL PROOF.
- 63A [“This Donald Duck nephew has been on-screen too long!”?] THAT’S A LOT OF HUEY. HUEY instead of HOOEY.
While I suppose HOOEY in 63A and HUE in 16A are not complete dupes, the sound that’s being changed is exactly the same, which I consider inelegant when it comes to themers. In general I wasn’t a big fan of this one. After grimacing at the fill in the north, I was looking forward to uncovering the grid-spanning theme up there, but the vocabulary in the clue for 16A took the enjoyment of that away.
Still, the fill! REFI, STU, ELAN, HRS, ENDOR, DEL, SHHH (?!?!?!), ELAL, FARAD and that’s just the north! Even normal stuff like OTTO found a way to feel stiff with [Director Preminger] as its clue. But really, the list goes on: SEC, ORD CUKE, ELIS, IOTAS, EIEIO, URALS… etc. It’s a crosswordese feast. I always try to solve the Universal from a new solver’s perspective. Unfortunately, if I were new to puzzles I would find this one to be a turn-off. Even the title was a bit stiff and difficult to interpret (“A-cue-stick” sounds like “Acoustic”).
On a positive note, the phrase THAT’S A LOT OF HOOEY, while dated, is fun to say, and the alteration with that ridiculous clue is amusing.
Overall though, not my favorite.
Paul Coulter’s LA Times Crossword – Gareth’s theme summary
Paul Coulter’s puzzle features five idioms meaning, broadly, to fail: FLAMEOUT, DROPTHEBALL, TAKEITONTHECHIN, MISSTHEBOAT and FALLFLAT. They are applied to specific situations where they are apt. In some cases, the idiomatic expression comes from that very situation, and in those cases the result is less effective.
“After two weeks of underwhelming themes, today’s NYT felt like a step back in the direction of what I look for in a Thursday NYT:”
Funnest puzzle I’ve done in a good while.
I loved it! Fun.
I got FRANK SINATRA very quickly. I finished the puzzle but thought it was odd that the added letters made no sense going across. I didn’t see ELVIS PRESLEY at all until looking here. Now I like this puzzle very much!
I would have been very annoyed if I’d done the print version with the slashes. Most of the fun for me was figuring out the Schrodinger squares. I didn’t know Elvis recorded “My Way” and enjoyed learning it. Very nice puzzle!
The slashes didn’t make it totally obvious that they were only Schrodinger squares going across but not down, but slashes (or the note from the NYT site saying that slashes should be there) definitely made it a quicker solve. I am surprised at how rarely the NYT, even on Thursdays or Sundays, has the courage to publish puzzles with a totally unmarked twist.
Both MW11C and RHUD have GAEA for the Titan and GAIA for the quasi-scientific hypothesis that models the planet as an organism. By that measure, the WSJ clue is simply wrong. But having see the Gaia hypothesis often enough, I entered that spelling right away, which was lucky as I hadn’t heard of NIA.
I enjoyed the theme. It wasn’t until near the end that I got the revealer, which was smile worthy.
OMG, that song , “Comme d’habitude”, is hilarious! I had no idea there was a French origin to My Way, and the topic is so different it feels mind boggling, somehow. Not to mention extremely cheesy. I’m still smiling about it. Thank you, Ben!
Yeah, did the puzzle with Frank Sinatra, understood there was a trick to the missing letters, thought I should figure it out, and came here instead. Very Clever.
And yay for ANN Arbor!
ODENSE x MEDE in the Fireball puzzle is maybe the worst crossing ever. If you’ve never heard of either, the D could be just about anything.
How can we refer to “My Way” without mentioning the parodies, the most famous and perhaps first being https://www.copticdadandmom.com/their-way-my-way-education-parody/. Others can easily be found by googling.
I think I would have had an easier time with the NYT if the rebus function in the app allowed for verticality because it was awkward as hell entering FERLAVNIKS and SPIRNEASTLREAY into those spaces. Yikes.
I’m glad I came across your post when I frustratedly googled “ to rebus or not to rebus”. I just recently (during stay at home) signed up for NYT daily. I do okay and using iPad mini is easier than laptop. – but today’s irritated me. I used the rebus box for frank sinatra but it didn’t recognize online as completed.
I reread all the “tips and tricks” but nothing stood out to guide me. Perhaps an entry elsewhere is off. For example shouldn’t TATES be tateRs Oh well, I guess that’s why they call it a puzzle!
Lake of Fire is an excellent song about hell by the band Meat Puppets. Nirvana covered it in their MTV Unplugged set.
After no luck here, I was forced to figure out the LAT theme. “ Water down” refers to the string HHO found in four long DOWN answers. If anyone was wondering.
I really liked the NYT puzzle–Elvis and Sinatra smushed into the same little boxes. Thanks, Ben, for posting the original version of “My Way.” I never knew Paul Anka based it on a French pop song. I just read the Wikipedia entry on “My Way” and it has a pretty interesting history. Now I’m going to go over to YouTube to listen to all the versions.
Twice this week no LAT. I am worried about Gareth. Is he following all the rules about the virus?