Title: “Make It Count”
Prompt: The meta for this puzzle is a musical movement.
Answer: Riot Grrrl
7-for-7 in 2021, baby! Feels good. Found it quickly but only 248 right answers with under an hour before deadline so tricky enough.
Similar mechanism to last month: instead of changing three letters in certain entries to get a music act, you change one letter from a word in each of nine entries to get a number from 1 through 9. Like so:
53-A: [Siderite, say] = IRON ORE. Change the R in ORE to get ONE. I call shenanigans; a music puzzle with IRON ORE as a theme entry is morally obligated to use a “Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald” reference.
24-A: [Its name in Japanese translates to “Sulfur Island”] = IWO JIMA. Change the I in IWO to get TWO. Everything sounds cooler in Japanese…or do Japanese speakers think “Sulfur Island” sounds cool and it’s all relative?
63-A: [Final movement?] = DEATH THROE. Change the O to an E to get THREE. This is the one that gave it away for me. I’d noticed long ago at THROE is one letter off from THREE, and a singular “throe” is so weird that it tipped me off immediately to the trick.
27-A: [Postshow party spot, sometimes] = TOUR BUS. Change the T to an F to get FOUR.
40-A: [Exude] = GIVE OFF. Change the G to an F to get FIVE.
51-A: [Top 10 hit for Stevie Wonder] = SIR DUKE. Change the R to an X to get SIX.
34-D: [Leave a group you don’t feel right about, say] = SEVER TIES. Change the R to an N to get SEVEN.
17-A: [Call from a drill sergeant] = DRESS RIGHT. Change the R to an E to get EIGHT.
11-D: [Depth-finding device] = PLUMB LINE. Change the L to an N to get NINE.
Now what? Take the replacement letters, of course (as in “The Replacements” from last month), but how to order them? As they are in the grid it’s RITLGRRRO, which was probably R-rich and vowel-poor enough to cause some solvers to look elsewhere. But let’s number them by numerical order of the new single-digit numbers we’re created, and out pops RIOT GRRRL, the 1990s movement that started in the Pacific Northwest.
Another strong effort from Pete in this, his 10th year of MMMM. Constrained choice of answers, so RIOT GRRRL was quite a find, and keeping it symmetrical in the grid quite a challenge. I’ve seen some nice ordering mechanisms before but actually forming the numbers 1-9 in the theme entries and using that as your ordering mechanism is inspired, and — well, quite meta.
4.65 stars. Like it a lot. Also like being 7-for-7! See you next month when I’ll make it 8-for-8 (maybe).
253 total this month.
Constructing this puzzle was hard, but the biggest challenge this month was figuring out how to cover a RIOT GRRRL song. Check out the write-up to see our video on Tuesday…