Fireball is on summer vacation until September.
Sara Muchnick & Doug Peterson’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Reverse Engineering”—Jim P’s review
Congrats to Sara Muchnick, Doug Peterson’s co-constructor, on this, her debut puzzle.
Their theme is TURNED THE TABLES (36a, [Shifted an advantage, and what we’ve done in this puzzle’s circles]). The circled letters in the four corners spell out the word TABLES but in different (but always clockwise) configurations.
I was about to say I don’t see any pattern to the placement of the letters, but I may be wrong. Note the locations of the starting Ts which I’ve marked in red in the image. In the NW corner of the grid, the T is in the upper-right position. Moving down to the SW corner, the T moves down to the bottom-right. Back up in the NE, the T is in the very bottom position, and lastly, in the SE corner of the grid, the T is in the bottom-left position. So it does seem the TABLES have been turned 180º.
But it was hard to find this pattern. In fact, if I hadn’t been writing this post, I probably wouldn’t have seen it. We normally read (and solve crosswords) left to right before moving down, so jumping from the NW to the SW then back up to the NE to follow the pattern doesn’t make sense to me. I would have gone from the NW to the NE to the SW and then the SE. And I would have had the T start at the top of its circle, then finish at its bottom. Like in my doctored-up pic below. Maybe that would result in some tough-to-fill sections, but to me it flows better.
Moving on, we see STAR SIGN, BUNKMATE, NEBRASKA, COLOMBIA, TABBY CAT, BAD ASSES, ANCESTOR, and ERASMUS topping the fill. That’s way more than usual, no doubt due to the theme being relegated to the corners thereby leaving space for sparkly stuff elsewhere.
Clues of note:
- 15a. [Board of inquiry?]. OUIJA. I should’ve gotten this, but I admitted defeat because I didn’t know two of the three proper names in the crossings (LILA and AJA—country music and sports are not my strong suits) and because the PUCKS clue [They’re kept on ice] looked to me like either PACKS or PICKS (ice packs, ice picks). The U never entered my mind. So with just O___A, I was dumbfounded. Still, I should have gotten it. The clue is fair (though tricky). I just wish the crossers weren’t also thorny.
- 41a. [They’re part of your history]. SITES. Browser history, that is.
- 42a. [It’s on the same side as the pinkie]. ULNA. Nice, fresh angle on this old crossword standby.
- 37d. [Setting of the annual SPIEL board game fair]. ESSEN. Another new angle. If you enjoy board games, you’ve no doubt run across the “Spiel des Jahres” (Game of the Year) symbol on many of the top games. I take it the game fair in ESSEN is where game-makers hope to get their games recognized for an award?
I like the theme, but I didn’t detect the pattern until well after the solve. Loads of fun fill and cluing. 3.5 stars.
Jake Halperin’s New York Times crossword—Amy’s write-up
Ben’s traveling today, so I’m subbing for him.
Theme revealer is CALLS IT LIKE IT IS, 40a. [What each asterisked clue’s answer does, to correct a misnomer?]. Anyone else try TELLS IT first here? Each of the four themers takes a familiar term that is scientifically inaccurate, and “corrects” it:
- 18a. [*Sensitive part of the elbow], FUNNY NERVE. Your funny bone is actually triggered when you bump your ulnar nerve.
- 20a. [*Oft-wished-upon sighting], SHOOTING METEOR. A star is a ball of fire, while a meteor is more of a zooming rock.
- 57a. [*Symbol of Australia], KOALA MARSUPIAL. ’Tisn’t a bear. I wonder how the koala population has recovered from the 2019-20 bushfires.
- 63a. [*Headwear made from jipijapa fibers], ECUADOR HAT. The panama hat isn’t from Panama.
Toughest crossing for most solvers, I’ll bet: 5a. [It’s found near a trap], DELT crossing 7d. [Sally ___ (English teacake)], LUNN. I know this teacake only from crosswords, so I mostly rely on crossings to remember if it’s Bunn, Dunn, Munn, Nunn, Lunn, etc. The DELT clue is particularly tricky—we’re talking muscles, and the deltoids are near the trapezoids. DEBT and DENT are actual words, so if you don’t know LUNN …
Overall, the fill and clues had a sort of old vibe. Very little of it has to do with anything specifically from the past decade. KEKE Palmer was an actress but not yet a TV host, and 2017’s “LADY Bird” is perhaps the only thing from the last five years. Even the TNT slogan “Boom.” dates back to 2014.
Four more things:
- 1a. [Alternative to a Ding Dong], Hostess HO HO. Speaking of highly processed snack cakes, do read this New Yorker humor piece, Lesser-Known Rejection Stories by Taylor Kay Phillips. One of the bits provides an origin story for Little Debbie snack cakes and it made me laugh.
- 1d. [Sound of a snicker], HEH / 22a. [When doubled, “Good one”], HAR. I dunno, man. I think we’re good capping off the number of spelled-out laughs at one per puzzle.
- 28d. [Sch. with a campus in Narragansett], URI. I know the health care workers are all wishing we’d use the “upper respiratory infection” meaning sometimes.
- 42d. [Tour de France units: Abbr.], KMS. Never a fan of pluralizing a metric unit’s abbreviation. Heck, the “English” measures pound and ounce don’t generally take an S, either (just lb and oz).
3.5 stars from me. Neat theme, but the nonthematic parts of the puzzle didn’t offer much fun for me.
Brendan Emmett Quigley’s “Life of Brian” crossword—Darby’s write-up
Theme: Each themed answer adds ENO to a phrase which could otherwise stand on its own. The title is also a reference to the Monty Python film Life of Brian.
Revealer: 67a [“Brian added to this puzzles theme answers”] ENO
- 17a [“Say a few disparaging words about a baseball hat”] – DENOUNCE CAP / DUNCE CAP
- 20a [“Job that entails informing people that they have overdue library books”] – LATE NOTICE WORK / LATTICE WORK
- 37a [“‘I need that coiled-wire switch’?”] – DO ME A SOLENOID / DO ME A SOLID
- 56a [“No longer have sails?”] – RUN OUT OF GENOAS / RUN OUT OF GAS
- 62a [“Lack the courage to play Othello”] – DARE NOT MOOR / DARTMOOR
First and foremost, it’s impressive how many themed answers are squeezed into this puzzle. . I wasn’t familiar with Brian Eno before this quiz, so the revealer didn’t necessarily help me until I filled it in via the crosses, but then I saw the pattern. It was certainly a creative theme, and it’s neat when ENO is removed. However, I thought 20a’s LATTICE WORK was a stretch sans ENO. I did learn both what “solenoid” (a wire that works as a magnet when holding an electrical current) and a genoa sail are (30d [“Hull piece”]’s KEEL also refers to a boating term).
Save for LAUREN Alaina (45d [“Country singer _____ Alaina”]), the puzzle’s references to George Clinton via 13a [“Clinton’s collective, familiarly”] (PFUNK), Franklin Delano Roosevelt and Joseph Stalin’s meeting in YALTA via 50a, BRET Stephens (6d [“Pulitzer Prize-winning columnist Stephens”]), Derek WALCOTT (21d [“‘Omeros’ poet Derek”]), and ISAO AOKI (39d [“First Japanese player to win a PGA tour event]) reinforce a male-dominated puzzle that has a theme centered around another man. As the daughter of an avid PGA watcher, I did appreciate the fact about ISAO AOKI.
Other clues that caught my eye:
- 16a [“Constitution, in D.C.”] – I thought this was a super clever use of AVE, especially with the red herring focus on the Constitution. I spent several minutes thinking of how to abbreviate “National Archives.”
- 62a [“Lack the courage to play Othello”] – David L pointed out to me that 62a’s DARE NOT MOOR sans ENO word Dartmoor refers to a place in England. As I was looking to see if there were any connections between Dartmoor and Othello, I found that in the 19th century, Dartmoor Prison put on a production of Othello with an all-Black cast. Both Dartmoor Prison (a play) and Mad Blood Stirring (a novel) are based on this event. As a history nerd, this one was definitely a great realization, so thanks David for pointing out Dartmoor to me!
- 10d [“It’s in and out of the shops regularly”] – This was a fun way to include JALOPY in the puzzle.
- 14d [“17th letters”] – As far as letter clues go, I’ve seen “ess” (S), “bee” (B), and “jay” (J), but never KUES. Question though. Which is better: cues or KUES?
- 40d [“A pushover”] – DUCK SOUP is not a phrase I’ve heard much, and it has a variety of meanings, if you ask Merriam-Webster. It does refer to, as BEQ notes, a pushover, but it can also mean “something that is easy to do.”
Overall, I think that the theme carries this one, but it could have used some more contemporary references to help live up to the medium skill level assigned to this grid.
Rebecca Goldstein’s USA Today crossword, “Middle of the Pack”—Sophia’s review
Theme: Each theme answer fits a “X [in/on] the Y” pattern, where the first word starts with PA and the last word ends with CK
- 19a [Major nuisance] – PAIN IN THE NECK
- 35a [Shift blame to someone else] – PASS THE BUCK
- 52a [Encourages, in a way] – PATS ON THE BACK
Shorter write up than usual today because I’m actually going into the office for work this morning, can you believe it?? Anyways, I liked this theme a lot! It’s a nice touch that all the theme answers have “THE” in the middle of the PACK; It worked well with the puzzle’s title.
The fill in this puzzle is all around top-notch. All four of the long downs (PING PONG, FLAT WHITES, BEER BATTER, PUNK ROCK) are great bonuses, which is especially impressive because each of them crosses two theme answers. There’s a lot of very strong 6 and 7 length fill too (see: BOSEMAN, UTERUS, the timely clue on CICADA). As I worked my way through I was consistently delighted by the words I found, which is one of the best things I can say about a puzzle.
- Besides the aforementioned BEER BATTER and FLAT WHITES, today’s food roundup includes CATFISH, UDON, shakshouka, pad thai, ICEE…. and can I count “Butter” by BTS?
- The only thing I like more than food in a puzzle is LGBTQIA+ representation, so I loved the Janelle MONAE and gay ICON clues.
Happy Thursday y’all!
Bill McCartha’s LA Times crossword – Gareth’s summary
Today’s puzzle theme by Bill McCartha is an ambitious example of a genre that isn’t my favourite: a single repeated word scrambled and hidden between two parts of a theme. The central explaining answer is CHANGEOFCLOTHES, and the seven letters in CLOTHES are found scrambled in four other entries. That’s a lot of letters to have to find in an entry, so, for the most part, the entries lean towards the vague: TOOLCHEST, SCENICHOTELS, BALLETSCHOOL. THECLOSER is a specific TV show though, and now I know something about Kyra Sedgwick, whose name I mostly just have memorised as a name for crosswords.
The grace notes, as is often the case, come in the long down answers: OFFYOUGO, ALLWEATHER, somewhat incomplete-sounding PEDALSTEEL and reduplicative BAHAMAMAMA.
Joel Elkins and Andrea Carla Michaels’ Universal crossword, “Measure for Measure”— Jim Q’s write-up
This one measures up!
THEME: Units of measurement are homophones of common phrases.
- WATT HERTZ. What hurts?
- KNOT FURLONG. Not for long!
- JOULE VOLT. Jewel vault.
Sign of a good theme is when it can’t be replicated. And no way in hell can you replicate this!
Really fantastic little set. And yes, it’s little, but it packs a punch. Okay, you may have to use a twinge of imagination to liken VOLT to VAULT, but even that makes me smile.
The themers are so full of scrabbly letters themselves that it was probably more difficult to fill cleanly than one might imagine. It is indeed quite clean, but I personally would’ve preferred a lower word count on this one. Of course, it passes because the theme is so awesome, but were it anything less I’d feel a bit more blah because most of the solve was spent on familiar fill.
All in all, 3.9 stars from me.
NYT: I noticed what might be a dupe at the 25A/25D crossing. ONE being the answer at 25A and “One in a pod” being the clue for 25d (ORCA). Did anyone else notice this?
Some solvers (and editors) are more sensitive to dupes than others. Will Shortz tries to avoid words in clues that telegraph answers. He obviously does not believe that a common word like “one” in a clue will spoil the solve. Occasionally, THE appears in a grid. Should this require the avoidance of “the” in all clues?
WSJ. “Ford predecessor” is EATER? HUH?
I see “Food processor” there.
NYT: I like the theme but not the rest of it… It felt laborious but it may also be that I’m still getting used to the NYT app. I miss Across Lite… I’m trying to be fair to the constructors but my annoyance may be affecting my ratings.
I found the (previously considered extinct) NYT .puz file here under the “Today’s Puzzles” tab this morning. Amy – do you have a secret source?
I guess the relevant data is still included in the webpage? We didn’t touch anything. No idea if this will continue to work.
I had the same reaction. I thought the theme was solid but the rest was both difficult and unpleasant, mostly due to the cluing. And my times are also notably slower on the NYT website than in Across Lite.
Stars are not on fire! They are undergoing nuclear fusion.
NYT: In my experience, you “call it as you see it” and you “tell it like it is.”
I thought in both cases it’s “AS it is”
In a sports context, I think “call it as you see it” (or “call ’em as you see ’em”) is pretty common. We expect referees and umpires to be fair, and render an unbiased judgment – call ’em as they see ’em.
In the context of telling the unvarnished truth, I think “tell it like it is” pretty much rules.
In the context of today’s puzzle though, it’s kind of in between. It’s not exactly a question of truth-telling – more a question of calling something by its proper name. So I can buy CALL IT LIKE IT IS – but it’s just not a very in-the-language phrase.
BEQ: DAR[ENO]TMOOR — Dartmoor is a place in England, one of the very few pristine, undeveloped areas in the country. Probably not well known to most USians, but Mrs BEQ is from England, I believe.
That’s super helpful! I’m going to add it into my write up. Thanks for catching this!
Happy to help!
One way some people may know of Dartmoor is that it’s the setting for The Hound of the Baskervilles, which capitalized on its wild and remote nature.
Oh that’s so interesting! I should have realized since I love Sherlock Holmes.
I found some great stuff diving into the Dartmoor/Othello connection, so I’m so glad you pointed it out!
Anyone know why the NYT puzzle is not offered in the Across lite format?
FWIW: Cruciverb.com offers NYT in Across Lite
What’s your trick? Didn’t work for me…
Thank you, Jim Q… that was awfully nice write up!
We loved this puzzle and had a tough time finding a home for it and it got a bit lost in the shuffle! :)