Evan Birnholz’s Washington Post Variety Puzzle, “Spell It Out: A Meta Hunt from A to Z” – Jim Q’s writeup
Wow. Just wow. If you haven’t done this puzzle yet, it’s worth downloading a copy, finding a printer, and brandishing your favorite #2 pencil. Get the puzzle here.
Sure, it will take a bit longer than normal to solve (well north of an hour for me), and it may look a tad intimidating, but this is masterful work.
5 big fat stars from me, no question about it.
The puzzle is broken down into four different grids, which have a “cryptic” style look to them. That, and the somewhat confusing directions gave me a momentary twinge of dread- I often can’t finish puzzles without overall interlock (like typical American crosswords have) and my grade school teachers will attest to my lack of direction-following skills. But I also trust Evan’s judgement and skill as a constructor, so I dove in.
The directions ask us to fill in the first missing letter for each of the individual grid’s clues, noting that in each puzzle, one letter will go unused. This part is pretty easy. Then the solver is to transfer the newly entered letters into the boxes that correspond with the clue number.
The next part is, of course, trickier. In a sense, there really are no clue numbers (they’re simply indications of where to enter the letters), and it’s up to the solver to figure out where the actual answers to the clues fit in the grid. I thought this part was tremendous fun as some clues are Monday-level gimmes, and others test your prowess as a puzzler.
PUZZLE #1 :
UNUSED LETTER IN CLUES = Z
The easiest of the grids for me- for which I was thankful since it was an affirmation that I was solving the puzzle correctly.
I had a small stumble as I inserted L instead of X for the second clue [_enon, e.g. (2 wds.)], but that worked itself out quickly.
The hardest crossing was at LYRIC and BACON since the clues for those were somewhat difficult (I really wanted SLAW for [Diner side dish]). And, without proper clue numbers, it’s very easy to succumb to doubt as to whether or not you’re filling in the correct blanks for any given clue. However, it’s a very satisfying feeling when it all snaps into place.
UNUSED LETTER IN CLUES = U
A tad trickier than the first puzzle, but going back to the part where I only had to fill in just the initial letters provided a welcome break from thinking… like watching Wheel of Fortune after Jeopardy!
I immediately searched for a spot to enter TONY [Yul Brynner won one for “The King and I”] and was disappointed (he won an OSCAR). And having no idea who Jordan Spieth was, I had to let all the answers I was confident with settle in before searching for a place to enter a sport- in this case GOLF. But this is part of the fun/appeal of this puzzle- the doubting and narrowing down of possibilities before it comes together.
My only nit about this grid is the awkward clue for NOTE [Xylophone score mark] since the “xylophone” part of that clue is unnecessary (I was looking for somewhere to put STACCATO or something). I suppose that’s the nature of having to clue each entry with a different starting letter. **See Evan’s take on this at bottom of post**
UNUSED LETTER IN CLUES = L
Possibly the most difficult of the quartet for me. And that is mostly due to a confident error I made when I inserted AREAS for [Districts]. Took a looong time for me to suss that out and erase it in favor of ZONES.
JULIETT was very tough and somewhat awkward as well [Soviet submarine class, or an ill-fated lover with an extra T]. If it weren’t for the second half of that clue, I never would’ve gotten it (turns out the entry was necessary for the meta, but we’ll get to that later).
UNUSED LETTER IN CLUES = U
[Like “Frozen” (hyph.)] tripped me up on this one. I think it’s because I have trouble differentiating between “hyph.” and “2 wds.” PG-RATED eventually fell into place, but I feel like I considered every hyphenated thing I could think of… IN-HD? No. SLO-MO?? Maybe there was a SLO-MO scene? like Olaf melting in a very sad way? Nope.
The most important thing to note about this puzzle is the central grid spanner: INTERSECTIONS [Crossings, and where to find the meta answer].
The puzzles were fun enough on their own, and I’d probably have been satisfied had that been the end… but the meta is absolutely astonishing.
In the directions, the solver is told that “The unused starting letters will spell out a word that completes a set. That set hides a two-word device used in spelling out some words.”
That word is ZULU.
In hindsight, I think I might’ve liked a bit less of a nudge here- perhaps just “The answer to this puzzle is a two-word device used in spelling out some words.” Although I didn’t think about trying to determine the meta answer until the grids were completed, it’s probably easy to figure out mid-solve with the meta hint as specific as it is, which could mar the solving experience. It might’ve been nifty to uncover ZULU without being directly told where to look for it, and then figure out independently that it was part of a set.
But then again, Evan has to go for mass appeal- and that approach would probably only satisfy a tiny niche. Besides, he’s taking enough risk publishing a variety puzzle in the first place.
Since ZULU ends the phonetic alphabet, is it possible that the grids contain other letters of the phonetic alphabet? And I didn’t notice the entire time?? Sure is. That’s exactly what happens (hence the awkward spelling of JULIETT).
Not only are they all there (with the exception of ZULU of course), but they all intersect. (see screenshot- ignore the blue highlights).
Not only do they all intersect, but the letters at which they do so, spell out- in order mind you- RADIO RECEIVER.
Take a moment to appreciate how well this was done. In four clean, symmetrical (!) grids all of the letters of the phonetic alphabet are used (!!) and- in order (!!!)- all of their intersecting (!!!!) letters spell out a related two word phrase (!!!!!).
Some time ago, Patrick Berry published a puzzle suite where every puzzle on its own was incredible, and they all connected with one another to create a mind-bending meta. This is right up there with those.
I don’t know how Evan is going to meet the bar that he just set with this one, but I’ll be damned if I’m not looking forward to seeing him try.
P.S. When I mentioned to Evan that the only answer I wasn’t confident in was NOTE because of the xylophone clue, he responded with some pretty cool insight:
[…Never, ever write a From A to Z puzzle without a clear plan for the clues beginning with X, Z, Q, J, etc. Especially don’t do that if you have theme answers all over them. The Q and the J you can maybe shoehorn in on some occasions, and the Z too if things break right ….. but the X is murder. So I had to stretch big-time to find something that would sorta work in that puzzle, but I’m hoping that it and the other X’s are gettable.]
They were. Bravo! (no pun intended)
Ross Trudeau’s New York Times crossword, “If I Were You”—Amy’s write-up
Hearty thanks to the various members of Team Fiend who covered for me during my vacation! It’s good to be back home with my own bed, but I’m missing the swimming pool and my in-laws.
Good title for this theme. Familiar phrases have an I turned into a U, and the resulting goofy phrase is clued accordingly:
- 23a. [Land O’Lakes and Breakstone’s?], BUTTER RIVALS. I didn’t know Breakstone’s was more than sour cream or cottage cheese. (Bitter rivals, with that second I untouched.)
- 31a. [Ministering?], WORKING THE SOUL. (Working the soil, again with another I unchanged.)
- 47a. [“Damn, I can’t seem to get a ball into fair territory!”?], CURSES, FOULED AGAIN. (“Curses, foiled again!” with an extra U and I without vowel changes.)
- 62a. [Like a trip overland from Venezuela to Bolivia?], JUNGLE ALL THE WAY. (Jingle All the Way, a holiday movie.)
- 82a. [Expensive line of nonsense someone throws you?], HUNDRED-DOLLAR BULL. (Bill, with that extra U in HUNDRED.)
- 95a. [“What are you hauling in there?” and “How many axles you running?”], TRUCK QUESTIONS. (Trick, with an unchanged U and I in QUESTIONS.)
- 108a. [Entering your middle name, then date of birth, then adding a “1,” etc.?], PASSWORD HUNT. (Hint.) For the record, I have never used my middle name in a password.
Workable letter-change theme, with some mildly amusing theme answers. It would have been more elegant to exclude extra U’s and I’s, though I wouldn’t want an elegant set of supremely dull themers.
Ten more things from throughout the puzzle:
- 30a. [Commies], REDS. Remember when it seemed funny that electoral maps used red for the Republicans, because Republicans were always calling Democrats commie pinkos, reds, etc.? And now we have Republicans sporting T-shirts that proclaim they’d rather be Russians than Democrats. Sigh.
- 89a. [Part of NGO], NON. My airplane reading was Guy Delisle’s graphic memoir, Burma Chronicles. He uses NGO plenty, since his wife was working for Médecins Sans Frontières of France, and much of their expat community in Myanmar worked for nongovernmental organizations. There was only one brief mention of the Rohingya people, but you get an idea of what it was like to live in Rangoon for a year about a decade ago. So much repression and corruption. It’s easy to see how the people would be hard-pressed to resist a genocide.
- 102a. [One putting others down], ABASER. Nobody uses that form of the word, come on. Then there’s crosswordese 88a. [Indigo source], ANIL. Kosher for NYT crosswords but deemed too unfamiliar to be an answer in their online Spelling Bee puzzle.
- 94d. [Comedic duo?], HARD C’S. As in the letters at the beginning and end of comedic. Aww, I really wanted some funny people.
- 87a. [Informal assertion of authority], “SEZ ME.” My pick for the single worst entry in this puzzle. It’s terrible.
- 61a. [Biblioklept’s targets], BOOKS. No jury of their peers could convict, etc.
- 31d. [Excessive lovers of the grape], WINOS. I wish this entry would vanish from crosswords. My dad was an “excessive lover of the grape” in that he drank a shit-ton of wine, but it wasn’t so much the love of the grape as an addiction.
- 29a. [Kind of torch], TIKI. I wonder if the white nationalists and Nazis attending tomorrow’s “Unite the Right” event in Washington will be carrying tiki torches again. This week, we remember the loss of Heather Heyer, the young woman committed to social justice who was killed at last year’s gross event.
- 112a. [Missile in a mating ritual], LOVE DART. I don’t know what the hell this means.
- 117a. [Nitpicky know-it-all], PEDANT. Greetings! You know who you are.
I like AGLIO E OLIO, BAIT SHOP, ROUNDHOUSE, JP MORGAN, and LEGAL PADS.
3.9 stars from me.
Brendan Emmett Quigley’s CRooked Crossword, “OK by Me”—Laura’s review
I suspect Cox/Rathvon are on vacation, since this is the third BEQ CRooked I’ve reviewed in a row. Today we have phrases with repeated instances of the abbreviation OK, each of which is over, or by, the letters ME — hence the title; I might’ve chosen “I’m OK, You’re OK” instead.
- [23a: Reviewed]: TOOK A SECOND LOOK
- [42a: Falsify finances]: COOK THE BOOKS
- [67a: “That’s what it’s all about” dance]: HOKEY-POKEY
- [70a: Florida swamp]: OKEFENOKEE
- [94a: Lover, per a Judy Garland song]: SNOOKY OOKUMS. An Irving Berlin tune from 1913 that Garland sings with Fred Astaire in Easter Parade (1948)
- [113a: Somehow]: BY HOOK OR BY CROOK
With a theme like this one, you need LOTS OF down entries containing K. FAKE YOKELS EKE ASKEW UKES, MIKE, IKE & JAKE ride a TRIKE while drinking SAKE and playing SKEE-Ball along the AKER. Gotta DASH because it’s time for lunch; can’t decide between a TUNA MELT or a TOSTADA. I look forward to your FAN MAIL.
Gary Larson’s Los Angeles Times crossword, “Sounds Like a Snooze” —Jenni’s write-up
Fun theme! Each theme answer has an “s” sound replaced by a “z” sound. Wackiness results.
- 23a [Liquor store?] is BUZZ DEPOT (bus depot).
- 16d [Much-admired cooktop?] is a PRIZE RANGE (price range).
- 25a [Feeding time for the herd?] is GRAZE PERIOD (grace period).
- 46a [Caribbean island chain?] is CAYS BY CAYS (case by case).
- 67a[ Make change for a five?] is GIVE THE ONES OVER (give the once over).
- 73d [Withhold enthusiasm?] is HARBOR ZEAL (harbor seal). This sense of “harbor” stumped me for a little while. I think of it more as “holding” than “withholding.”
- 93a [Funding for cops?] is the FUZZ BUDGET (fussbudget). That one made me chuckle.
- 115a [“No legumes for me, please”?] is KEEP THE PEAS (keep the peace). Another chuckle.
- 117a [Slept through the alarm?] is OVERDOZED (overdosed). Not a fun base word.
A solid, enjoyable Sunday theme.
A few other things:
- 8d [React, barely] is BAT AN EYE. I don’t think I’ve ever heard this without the “didn’t” in front of it. It reminded me of this classic from The New Yorker.
- 27a [Post-Thanksgiving dinner feeling, for many] is a FOOD COMA. Probably not induced by trytophan, as I was taught many moons ago.
- 36d [He pitched in the majors at age 59] was the legendary Satchel PAIGE.
- 69d [Edison contemporary] was TESLA. We would also have accepted “rival” or “mortal enemy.”
- 83a [Good sound at the garage] is the PURR of a well-tuned engine. Do they even tune engines any more?
What I didn’t know before I did this puzzle: that there was a Belgian prime minister name ELIO Di Rupo, and that Raymond MASSEY co-starred in Dr. Kildare. I went looking for a clip featuring Massey and found this gem of overacting by none other than William Shatner. Enjoy.
Thanks, Jim! This puzzle drove me up the wall for several days just trying to get any phrase to work with the intersecting letters, but I’m happy with how it turned out.
One amusing thing about the puzzle that I didn’t realize until a test-solver pointed it out to me: In Puzzle #2, WHISKEY-TANGO-FOXTROT appear in order by grid number. Seems apt.
This is what I listened to after the solve:
Love Jim Q’s time description for WaPo! That rates a five.
NYT: Cute! Pretty easy, I thought…
my favorite was the little Italian corner with ALITALIA and AGLIO E OLIO… heading to a small island outside of Venice next week and getting excited about it.
That’s a very generous review of the NYT – I am sorry, but all I’s in theme entries have to change to a U. Surely one can find multiple entries for this simple substitution theme? Let’s see: TO THE BUTTER END, SUCK AS A DOG, MUSTY COPELAND .. I could go on, seriously.
The NYT theme was good enough for me. I had no idea what to make of LOVE DART either. TIKI doesn’t have that usage in dictionaries, and presumably the fad just hasn’t reached NYC. (Where would we hang such a torch in an apartment anyway?) But I gather it’s real.
I’d like the Washington Post variety puzzle a lot more if the pdf printout had a typeface that was easier to read. I don’t know if it was crisper in print in the paper or rather it’s just that so much of that sans serif is beyond me. (I have normal reading vision.)
It seems like ULTRAS represents two days in a row of soccer-related clues in the NYT that are not OLE (although that’s here too). Nice to see this branching out.
Is there a way to print the shown WaPo puzzle and work it on paper (for those not inclined to attempt the Meta Hunt)?
Yes. The link is at the top of the post, but this will work too: http://herbach.dnsalias.com/WaPo/wp180812.pdf
This is still the Meta Hunt. Don’t want that. I want the puzzle, S0und Packing, that is shown on the WaPo web page. It is described as an older puzzle. I see no link at the top of the post. Pressing Print will end up with Meta Hunt.
Send me an email: devilcrosswords AT gmail DOT com.
I was doubly impressed with the WaPo puzzle — first, because it was such an ingenious construction, and second, because I figured it out (I generally fail at metas).
At first I thought maybe “NATO alphabet” was the solution, but the clue for intersections in puzzle 4 made it clear something else was up. There’s a an awful lot of intersections in these puzzles, I said to myself, but then I googled the NATO alphabet and found that all the words were in the puzzles — and then I saw how to get RADIO RECEIVER.
My only quibble — me being a PEDANT and all — is that the explanation “The answer to this puzzle is a two-word device used in spelling out some words” doesn’t make a whole lot of sense to me. How would you use a radio receiver to spell out words (it’s the person at the other end, with the radio transmitter, who is presumably doing the spelling)? And does “some words” means some words in the puzzle (none of which are spelled out using the NATO alphabet, as far as I can see) or some words in general?
But I imagine part of the difficulty in making a good meta is finding a way to give hints to the answer without giving away the whole store.
In short, a very excellent puzzle!
(NYT was a big snooze, as seems increasingly to be the case).
In BEQ’s “OK BY ME” offering, I think the 94A Garland/Astaire song is spelled “Snookey Ookums,” not “Snooky Ookums,” although you will find both spellings on the Web.
See https://www.sheetmusicnow.com/products/snookey-ookums-p275606 and https://cudl.colorado.edu/luna/servlet/detail/UCBOULDERCB1~78~78~1047394~137941:Snookey-ookums and more.
I recognize no authority but that of the Library of Congress:
There are many errors/inconsistencies at loc.gov, Laura. And I note that the first of the two URLs you cite is a blog entry, and the second doesn’t bother to capitalize properly.
Check out these two loc.gov URLs:
You can find many more. I stand by my second URL in particular, with its very clear graphic.
I personally just roll with any old spelling of nonsense “noms d’amour”, but I feel the pull of being a PEDANT here myself. So, Bob, I’ll point out to you that even in the references you gave, the sheet music to the song, Berlin spells it both ways. Just read to page 3…
Good point, Darren, I should have turned the page. But, FWIW, I still think the Waterson, Berlin, & Snyder graphic is definitive. Don’t you?
LAT: I didn’t understand the theme at first, because I thought the theme entries would rhyme with Snooze (Booze DEPOT would make sense for 23A) and when I caught on to the oh-hey-an-S-sound-is-replaced-with-a-Z-sound, I thought well, okay, whatever; but the further I got, the more I liked the theme. It’s high on the wacky-meter.
As my printer is currently in a coma, I can’t do the WaPo, which looks fabulous rats rats rats! I have saved the pdf for when my printer comes to, or I get a new one (seems likely), in case the link no longer works. Can’t wait!
TIKI torch is familiar, but [Kind of bar] might have been better – probably TIKI bar is more familiar, and the clue might have offered a little misdirection, if the solver starts thinking of candy bars.
I assumed LOVE DART was some sort of Cupid reference, but Wikipedia says it’s something certain snails and slugs produce as part of a mating ritual – new knowledge that I’m sure will come in handy some day.
I wasn’t bothered by the I’s that didn’t change to U’s in the themers, but most of the theme answers just fell kind of flat for me. I did like JUNGLE ALL THE WAY (though I associated it with the phrase in Jingle Bells, rather than a movie I hadn’t heard of).