Alex Eaton-Salners’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “States of Being”—Jim P’s review
When you see Alex Eaton-Salners’s byline, you know you’re often in for something with a twist. This one’s a little more straightforward than some of his other offerings, but it’s entertaining nonetheless.
Let’s see what he brought us.
- 16a [Start of a candidate’s promise] IF ELECTED…
- 25a [Greeting on el primero de enero] FELIZ AÑO NUEVO. Let’s just pretend there’s a tilde in the grid because otherwise this would need an entirely different (though probably a lot funnier) clue.
- 43a [Words following a countdown] WE HAVE LIFTOFF. What a fun entry!
- 54a [Biological sequence, or what you’ll find in the circled letters] LIFE CYCLE
LIFE CYCLE serves as both revealer and final theme entry. Each of the theme entries has the letters of LIFE circled but not in the same order. However, they are each in a specific order as the letters cycle around. For example, looking at the L, it starts off in the fourth position, then moves to the third, second, and finally back to the first position where it belongs in LIFE. This specific ordering makes finding valid theme entries harder for the constructor, but Alex has managed to gather a fun set, in my opinion.
I don’t know if this was intentional, but the entire grid also gives the feeling of a wheel rotating around a central axis, further emphasizing the CYCLE aspect. I expect it was planned. Nice touch.
Moving on to the fill, there’s not a whole lot of flashiness. The longest entries are CAME NEAR, AMARILLO, ATONE FOR, and REFINERY. These feel more utilitarian than anything else. And entries like LEFT TO and EVINCES feel bland. With only four theme entries, I’d expect to find more interesting fare in the gird. But I did like seeing TAHITI, MOTIFS, and WII FIT.
I like VICUNA as well, even though I didn’t remember it as being a type of animal [Llama’s cousin]. Looks more like the name of a drug. CO-MVPS [Harvey Martin and Randy White, in Super Bowl XII] also looks weird in the grid, and JUTES [Early invaders of Britain] are probably not in most solvers’ knowledgebase. A Germanic people, they invaded Britain in the 4th century alongside the Angles and the Saxons.
Clues of note:
- 5a [Test with two logical reasoning sections, for short]. LSAT. Slight dupe since the T stands for “test”.
- The bottom half of the grid fell much more slowly for me thanks in part to clues like [Like a tiger] and [Breakfast bowlful]. I immediately put in FELINE and CEREAL for these, so it took some time before I realized they needed to be FIERCE and FLAKES respectively.
- 42d [Dessert, in Derby]. In my experience, “pudding” was the more common term rather than AFTERS.
Nice theme and puzzle but I wonder if the grid design compromised some of the fill. 3.6 stars.
Joel Fagliano’s New York Times crossword—Amy’s recap
So I’ve long been a fan of geography themes, and of anagram themes. And yet, this puzzle just felt like such a dry iteration of both. 36a. [What the answers to the starred clues are each anagrams of] clues STATE CAPITALS, and those starred answers are of varying lengths, with the longest Across answers other than 36a not being anagrammed capitals.
- 20a. [*Not formally worded], IN SLANG. Lansing. Awkward as a crossword entry.
- 21a. [*Like the pitcher in a batting order, often], UP LAST. It’s often spelled out as Saint Paul, so not ideal to use in an anagram theme.
- 26a. [*Peacocks, but not peahens], MALES. Salem.
- 44a. [*Wandered], ROVED. Dover. Dull.
- 54a. [*Like some foreign protests], ANTI-U.S. Austin. Wow, contrived much?
- 55a. [*What keeps a part apart], HAIR GEL. Raleigh.
- 24d. [*Internet addresses], DOMAINS. Madison.
What I liked best in this puzzle was the longer non-theme fill. MAIL FRAUD, with the topical clue 17a. [Matter for the Postal Inspection Service]—they played a role in cracking the “rich folks bribing their kids’ way into elite universities” scandal. VITAMINS. BLONDE ALE. 36d. [Killer Bee?] SAMANTHA—check your on-demand service for her “Not the White House Correspondents Dinner” special from a few days ago.
Unlikes: AGHA + EMIR; crosswordese STELE; ampersand-deprived S AND P; DUE UP repeating part of themer UP LAST and, worse still, HAUL UP crossing UP LAST; I HOPE/MUST I dupe; awkward UNKNIT.
2.5 stars from me. Just didn’t have fun with it.
Rachel Fabi and Jeff Chen’s Universal Crossword, “Let the Sparks Fly!”—Judge Vic’s write-up
So, what we have here is a word-that-can-go-before-thus-and-such theme, with each of two words in the theme entries playing the role. To wit:
33a [Flammable material, or a clue to both parts of 16-, 24-, 45- and 54-Across] FIRE STARTER
16a [Scene from an earlier time] FLASHBACK–Flash fire. Backfire.
24a [Foes’ home base] ENEMY CAMP–Enemy fire. Campfire.
45a [Uncultivated landscape feature] WILD GRASS–Wildfire. Grass fire.
54a [Menage, in English] HOUSEHOLD–House fire. Hold fire? The latter one I’m not feeling the love on. Hold seems verby here to me, whereas all the other fire leaders are, or can be, adjectives. Plus the verb phrases I hear are “Hold your fire” and, possibly, “hold one’s fire.” Quick research shows that there is an argument to be made for “hold fire”–as a verb phrase–but that same research shows a YouTube video titled “How to hold fire without getting burned,” a green-paint usage pure and simple.
Other stuff of note includes
10d [Vader’s childhood ride] POD RACER
11d [Colleague of Thor] IRON MAN
12d [Foul place] CESS PIT
17d [Steal some wheels] HOT WIRE
32d [In a zen state] AT PEACE
33d [Hits a non-fair fly to a fielder] FOULS OUT–Some say this answer makes it a no-no to use foul in the clue for 12d. Others say, “Ain’t no rule!”
36d [If all else fails] AT WORST
Fun puzzle, though. 3.5 stars.
Byron Walden’s AVCX, “Bad Calls” — Ben’s Review
A second 4.5/5 difficulty AVCX in a row! Spring has sprung, and that means a baseball theme is back in play. Given that I tend to not be on Byron Walden’s wavelength AND didn’t catch the baseball connection in this puzzle for a while, this was a longer solve than usual for me. Let’s peek under the hood at the theme:
- 17A: Faux pas on “Morning Joe”? — SCARBOROUGH FOUL
- 21A: Headline about the firing of a kitchen worker? — DISHWASHER OUT
- 36A: Dance for oil prospectors? — WILDCAT BALL
- 40A: Where a coop resident might keep passports and extra cash? — CHICKEN SAFE
- 53A: Expo that showcases all the latest jargon? — TECHNICAL FAIR
- 61A: Collective action that disrupts the social calendar? — DEBUTANTE STRIKE
All of the umpire calls in this puzzle are mixed up – the more common phrases are SCARBOROUGH FAIR, DISHWASHER SAFE, WILDCAT STRIKE, CHICKEN OUT, TECHNICAL FOUL, and DEBUTANTE BALL. WILDCAT BALL threw me for a loop in its cluing – I had no idea that prospectors were referred to as wildcats, but it checks out.
Elsewhere in the fill, there wasn’t much to CHAFE AT – there was a nice blend of pop culture (MOESHA), high culture (O FORTUNA), and some solid 7-letter fill in each corner – TIED OFF, DIVULGE, ANTI-FLU, FELLATE, SAVE FOR, STEALTH, and SI SENOR.
Fun fact: NENEH Cherry’s “Buffalo Stance” was derived from the bones of a remix of Morgan McVey’s “Looking Good Diving”. Spot her in the back of the video!
Paul Coulter’s LA Times crossword – Gareth’s review
It’s a “words with” theme, only vertical and with slightly longer than typical “with words”. The hook is BELLBOTTOMS, and sure enough the bottoms of four entry can be bottomed by BELL to make LIBERTY, SCHOOL, COW (I’ve got a fever…) and DINNER BELLS. These are found in LADYLIBERTY, CHARTERSCHOOL, CASHCOW and POTLUCKDINNER respectively.
Notable answers elsewhere:
- [Marshal at Waterloo], NEY. Seen surprisingly rarely, given his name. I guess Americans have an aversion to the minutiae of European history…
- [Clog kin], SABOT. Another bit of less common crossword-ese, basically a clog, but French. Many of you will likely know this, but is the source of the word saboteur, from the act of throwing shoes into machinery to damage them.
- [“I’m qualified, too!”], WHYNOTME. That sounds rather stilted.
- [“Gotcha”], AHSO. [Eye rolls]
- [Ocean State sch.], URI. Poor fraudulent mister Geller. He felt like an overwhelming cultural reference point, or at least the butt of jokes by just about every comedian, for most of the 90s (and 80s from cross-exposure), but his relevancy is dying…
WSJ: You don’t have to pretend there’s a tilde in the grid, since the cross (vicuña) has one too.
NYT: UP is not normally a bad dupe, but it’s used in pretty much the same sense in DUE UP as in LAST UP, with the latter being a theme entry, so I’m going to go ahead and call that a bad dupe.
You missed HAUL UP actually crossing LAST UP.
You’re right, I did miss that.
Truth be told, I’m not usually much bothered by dupes of prepositions in verb phrases. If DRESS UP crossed KISS UP in a grid, I don’t think I would mind, especially if they crossed at an S and not one of the letters in UP. This dupe was egregious to me because in both LAST UP and DUE UP, the UP is being used as an adjective, and in the exact same sense.
NYT – I liked most of the fill, but I just don’t really care that the theme answers are anagrams of state capitals. And one of them is an anagram of my home state’s capital (Oregon).
universal was a lot of fun, congrats to rachel on the debut!
loving the spanish from aes
State capitals are in appropriate geographic locations!
I have been to Lansing, and can attest that it is east of St. Paul, not west.
Darn! I want to deduct 0.5 stars now. :-)
Universal: 44d [Black-and-white “bears”] PANDAS.
They’re ursids; no quotes necessary.
Perhaps it would seem less so with the tilde above the N: vicuña.
Ah. Didn’t realize it needed the tilde. But now I can argue it just looks like Spanish viagra.
In my defense, Wikipedia lists the tilde-less version as an alternative.
And kudos to Alex for crossing ñs in the grid!
For what it’s worth, MW11C prefers it with the tilde, while RHUD prefers it without, but both list the alternatives. Rather a nice touch that it occurs at the crossing. I learned some Spanish in the process.
Anyhow, I know it’s hard for puzzle reviewers not to chortle a bit over the pun, but it’s getting old. Besides, we know by now that there are limits to entering accents in a grid or, well, right here. If we were sticklers, we’d be demanding one for RENE, itself a common fill, in this very puzzle.
Universal kind of bummed me out today. FLASH / ENEMY / WILD / HOUSE fires are all pretty tragic, deadly, destructive events that I’m not necessarily trying to think about during my morning. I liked a lot of the fill though.
WSJ: Does anyone get the clue for CATS [“Do some laps”]?
WSJ – 1A [Some do laps] CATS. Some cats “do laps” in the sense that they take in food or drink by lapping it up with their tongue. Kinda clever, right?
Ah gotcha. I was definitely scrambling that clue in my head, didn’t parse it correctly. Thanks.
Word order is crucial. The clue is “some do laps.” As in some CATS lap at milk/water. The attempt for a fresh clue fell flat for me.
Cats sometimes sit on people’s laps
Brilliant AVCX puzzle with a great AHA moment for me. Looking forward to Ben’s review.
I liked the NYT!