Joe DiPietro’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Utterly Gorgeous—Jim P’s review
Hafa Adai from Guam, where America’s day begins! A thousand thanks to Jenni for giving me a week off from blogging duties.
Clearly I’m still on island time because my solving time was very slow (and that’ll be my excuse for the next week)…and I needed help. There were a few phrases/words I’d never heard before and some tough crossings that got me.
But let’s start with the theme. 41d is DROP DEAD clued as [Utterly (gorgeous), and a hint to this puzzle’s theme]. Interesting that the entry is clued as a partial when “DROP DEAD!” is a perfectly cromulent phrase on its own. Anyhoo, we’re looking for phrases where the word “dead” has been removed.
- 17a [“No longer obsessed with what shape I’m in”?] OVER MY (dead) BODY. A little awkward, and I don’t see the need for the quotation marks. Well, I guess the base phrase, “over my dead body”, needs to be in quotation marks, so that’s probably why.
- 24a [Issue devoted to shoe protection] (dead) TREE EDITION. The clue didn’t help me one whit. Part of it is that I only just now realized that the word “Issue” is referring to a magazine issue and is not a synonym for “topic.” Second, shoe trees protect shoes? I’ve never used one nor seen one used.
- 51a [Ashes in a fireplace?] THE GRATEFUL (dead). Cute. I like this one.
- 61a [Win the human/thoroughbred race?] BEAT A (dead) HORSE. I’m glad this was clued with respect to racing rather than pummeling.
Overall this works, it’s just that I had issues with some of the cluing. Interesting to see an 8-letter revealer not alongside the other theme answers, but in the Down direction.
Those stacks of eight in the NW/SE corners, necessitated by the placement of the revealer, are impressive, but they aren’t without issue.
- Never heard of DECLASSE [Of inferior status], but the crossings were easy enough.
- Never heard of “SHOWS YOU” (1d, [“Be more prudent next time”]), and it seems to be ungoogleable. Am I parsing it correctly? That section was tough with that entry crossing YERBA, clued unfamiliarly as [___ mate (tealike drink)], and WEFT which crossed GERT. I didn’t want to believe any of my options, but I eventually got it all right without cheating.
It was the upper right where I needed help. 10A [“That’s ___”] could have a number of options (I couldn’t get MINE or FINE) out of my head, and 10d seemed to want LEGIT. Didn’t remember FALCON from the Avengers movie nor the COLT players. But getting that L at the FALCON/COLT crossing helped me to break through.
LOVEFEST makes for great fill. USE FORCE is strong as well.
I will leave you with UNMARRED [Pristine]. Guam is definitely marred in many places, but seeing a Guam sunset you can pretend, at least for a little while, that there is still some perfection in this world.
Hoang-Kim Vu’s New York Times crossword—Ben’s review
I like the Thursday NYT because there’s generally going to be something a little out of the ordinary going on. That’s certainly the case with this Thursday’s puzzle, and while it’s not the most innovative Thursday I’ve seen, it’s a concept that’s well-executed, and that counts for a lot.
The revealer at 9D mentions that, along with 39D, we’re looking to “fulfill requirements…or how to fill four of this puzzle’s squares?”. That answer turns out to be CHECK ALL THE BOXES, and that’s exactly what needs to be done for four sets of answers to fit in the grid:
- 2D: Preconcert job — MIC (CHECK)
- 20A: What the Constitution provides among the branches of government — (CHECK)S AND BALANCES
- 30A: Free rein — BLANK (CHECK)
- 33D: “Game over” — (CHECK) MATE
- 55A: Famous symbol of the Cold War — (CHECK)POINT CHARLIE
- 55D: Last step of a purchase — (CHECK)OUT
- 53A: Tipping point? — COAT (CHECK)
- 54D: One of 24 game pieces — (CHECK)ER
I’ll take a solidly executed rebus like this any time. Plus, there was some lovely personality to the fill! “YAS queen!”, clued as a “slangy affirmative”! KACEY Musgraves, who rightly got the Grammy for Album of the Year for Golden Hour! A kicky “Lightning Bolt” clue for USAIN! Long fill like FULL OF IT and EYE TO EYE! This one CHECK(ed) ALL THE BOXES for me.
Peter Gordon’s Fireball Crossword, “Tennis Tip: It’s In Net”–Jenni’s write-up
Crossword constructors notice things and file them away for future use. Peter noticed that two Wimbledon finalists had palindromic last names, found a relevant movie title with a palindromic last word, figured out that the letters worked out for grid symmetry, and created today’s theme.
- 18a [1992 Wimbledon finalist] is MONICA SELES.
- 26a [With 55-Across, film about two Wimbledon champions] is BATTLE OF THE SEXES. The champions were Billie Jean King and Bobby Riggs, and if you haven’t seen the movie, you should.
- 39a [2017 Wimbledon finalist] is MARIN CILIC.
- 66a [What 18-, 26-/55-, and 39-Across end with] are PALINDROMES.
Game, set, match.
A few other things:
- 11a [Main squeeze?] is LIME. Mmm, seltzer with lime…
- 31d [Some AARP members are part of it] is GEN X. Yup.
- 32a [Belvedere Gardens and Wellington Heights are two of its nabes] is EAST LA. I like the subtle signaling that we’re looking for the slang name with “nabes.”
- Patented Peter Gordon unusually long clue at 45a: [Play whose final stage direction is “[They slump onto their respective sofas. A long silence. The laughter dies away and they gaze at each other.]”] which is NO EXIT.
- 43d [First name of “The Queen of Gospel”] is MAHALIA. As in Jackson.
What I didn’t know before I did this puzzle: that XANADU was nominated for a Tony for Best Musical.
I leave you with The Queen.
Jules Markey’s Universal Crossword, “Turning Points”—Jim Q’s write-up
THEME: Phrases that include bending body parts with the word GO over each.
- 17A [*Extra effort in cleaning] ELBOW GREASE. No crosses needed!
- 24A [*Protesting at an NFL game] TAKING A KNEEE. No crosses needed!
- 38A [*Punch in the kisser] KNUCKLE SANDWICH.
- 61A [*Marine, colloquially] LEATHERNECK.
- 50A [Binge, or a hint to each starred answer’s body part and two letters above it] GO ON A BENDER.
Boy do I wish I read the whole revealer before just now. It makes it much more interesting and humorous, though I think the solve experience would be the same. I completely missed the fact that GO was atop each of the “benders.”
It also explains the extremely odd placement of the revealer. At 11 letters long, it could easily be put in the “correct” position where LEATHERNECK resides, but with the additional constraint of placing the letters G and O, I’m guessing it was too difficult to fill cleanly. That being said, it really threw me off- the revealer being where it was.
Nothing too bothersome fill-wise, which is impressive given the extra constructing challenge. I’ve been to SKAGWAY, but still had problems with that. LESAGE was new to me. A TAD crossing A GRIP is pretty yucky. And- ya’ know- OGEES. But all in all, just fine.
Brendan Emmett Quigley’s website crossword, “Boss Words'”—Andy’s review
This week, BEQ delivers a plug for next month’s Boswords, a crossword tournament held in Boston. This year’s Boswords will be held on July 28th, and I’ll be going for the first time this year! Join me, won’t you?
Brendan’s “Boss Words” gives us five phrases that begin with the surname of a TV boss:
- 17a, SLATE ROOFS [House coverings made of stone]. Mr. Slate, of The Flintstones.
- 24a, SCOTT TOWELS [Brawny rivals]. Michael Scott, of The Office.
- 38a, BURNS CALORIES [Does some cardio, say]. Mr. Burns, of The Simpsons.
- 53a, SOPRANO CLEF [It establishes middle C as the bottom line of a staff]. Tony Soprano, of The Sopranos.
- 62a, SKINNER BOX [Trick or treat container?]. Principal Skinner, also of The Simpsons.
A solid theme — I liked that it took getting a few theme answers to figure out what the theme was. A bit of cheeky cluing: back-to-back answers clued as [Booty] were TAIL and SEX.
A couple tough crossings in this one, like the Z of AMOS OZ [Israeli author of “Elsewhere, Perhaps”] and ZIA [Pakistani president of the 1980s] as well as the C of MEL C [Sporty Spice] and CDR [Cracked copy of Photoshop 6.0 holder, maybe].
A closing thought: if ORAJEL is oral relief in the form of a gel, is ORIGIN oral relief in the form of gin?
Until next week!
Bruce Haight’s LA Times crossword – Gareth’s summary
I appreciated the extra effort that went into the execution of this theme. The first layer of the theme is simply COMPANY, DEALER, FIRM, BUSINESS, CONCERN – five phrases end with synonyms for corporate entities. But the clues are also changed to be “?” style and describe a hypothetical type of organisation. Some of those clues are quite strained, and I can only assume All is an American brand of washing powder or similar.
Nines and fourteens in one puzzle make for an irregular grid design, but this seems to have been juggled quite well. The only really contrived answer was RPMS. AOLMAIL is an entry I haven’t encountered before, and since AOL isn’t really a thing here I was skeptical, but it does seem that is what there email is called. My mistake was LORIMeR/LeMARR – crossing proper names at dubious vowels is often my (our?) downfall.
What’s up with the American stereotype that MATE (and BUSH and UNI) are Australian-only words? Refer to British duo Right Said Fred’s You’re My Mate to find the English using it for example (but only if you’re very brave).
Excellent NYT debut puzzle. Congratulations, Hoang-Kim!
Very enjoyable solve. Congrats on this debut!
NYT: Yes, excellent NYT– a classic Thursday. I actually appreciate it when constructors experiment with different ideas, but it’s also great to get a known format that’s well executed. It reminds you why that genre became classic.
Yes. Shoe trees are very good at protecting your shoes. They preserve the shape [of the toe, in particular], help to minimize creases, and, if made of cedar, help your shoes smell nicer.
Oh the joys of expensive shoes that one takes care of for years and years … I bet you have a beautifully organized closet.
I wonder if “protecting” is misleading for the youngers (who are less likely to know about shoe trees, because cheaper, disposable goods have become the norm) — “protecting” suggests a waterproofing spray or a cloth bag to protect from dust. “Preserve” (which you also used) might have been a better verb (though cooks might think of culinary preservation!).
I find Thursday WSJ to be my most consistently enjoyable puzzle. Today again.
LAT – This was very good today. My rating of 4 would have been a 5 except for the last one. I wanted “Place to get help with estate planning” to be GOINGCONCERN, which I think is a lot more in the language than PASSINGCONCERN. Alas, this didn’t fit, of course.
UNIVERSAL – this was excellent, too, a 4.5 from me. I enjoyed the pay-off very much.
Thank you Paul.
I second Paul’s comment about UNIVERSAL. It was so fun to recognize what “Go on a Bender” meant in this puzzle!
Peter’s title for Fireball is also a palindrome…Bravo!
And an incredibly strained palindrome at that…Fireball has been really disappointing lately.
LAT and UNIV both had TREVI in their fill — interesting coincidence (it’s a not-so-common answer).
WSJ: Can anyone explain how “Be more careful next time” = SHOWS YOU? That Y crossing with YERBA (mate?) was guesswork for me.
To child who has ignored parental warning to walk slowly on the icy sidewalk and has fallen on her keister: “Well, that just shows you. Be careful next time.”
It just shows to go you.
It was not cited on this page but on the June 27th Newsday puzzle “Doublers” by Pam Klawitter, 32 across came out “NMI” for clue: abbreviation on an application form. Any idea about that?? Sorry to say it’s stumping me what that’s an acronym for. Thx.
Kenneth, I think”NMI” is “no middle initial.”
Late doing the puzzle, but BEQ: Skinner is also Mulder and Scully’s boss on X-Files.