Pancho Harrison’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Broken Glass”—Jim P’s review
PRISM (69a, [Light refractor, or, when broken into three parts, a hint to the theme answers]) is our revealer today, except you have to break it in the following fashion: PR IS M. In other words, our theme is phrases where one of the words has the bigram PR changed to a single M.
- 20a [“You will not talk during your show,” say?] MIME DIRECTIVE. This one’s funnier than I first gave it credit for because I thought it was going to be MIME DIRECTION. But I can envision a mime exhorting themself to follow the MIME DIRECTIVE.
- 34a [Rarely used veterinary service?] MICE FIXING. Maybe it’s rare, but surely it’s been done to some degree, yeah? A lot of people have mice as pets. I’d love to see a funnier clue here. Perhaps something to do with Mickey and Minnie deciding not to have children?
- 42a [What you might do while garnishing a julep?] FINGER MINT. Meh. This sounds kinda creepy.
- 57a [“No more tracking mud into this house, and I mean it!”?] STOP THE MESSES. I don’t quite see these statements as being equal. How about a clue involving Felix Unger? (I mean the fictional Felix Unger, not the real one.)
As letter-changing themes go, this works fine. There’s some humor here, but I feel like it could have easily been ratcheted up to good effect. I do like the use of the word PRISM as the basis for the theme.
In the fill I’ll highlight AD NAUSEAM (and I even spelled it correctly this time, ending it with -AM instead of -UM), MASTIFF, RAT PACK, THE ASP, and FONDUE. Do people do FONDUE much anymore? We like to do it a couple times a year maybe, but only if time and mood allows.
There’s a fair amount of crosswordese in the fill (RFD, CBER, IAMB, ETS, RELOS, ANAS, AS AM I, etc.), and it gets to be a bit much. There’s nothing too outlandish, but it does weigh the grid down. Good grief! I just spotted that fifth row with STS, UTES, and IN ESSE. That’s a contender for the crosswordeseiest row, for sure.
Cluing felt unusually straightforward for a Thursday, judging by my relatively speedy time. I will point out 8d‘s clue [“Totes awesome, dude!”] for EPIC. Granted, I’m not the one to ask what kids are saying these days, but “Totes awesome, dude!” does not ring true. As Urban Dictionary puts it in its top definition for totes, “This word is commonly used by teenage girls.” This means, combining it with bro-ey “dude” and “EPIC” just doesn’t work.
Good wordplay on display here, but it could have used a bit more humor and a bit less crosswordese. 3.5 stars.
Peter Gordon’s Fireball Crossword, “Themeless 131”–Jenni’s write-up
I was very glad to see a puzzle with both vowels and consonants. It was a good puzzle, too – a bit harder than the last few FB themelesses.
I suspect the central grid-spanner was the seed entry for the puzzle: 35a [Melatonin product from Vicks] is ZZZQUIL PURE ZZZS. Who could resist that collection of Zs? Not Peter! And he’s skillful enough that the crossing entries did not feel forced.
Other things I liked:
- 17a [Some breaded cutlets] are SCHNITZELS, not SCALLOPINE. The plural is a little roll-your-own but SCHNITZEL is delicious, so I give it a pass.
- 20a [Product with the ad slogan “Say hello to the future”] is the IPHONE X. This took me a little while to parse despite the fact that I own one. Silly me.
- 36d [2018 GLAAD Media Award winner for Outstanding Reality Program] is the reboot of QUEER EYE.
- 39d [Carrier of reporters and TV crews that accompanies Air Force One] is the ZOO PLANE. Why do I suspect that Air Force One is more of a zoo these days?
- 64a [Places with digital files] are NAIL SALONS.
What I didn’t know before I did this puzzle: that ALCATRAZ was home to the West Coast’s first lighthouse, and that KTEL made something called the Blitzhacker food chopper.
Doug Peterson’s New York Times crossword—Ben’s review
This felt like a really solid Thursday puzzle to me. Exactly what I look for from this venue on this day – something out-of-the-box, grid-wise (like a rebus square), and reasonably mid-week cluing:
- 17A: Employs — B(RING)S INTO PLAY
- 25A: “Yellow Submarine” vocalist — (RING)O STARR
- 32A: Extremely awkward — C(RING)EWORTHY
- 42A: Exerts one’s clout — PULLS ST(RING)S
- 53A: Mid-March shout — E(RIN G)O BRAGH
- 61A: It’s usually presented in a small box, as seen six times in this puzzle’s answer — ENGAGEMENT (RING)
Again, the execution on the theme here is super clean. A tight set of answers that put the (RING) squares in a nice distribution across the theme answers, and down fill that also feels straightforward – SYRINGE, ALLURING, PRINGLE, PARINGS, WRING OUT, and KRINGLE. Some the fill towards the edges of the grid (like ISPS, SASE, STR) is less than ideal, but I liked the references to KAL Penn and IDA Lupino in the upper right’s cluing.
I was absurdly proud of my ability to spell SUSSUDIO correctly on the first try without any crossings. If you’re a fan of music podcasts, I highly recommend Slate’s Hit Parade, which talked about the chart dominance Genesis and its offshoots (including the careers of Peter Gabriel and Phil Collins) had in the 80s.
Happy Thursday, all!
Brendan Emmett Quigley’s website crossword, “The Corp. Is In Session”—Andy’s review
A pretty simple theme today, made fairly clear by the title: Change “T” sounds to “P” sounds, to punny effect:
- 17a, MARIO CARP [Serious complaint from author Puzo?]. Mario Kart.
- 56a, BURP PARKS [Outdoor areas where one can belch?]. Bert Parks.
- 11d, DISH THE DERP [Dole out an expression of stupidity?]. Dish the dirt.
- 25d, HARP AND SOUL [Two things an angel must have while covering Aretha Franklin?]. “Heart and Soul.”
As far as I can tell, there’s no revealer, which is totally fine since it’s not necessary. I’m also not sure if there’s a reason to have the number 8 in the grid (8-BIT crossing 8-PM at 1a/1d) other than “Why not?”.
A few other notes:
- The quote from Gloria STEINEM at 20a, [“Some of us are becoming the men we wanted to marry” speaker] is a really pithy distillation of second-wave feminism.
- Always happy to see 43a, DON’T AT ME [“I’m not looking for a response,” on Twitter].
- If you didn’t know the MEME clue [“I’m baby,” e.g.], you can read more here. Or not. I’m not in charge of you.
- You can listen to [Ahmad Jamal’s instrument], the PIANO, below:
Until next time!
David Poole’s LA Times crossword – Gareth’s summary
I think this puzzle’s theme can best be described as quirky. The revealer, SPYVSSPY, divides the grid in two left and right halves. I feel like that left-right apposition is used at least on some occasions in the strip? It’s been a while. The actual SPYs are represented by 3 triplets of circled letters. Read vertically, they spell CIA and KGB. Two make these circles a tad more significant, when read across, each answer uses the circled letter as a stand-alone letter. We have: CSECTION, IPHONE and AFRAME on the American side and COACHK, KENNYG and VITAMINB on the Soviet.
[“Miracle on Ice” winners: Abbr.], USA. But not winners against England in their (Men’s) Rugby World Cup opening game today. Canada also played today, losing to Italy. (South Africa also lost their first game, though it was to New Zealand, and barring upsets, both teams should qualify.)
Read all about the puzzle at Wordplay! It’s such a sweet story!
THIS! I had no clue and it made the puzzle even sweeter.
Sorry, new here. What / where is Wordplay? Google didn’t turn up an obvious reference to your comment.
I enjoyed this puzzle despite having it spoiled on Facebook after the Pleasantville tourney – I suspect I would have gotten it quickly anyway. Nice Thursday.
Strange. The print version of the NYT carries a different puzzle, by Randolph Ross.
Thanks for posting this discrepancy. I’ve been clicking around trying to figure out what was wrong.
Having attended the annual Sing-a-Long Sound of Music showing at the Hollywood Bowl last weekend, 17A in yesterday’s Fireball puzzle was a gimme. “Doorbells and sleigh bells and schnitzel with noodles …” (from “My Favorite Things”, of course).
hooray to the LAT for having the print version in larger type font