Tess Davison and Kathy Lowden’s New York Times crossword—Jenni’s review
According to Deb Amlen’s Wordplay column, Tess and Kathy are mother and daughter, and this is their debut. I enjoyed this theme, which has a number of layers. I didn’t really care about the circles. The rest was fun.
We have five theme answers clued as months. For some reason the months are shouting at us.
- 17a [JULY] is RUBIES.
- 18a [MAY] is EMERALDS.
- 37a [FEBRUARY] is AMETHYSTS.
- 60a [APRIL] is DIAMONDS.
- 62a [JUNE] is PEARLS.
You can see that the circled letters spell BIRTHSTONES. We also have 11a, [One of 17-, 18-, 37-, 60- or 62-Across], which is GEM, and 22d, [Rough, as an 11-Across], UNCUT. That’s a lot of theme material for a 15×15. The fill doesn’t suffer, which is impressive.
A few other things:
- 6d [Part of Manhattan where the United Nations is located] is the EAST SIDE. Am I the only one who started singing “East side, west side, all around the town…”?
- I had the last three letters of 35a, [Ill-tempered, as a baby] and was surprised that the NYT would use PISSY. They didn’t. It’s FUSSY.
- I dropped in AIRFOIL for 44d, [Airplane wing feature]. Wrong. It’s AILERON.
- If this were an indie puzzle, DOM would have a different clue, not [___ Pérignon].
- 45d [Shell-less marine invertebrate] is the very unappealing SEA SLUG.
What I didn’t know before I did this puzzle: most of the birthstones. I was born in July, so I knew that one.
Nice work, Tess and Kathy! I look forward to seeing more from you, either separately or together.
Evan Kalish’s Universal crossword, “Waterside”—Rebecca’s review
THEME: Water drops have fallen off the sides of the grid as the start or end of themed answers
- 16A [Infamous headline about the 1948 election] DEWEY DEFEATS TRUMAN
- 27A [Classic movie quote spoken mindlessly?] IF I ONLY HAD A BRAIN
- 42A [“That didn’t go as planned”] MISTAKES WERE MADE
- 56A [Opts for a more private life, or a feature of 16-, 27- and 42-Across?] DROPS OFF THE GRID
Once I figured out what was going on, I loved this puzzle. As a Wizard of Oz fanatic, IF I ONLY HAD A BRAIN was the first theme answer that I got, which helped a lot. Really perfect use of the phrase DROPS OFF THE GRID and solid choices for all of the theme answers made for a really enjoyable solve all around.
Interesting grid design also allowed for some enjoyable bonuses. HOME ALONE, WORK PARTY, and HOT KEYS were my favorites, but really every part of the puzzle had something that made it exciting to solve and interesting to work through.
I also have to mention the great clue for SUM [4039, for 2019 and 2020].
Gary Larson’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Fast Forward”—Jim P’s review
The apt title is a good indication of today’s synonym theme. The first word in each entry is a synonym for “fast.”
- 17a [Alkaline substance used in plaster] QUICKLIME
- 19a [Cornmeal mush] HASTY PUDDING. I’ve heard of this but had no idea what it was. Here’s a good primer on the dish.
- 35a [Naval tradition in major ports] FLEET WEEK
- 53a [Drink sold by Pepsi Lipton] BRISK ICED TEA. I had no idea Pepsi was involved in this.
- 57a [Town near Mount Rushmore] RAPID CITY. My brother used to be stationed at nearby Ellsworth AFB, and I visited him once there while I was in college. Other worthy sights nearby include the Badlands, Devil’s Tower, and Wall Drug.
The rest of the grid is solidly filled though none too sparkly. Top hits for me: SASHIMI, RAT TAIL, PLAYBILL, EXPLICIT, and MASALA. Did you know that one of the favourite dishes in Britain (by most measures) is Chicken Tikka Masala? Although, as with many popular foods, there is some argument is to its origin.
Let’s see. What else? Not much except to say I’m impressed with those NW and SE corners with stacks of sevens and all clean crossings. Well done.
A fast and breezy start to the week. 3.8 stars.
Patrick Berry’s New Yorker crossword – Rachel’s writeup
This felt very hard, but my time was only slightly higher than average for a Monday New Yorker, so I’m not sure exactly how to rate the difficulty. I do know how to rate the quality of the puzzle though: so many stars!
There’s some unusual segmentation happening around the middle, where the marquee 15-er is SELF-DRIVING CARS (“They’re beyond your control”). (Sidebar: Is this true? I thought most SELF-DRIVING CARS had, like, emergency controls that a passenger could employ if necessary? I have never ridden in a SELF-DRIVING CAR, and I think if they are *truly* beyond your control, then I may not be brave enough to try it anytime soon). Anyways, back to that segmentation! The black squares pretty neatly divide into wide-open corners in the NW, NE, SW, SE, with fewer connections across than you might normally expect. This allows for lots of medium-to-long entries stacked all over the place, including some impressive vertical 4-stacks of 8s in the NW and SE. The triple stacks in the other two corners are also excellent, with IN BAD TASTE/COLD DISHES/SNEETCHES taking the win for best stack.
A few other things:
- I always though a FLOPHOUSE was a brothel, but clearly that is not the case. Oops.
- Names I didn’t know: NIJINSKY, Billy Wilder and LEMMON.
- The cluing felt really tough! Some highlights:
- “Course load? for GOLF BAGS
- “Short end?” for BOBTAIL
- Here’s another “you did it!” cartoon with a non-crossword in it (now I’m going to notice these every time and be super annoying about it).
Overall, again, lots of stars for this beautiful Patrick Berry themeless.
Craig Stowe’s Los Angeles Times crossword—Nate’s write-up
17A: LIBERTY BELL [American independence symbol with a storied crack]
25A: BIRD ON A WIRE [1990 Gibson/Hawn film]
35A: LUCK OF THE DRAW [Pure chance in poker and lotteries]
50A: FINGER LAKES [Group of narrow bodies of water in upstate New York]
58A: LEADING LADY [Female box office star, and what the starts of the answers to starred clues can have]
Nice! The first word of each theme entry can have the word “lady” in front of it: Lady Liberty, Ladybird, Lady Luck, and ladyfingers. You know that I’m always going on about featuring women in puzzles more regularly / prominently, so this was nice to see. (Now if only they’d pay a LEADING LADY as much as they do male box office stars…)
Other random thoughts:
– In addition to the theme, the grid includes women like [“Chicago” showgirl] ROXIE, ABBESS, and DOES. But that’s it. So, for as much as I appreciate the women-centric theme, I’d have loved to see actual women represented throughout the puzzle, if even in updated cluing for this same grid. As for men in the grid, we have PABLO / PICASSO, HAL, ABE Lincoln, MAN, REESES, Oscar Madison, NWA, bucks, JAY Leno, and Brian ENO.
– Loved seeing NWA and appreciated the “I’m going to work out” New Year’s resolution mini-theme (REP, GYM, SALADS). OPAH didn’t excite me, but the grid was otherwise smooth.
– I was really happy to see the gender-neutral cluing for END IT: [Break up with a partner]. Loved that bit of inclusivity!
Nice Monday NYT.
Nice Tuesday or Wednesday NYT. Not sure why it ran on a Monday.
NYT – I found quite a bit of fill that I thought was either tough for a Monday, crosswordese or poor partials/abbreviations, including VAR, GEENA (at least for younger solvers….definitely not me), AGT, GAT, AFTRA, AILERON, SEASLUG, ERG, RANI, ASA, RAISA and RES. I’m a slow solver and my time was nearly 30% above my Monday average.
I forgot ELMIRA.
The “very unappealing sea slug” is actually one of a group of some of the most beautiful animals on the planet. I know you’re referring to the name but figured it’s a good opportunity to show off these invertebrates in all their glory.
Yes! Some of them are downright adorable, and there is a wide variety in structure and décor. I had forgotten how fun they are to look at. Thanks for the link.
Thanks, Martin. Gorgeous creatures!
Gorgeous. Like poison dart frogs and monarch butterflies, sea slugs use their bright colors to warn potential predators that they’re toxic and distasteful.
LAT unavailable at cruciverb?
WSJ standard stuff.
NYT – great for the Mother and Daughter team, double dose of female constructors. I did find it uneven with fill all over the map, (I have a heavy disdain for) random circles, only five gemstones (Including my lame-a$$ PEARL (/ Moonstone) – COCAINE & ACID (not that acid) and RAISA my old chum I haven’t seen for what – 20 years?
Forgot to do New Yorker ….
I am not a complete idiot. I run a successful business, I am a mechanical engineer, a private pilot, well traveled, and know 5 computer languages but not until today has my six month quest to find the answer to the WSJ crossword contest been satisfied. Someone posted a link to your site in the discussion blog.
I ended up reading you solutions for almost an hour. Every so often the make a technical mistake in their clues and now I have some where to send my observations. At least once per week they throw in the clue “Yoko of music” which is weak, no disrespect intended.
Thank you so much Amy!
Yes, it’s wonderful here.
Rather than clutter up with another post, I want to laud the New Yorker Puzzle. Side by side OCLOCK and ONIONS in vertical mode (I have real trouble with vertical except when I solve a puzzle that way intentionally!) made me look foolish, but I loved the puzzle, Berry is so talented and fresh!
Where is BEQ themeless write up?
BEQ – Right?! I so wanted to read Jim Q’s take on 58A.