Mike Shenk’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Split Personalities”—Jim P’s review
I didn’t fully grok the theme until after the solve. I could see that the main theme entries were all bent upwards at the beginning, but I couldn’t understand why. Then I realized those Down entries are palindromes, and looking at it from the perspective of the main theme answer, the beginning is split in both the Up and Down directions. Pretty cool.
- 18a [Director’s assistant] ST(A)GE MANAGER with 5d STATS
- 29a [Boastful sort] SE(L)F PROMOTER with 23d SELES
- 42a [Rock specialist] MI(N)ERALOGIST with 30d MINIM
- 55a [Court worker] TE(N)NIS PLAYER with 47d TENET
Like I said, this was pretty cool, but given the title, it seems like it would make more sense if the split came at the end of the theme entries. Here we start at the split and come together to form the rest of the themer. I guess it’s just a matter of perspective.
And I can’t find any significance of the word “personalities” in the title. The words STAGE, SELF, MINERAL, and TENNIS are split but there doesn’t seem to be any connection. I think it’s just because the term is idiomatic. “Split Decisions” might work better since the reader can decide whether to read upward or downward.
Anyway, on to the fill. I felt like I was not on the right wavelength for most of the solve, but maybe that was because I was still trying to sort out the theme. I’m not keen on SAPLESS [Lacking vitality] which I tried to make HAPLESS for a while, but that’s about the iffiest entry in the grid. Much better are PIED PIPER with a great clue [Leading figure in folklore] and ONION SOUP as well as WIRETAP, GOES PRO, FORESEE, and CARCASS.
Clues of note:
- 15a [Bad things for bluffers]. TELLS. I had CALLS here at first. Anyone else?
- 20a [Drags through the mud]. I’d say “drags through the mud” is a lot worse than DIRTIES.
- 25a [Filled with four-letter words]. I counted 20 four-letter words in this grid. I wouldn’t call that “filled,” so maybe this puzzle isn’t too COARSE.
- 27a [Like Russian Caravan tea]. SMOKY. Yeah, how am I supposed to know that? There’s nothing that relates the words “Russian Caravan tea” to the answer unless you happen to know it. See also 38d [Slavko Avsenik composition] for POLKA. Oh, Slavko Avsenik is a person and “composition” here means “written piece of music.” At least that one’s inferable.
- 40a [One doing the lord’s work]. SERF. Fave clue right there because it totally got me. I completely missed the lowercase L. SIMILARly, its crossing, 41d, is clued [Divine] but doesn’t mean godly; it’s the verb meaning FORESEE.
- 44a [Betelgeuse site]. ORION. I just learned, yesterday I think, that Betelgeuse is ORION‘s armpit. As a matter of fact, the name comes from Arabic which translates to “the armpit of ORION.” That’s according to Wikipedia, anyway.
Fun theme which I enjoyed unpacking, and plenty to like in the fill. Clues got thorny at times, but it is Thursday after all. 3.9 stars.
Paul Coulter’s Fireball crossword, “Either Way You Look at It”—Jim P’s review
Jim P here sitting in for the vacationing Jenni.
Paul Coulter brings us today’s clever puzzle which has sort of a Shrödinger theme. In a Shrödinger puzzle, a clue can have more than one answer, and the crossing entries are crafted in such a way that the letter changes still work with their carefully-worded clues. Here though, each theme clue still has two answers, but the letters put into the grid are exactly the same for both answers. The only question is where do you place the word break. Thankfully, the clues give us that information parenthetically. Supply your own punctuation where needed.
- 17a [Squeeze pieces of land? (4,5 or 5,4)]. Either CRAM PLOTS or CRAMP LOTS.
- 27a [Film reviewer’s terse pan? (4,4 or 5,3)]. Either “CRUD EPIC” or “CRUDE PIC“.
- 50a [Exclamation at an untrustworthy encounter? (4,4 or 5,3)]. Either “SCAM…POOH!” or “SCAMP…OOH!”
- 63a [Unimpressed reactions to a tree? (5,4 or 6,3)]. Either BALSA MEHS or BALSAM EHS.
- 10d [What might cause picnickers to leave? (3,4 or 4,3)]. Either BEE ROUT or BEER OUT.
- 44d [Greenery fury? (3,4 or 4,3)]. Either LEA FIRE or LEAF IRE.
I love this idea. If you’re one who loves playing with words, then I can’t think of anything more word-playful than this! My favorite is the first one I uncovered (the BEE/BEER one), but the CRUD/CRUDE one is smooth as well. The CRAM/CRAMP one is fine, too.
But unfortunately the rest felt really forced, especially the BALSA/BALSAM one. I didn’t even know there was such a thing as a balsam tree. And MEHS/EHS as nouns is just bleh.
I wonder if the clues would have worked without the parenthetical information. As it is, as soon as I saw it, I knew what was going to happen. Would I have been able to figure out without that? I have no idea, but I guess a certain percentage of solvers might not have, and Peter and Paul probably didn’t want to leave too many solvers disgruntled.
I nearly got stuck in that central upper-left area because I’ve never ever heard of the word FILLIP [Incentive] and I had I_INESS for [Reserve] and could not see that a C would go in there. LAMINA [Thin layer] was another tough one for me since PATINA fit so well. Oh, and I actually did finish with an error at 27d CZARS [Drug kingpins?], which, for some reason, I wanted to be CBERS. My erroneous crossings (BETAS and EST) seemed reasonable. Maybe it’s one of those Shrödinger things.
Other than those stumbling blocks, pretty good fill with LAMBADA, ORDEAL, TOENAIL, RANDO, and the double helping of SPUNKY and UPTEMPO near the end.
Clues of note:
- 6d [Reading room with one place to sit?]. LOO. Oh, I see what you did there. Reading, the town in England. Gotcha.
- 33d [Get a lead on]. LEASH. Another Brit-centric clue since they use the word “lead” in place of “leash.”
- 51d [Home of many fourteeners]. ALASKA. I have no idea on this. Anyone with this knowledge at their fingertips want to help us out here?
- 55d [Camp Swampy bulldog]. OTTO. I like this clue, mainly because I read it wrong as “Camp Swampy Bulldog.” I had no idea what it might mean, but I loved the idea of a camp called “Swampy Bulldog.” Turns out this is OTTO from the comic strip Beetle Bailey.
- 65d [Bud’s bud]. LOU. Referring to Bud Abbott and Lou Costello. Ask your grandparents, kids.
Super clever theme though the actual entries didn’t shine as much as I’d hoped. But on the strength of the wordplay, four stars from me.
Erik Agard and Jeff Chen’s New York Times crossword—Ben’s review
Today’s NYT is a Erik Agard/Jeff Chen collaboration that I really enjoyed. spotting what was going on took a second, partially because this is more of a sound-based theme than a visual theme:
- 21A: Word following sing or play — NIA LONG
- 23A: Furrowed feature — BROWNIE
- 27A: Language that’s the source of “gesundheit” — JOURNEYMAN
- 51A: The mister, affectionately — HONEYBEE
- 34D: Study of rocks — GENEALOGY
- 37D: What five answers in this puzzle do phonetically, in defiance of their clues? — TAKE A KNEE
As clued, the five across entries should be ALONG, BROW, GERMAN, HUBBY, and GEOLOGY, but in taking a “knee” sound, become the answers above. The right-left symmetry here (instead of standard symmetry) is nice, but the uneven distribution of answers feels a smidge off
Elsewhere in the grid:
- I needed so many crossings to get INUKTITUT.
- CROWD NOISE, APPLE JACKS, and EXAM TABLE were all nice longer fill.
- I had SLAV for “Lithuanian, e.g.”, but they’re a BALTic nation. Here’s some Lithuanian pop to close this out:
Ken Albright’s Universal crossword, “Refurnishing”—Jim Q’s review
A puzzle after IKEA’s heart…
THEME: Colloquial phrases that include items of furniture are reimagined as if they are actual items of furniture.
17A [Furniture for a reporter] NEWS BUREAU.
- 23A [Furniture for a clotheshorse] SNAPPY DRESSER.
- 49A [Furniture for a chemist] PERIODIC TABLE.
- 60A [Furniture for a spikey-haired singer] PUNK ROCKER.
As long as you don’t overthink it, this is a solid set of themers. If you start thinking too much though… well, a spikey-haired singer is a PUNK ROCKER. A clotheshorse is a SNAPPY DRESSER. But a chemist isn’t a PERIODIC TABLE… and a reporter isn’t a NEWS BUREAU. A reporter, of course, works in the NEWS industry, but alas a chemist doesn’t work in the PERIODIC industry.
So there’s that layer of inconsistency. But still a nice set.
Mostly solid fill rounds it out- AS WE SPEAK was particularly nice. Coulda done with out BAAS, OREM, and LOW–NECKED. I’d appreciate SKI POLE more if it weren’t slightly duped in the clue for 52D.
Love the title!
3.1 Stars from me.
Brendan Emmett Quigley crossword (No. 1227), “Course Prep”—Ade’s take
Good afternoon, everyone! Some winter storms are bearing down on a number of us in the next day or so, so hope you’re all prepared!
Today’s puzzle might have left you, well, puzzled, if you tried to find the theme and were not familiar with a 2017 New York Times bestseller. When putting together the first word of each of the four longest theme entries, in order, you get “Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat,” which is the title of a award-winning cookbook written by cook, writer and Netflix star Samin Nosrat.
- SALT LAKE CITY (20A: [Headquarters for the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints])
- FAT CHANCE OF THAT (28A: [“Yeah, [snort] right!”])
- ACID WASHED JEANS (44A: [Retro chic denim selection])
- HEAT OF BATTLE (51A: [When the most intense fighting occurs])
I knew of the book title that was the inspiration of the theme, but only faintly, and when I plunked in “bell-bottom jeans” instead of ACID WASHED JEANS, it hung me up even longer in trying to see what was going on with whatever theme there might be. Took a couple of minutes to get the bell bottoms out of my grid (and even longer to get out of my mind), and then I was golden after that. Totally was taken on a ride on memory lane with the clue for NES, as a few of my friends in elementary school used to go over to our friend’s place after school to play with the Game Genie and Power Glove he owned (39D: [Video game platform with a Power Glove controller]). Nice to know the tidbit in the clue to AFRICOLA (8D: [Soft drink that, despite its name, is actually German]). There’s a Mexican restaurant chain near me called Dos Toros, and I initially wanted to put that in instead of the less-familiar (to me, at least) DEL TACO, but, obviously, it wouldn’t fit (4D: [Fresh Mexican grill franchise]). I had never heard of THALIA before today but, from what I just read, has been a critically-acclaimed musician, despite her relative anonymity in the music world (25D: [Punk rocker Zedek]). I’ll have to give a couple of her tunes a listen later on today!
“Sports will make you smarter” moment of the day: BODE (6D: [Alpine ski racer Miller]) – The United States has produced a number of standout skiers who excelled in international competitions, but Bode (pronounced “BO-dee”) Miller is arguably the country’s best-ever skier. Miller is the owner of six Olympic medals, winning two silvers in the 2002 SALT LAKE CITY games and three more medals in the 2010 Vancouver Olympics, including his one and only Olympic gold medal in the super combined discipline. Along with his Olympic success, Miller won four gold medals and a silver during World Championships competition, and is only one of five men — and 12 skiers in total — to win FIS Alpine Skiing World Cup events in all five disciplines (downhill, slalom, giant slalom, Super-G, combined).
Thank you so much for your time, friends! Have a great rest of your day and, as always, keep solving!!
NYT: I came here to see what a HOBEE was (assuming it was modern slang), but I see it makes a heck of a lot more sense as HUBBY. With a couple of languages in the grid (one modified with that “NEE” sound), I was interpreting the revealer at first to imply these languages don’t have that sound (“in defiance”).
You missed a great opportunity to link to this video!
I was completely stumped by JOURNEYMAN, and ended up with a DNF. Also, GENEALOGY would have stopped me if JOURNEYMAN didn’t. I’m quite sure that I wouldn’t have gotten either one. Just not my flavor of puzzle today.
Same here. GERMAN fits for the last six letters, because 29D can be GETS instead of NETS. Then I didn’t know whether 42A was STOP or STOW, so that whole section baffled me.
Same for me.
I had CALLS for TELLS in the WSJ, too. Iit messed things up toward getting the whole idea (and I definitely resisted what appeared to be SAPLESS, sure I had a mistake). I don’t know poker, and after all “call” in that sense in everyday language (“called his bluff”) apart from poken is so common. In fact, “tell” in that sense appears in neither MW11C nor RHUD.
NYT: I did finish and get the theme, but came close to Natick City a couple of times– e.g. INUKTITUT and ATL. The B in EBOOK/BALT was the last to drop…
But INUKTITUT is cool to know about… I might take it up someday, for the love of vowels…
There’s a fun video all in Inuktitut. Go to Youtube and search for The Jerry Cans Mamaqtuq.
I didn’t like this NYT crossword. There were so many letter changes and no clues to the actual answers–to me it all seemed arbitrary.
Thank you for the tip, Amy L. The Jerry Cans are great, and the various videos range from cute to really moving.
I think I like this one best– Amazing scenery.
Ancient name for Ceylon = LANKA. But Wikipedia explains Lanka as a mythological city whose location came to be identified with what is now Sri Lanka. So this seems like cluing Atlantis as an ancient name for Malta, for example.
Jim P re Fireball: I think “fourteeners” refers to mountains (to be climbed) that are 14,000 feet high.
Thanks for that!
EMQ: I really like that book and the Netflix series… It’s an interesting re-conceptualization of food and cooking. And the recipes and settings are great. My grandson and I used her olive oil episode as inspiration for making focaccia together.
I pronounce GENEALOGY with a soft “a” so GEOLOGY didn’t work for me. Anyone else? Am I wrong in the pronounciation?
I couldn’t agree more, Alan. I come from a long line of genealogists and have heard and used this word regularly for a very substantial chunk of my life. In fact, that pronunciation is the only way I can remember how to spell it. I have the utmost respect for both Erik and Jeff as cruciverbalists, but imho, this puzzle is very much a puzzle for constructors and not solvers (at least not this one).
BEQ — tough cross at 43-D/61-A
Brilliant puzzle WSJ, but I needed help in the form of the Diary. Some of the crosses wee too tough to parse out and I had a really broken up day and didn’t devote a block of to this amazing puzzle.
No LAT again today. Is Gareth sick? And how is Amy?
Everyone please get well soon!