Robyn Weintraub’s New York Times crossword—Amy’s write-up
Dang, this one was fast! If you were hoping the puzzle would eat up lots of spare housebound time (me, I don’t have extra hours to kill, since I’d been working from home all along), so sorry, somehow this crossword was not the one that was going to drag things out for hours. Played like a Tuesday for me, go figure.
Robyn’s packed this JEWEL of a puzzle with lots of spoken phrases. The crossword has struck up a conversation with us. IT’S A START, right? I’d like to PROPOSE A TOAST to the primary ELECTORATE and our stalwart RUNNERS-UP who ran a good campaign. “ANY TAKERS?” Come on, folks—LET’S ROLL.” What’s that? You’d rather CALL IT A DAY than go out? Why are you so tired? “NO REASON.” (There’s also “ARE WE THERE YET?”)
Other fill I liked: PEABRAIN, TOP SCORE, GARAGE SALE, TOUCH-TYPES, OFF BALANCE. Oh! And LIFE LESSON, [Product of a teachable moment].
Clues that popped out:
- 39a. [Seasonal pickers] ELECTORATE. Not farm workers, nope.
- 55a. [45’s better half], SIDE A. Do they still make 45 rpm records? I feel like the terms of art are A-side and B-side, though, rather than this SIDE A presentation. Yes? At any rate, you had me scared with “45” and I’m glad it was a vinyl mislead.
- 7d. [Noted characteristic of a corpse flower], ODOR. Ah, yes, the titan arum, Amorphophallus titanum. The Chicago Botanic Garden has had a couple blooms in recent years. I … did not drive up there to smell it. Not a fan of stenches. (Great clue angle.)
- 25d. [Get off the street, in a way], PLOW. Ugh, snow. It’s now the second half of April and yet snow is heading towards Chicagoland. Although hey, I’m ready for it because (a) I woke up to a couple inches of snow on the ground a day or two ago, and (b) I wasn’t planning to leave the house anyway. The snow will melt before we’d get around to clearing it off the car. (Good clue.)
- 27d. [Unable to stick the landing, say], OFF-BALANCE. Gymnastics clue, nice. Want to see Simone Biles OFF-BALANCE? Sorry, the video below is typical Biles, sticking her landings and having a preternatural sense of balance.
- 30d. [Enters without looking, say], TOUCH-TYPES. Oh! Thought the answer would be about someone backing through a doorway or something.
4.25 stars from me.
Elizabeth C. Gorski’s New Yorker crossword – Rachel’s writeup
This puzzle was a delight from the very first clue/entry pair. “Baby showers?” for DRIZZLE has got to be the cutest pun I have encountered in a long time, and from now on I propose we all refer to DRIZZLE as baby showers. That this crossed the Bruno Mars weather forecast IT WILL RAIN was a just a cherry on top of this adorable corner that also includes ZEBRA MUSSEL and LUANN and ROWBOAT.
Other good long stuff included LOTTO WINNER, HASHMARKS, and SPONGEBOB (which is a cartoon I dislike but an entry I appreciate!). Going back through the puzzle, I can find very little to critique here. I loved SPUMONI! I loved MARISKA (after whom I named one of my d&d characters in the two online campaigns I’ve started since the world shut down)! I once met a Harlem Globetrotter nicknamed TOO TALL who was 5’2, so even though I didn’t know Ed Jones, I knew the nickname! This puzzle really perfects the New Yorker’s signature blend of high culture (Matisse’s Le BATEAU), pop culture (Ariana Grane’s “God IS A Woman”), word play (DRIZZLE!), and miscellaneous fun trivia (White Monopoly bills for ONES— a unique and fresh clue on an otherwise kind of tired entry).
- Names I didn’t know: Peter USTINOV, NADINE Gordimer, Ed Jones (TOO TALL),
- Fill I could live without: Just one, I think! Not a fan of ECT
Overall: all the stars from me, I adore this puzzle, and clearly I will take any excuse to embed an Ariana Grande video in my posts. Have a good day everyone!
Zhouquin Burnikel’s Universal crossword, “Conflicting Investment Advice”—Jim P’s review
Each theme answer ends in a word that is a homophone of either “buy” or “sell.”
- 18a [Hit the sack, to toddlers] GO BEDDY-BYE
- 28a [Oxygen transporter] RED BLOOD CELL
- 49a [Rare] HARD TO COME BY
- 64a [French sea salt] FLEUR DE SEL. Tough one for me. Needed every crossing.
Cute theme. It’s hard to know what advice to listen to! It’s especially tough right now when the market is undergoing unprecedented uncertainty. Should we have gotten out already or do we get out now or do we hold on and hope we’ll make a relatively quick recovery? Who knows!
I struggled right off the bat at 1a because I don’t recall ever seeing [Wine and dine] as a definition for FETE. The other one I really didn’t know was FENDI [Rome-based fashion house]; I don’t think I’ve ever heard that name at all. But those were my only real hang-ups. Everything else flowed smoothly. Of course, Zhouquin always brings us fun, fresh fill like TAX DODGER and SLEEP MODE.
Clues of note:
- 5a. [Word before “the day” or “the date”]. SAVE. I really like this clue. It seems simple, but finding it requires the constructor (or editor) to do a little digging. And while the phrases seem incredibly similar, they have vastly different meanings.
- 55a. [BTS music genre]. K-POP. I’m waiting for BTS to appear in a mainstream puzzle, and I don’t think they have yet. Honestly, I don’t know anything about the boy band from Korea (for example, I have no idea what BTS stands for), but when I see jigsaw puzzles of them in my local grocery store, I should probably expect to see them in a crossword puzzle before long.
- 10d. [Not at all wasted]. SOBER. Ha! This one was good for a chuckle.
Fun little theme and solid grillwork all around. 3.8 stars.
Joe Deeney’s LA Times crossword – Jenni’s write-up
If I’m going to play hide-and-go-seek, I’d rather be outside. I had no idea what was going on with this theme until after I finished the puzzle and went hunting. When I figured it out, it was more of an “oh, that” moment rather than “aha.”
The central entry is 36a [Acknowledgement of success–four are hidden in this puzzle, each adjacent to a black square] and that’s a ROUND OF APPLAUSE. The directions are very specific. On the one hand, I’m not sure I would have figured it out without the part about the black squares and on the other hand, it made it more like a kid-level connect-the-dots than a grownup puzzle.
The word CLAP is spelled in the squares surrounding four of the black squares, like so:
The letters move around, which is a nice touch. It’s not a particularly satisfying theme. The four CLAPS along with the 15 in the middle force some unpleasant fill. I’d be perfectly happy if I never saw OSIER in a puzzle again. There’s also plural STERNOS, Roman numeral math, –IER, and IF NO, filling in “What if ____ comes?” LIVE RADIO is a bit roll-your-own. I’ve been watching a lot of HGTV as part of my news avoidance strategy, so I know SOFT COLOR is a thing. And then there’s rapper MCREN crossing a vodka that could be either GRAY or GREY. I would have gotten that wrong if I’d done it on paper, since I started with A. When I didn’t get Mr. Happy Pencil, I went looking and decided to change it, but I wouldn’t have known otherwise. Again, rapper names are perfectly fine entries. Like all names, they need fair crossings.
A few things I actually liked:
- I enjoyed the juxtaposition of HOTH and HOAR. Ice, ice, baby.
- It’s nice to see AER LINGUS rather than just AER.
- 24d [Self-playing instrument] is a PIANOLA. The other name for that is “player piano,” which is what we called it. Kids, ask your great-grandparents. I grew up with one because my father loved anything with gears – clocks, watches, and player pianos. Over the years, my parents accumulated hundreds of rolls ranging from classical piano pieces to “Rubber Duckie,” which came with a rubber duckie. We also had this song. The lyrics including stage directions telling you when to squeak the duck. We also had a player harmonica, which I inherited. Neither my brother nor I had room for the piano (and I have a regular piano with much better action and sound) and I couldn’t bring myself to landfill it. Social media to the rescue! Someone saw my plea on FB and connected me with a woman in Georgia who was starting a rec center for vets. The piano is happily ensconced there and is still loved.
- To me, CHIRPILY isn’t just “in a cheerful way,” it’s “annoyingly cheerful.”
- 55a [“Three inches is such a wretched height to be” speaker] is a delightful clue for ALICE.
What I didn’t know before I did this puzzle: never heard of “Les Rougon-Macquart,” although I know who EMILE ZOLA was. Also never heard of sportscaster CRAIG Sager. Wikipedia tells me he was a basketball guy, and I am not a hoops fan.
NYT: I enjoyed this puzzle a lot but was naticked by PLOW/WEBB. It doesn’t snow in this country except in some ski areas so we don’t plow the streets. And even if we did we would probably spell it PLOUGH. And sadly I had never heard of the former First Lady. Oh well, a very enjoyable puzzle nonetheless.
That crossing was my last to fall, but I smiled when I got it. (We didn’t get much snow this winter.) Overall, the long answers were tough but smile worthy, and I didn’t find it half as easy a puzzle as the reviewer. I enjoyed it. I did have to look up afterward to see what TOD Fox was about.
I also enjoyed Gorski’s TNY, although as usual with an opposite frame of reference from the review. Say, while I somehow can’t even remember if I ever got around to NADINE Gordimer, it was a gimme, and while I didn’t remember the movie or the role (if I ever saw it), I recognized the name USTINOV with the help of crossings. And then I never heard of, say, MARISKA, but definitely gettable. But yeah, ECT as opposed to “ecto” or (my first guess since it had the right number of letters) “exo” seemed maybe a little odd. Oh, question: is it ok to have BOAT as part of an answer word and also in the clue for the French word?
Great cluing!!! Fun! Thank you, Robyn.
Sorry for the off-topic posting. I have not been able to access archived versions of the NYT crossword since yesterday. I have reached out to customer service but wondering if anyone else is facing the same issue.
Standard all-purpose advice: try clearing your browser’s cache?
I haven’t had any problems. I’m solving a lot of those puzzles these days.
NYT: The 47D clue is not accurate. Japan won the FIFA Women’s World Cup in 2011. It is true if you’re only talking about the Men’s World Cup (although “surprisingly” is a bizarre editorial aside that I expect from AVCX, not the NYT).
Actually, “FIFA World Cup” is the trademarked name for the men’s tournament. “FIFA Women’s World Cup” is the trademarked name for the women’s tournament.
Really? LOL, FIFA is just the worst.
It is ECTO- not ECT; ECT is a fine treatment for some severely depressed individuals medication intolerant/resistant. Probably a bit insensitive for NYer?
A fine & lovely puzzle, great fill – writes-in: BATEAU et FATALE *MDR* (rire rire), parlez-vous?
MARISKA Hargitay a good friend of Ramon Franco, great character actor and human being. SPUMONI – fave of mine since I can remember, like age 4.
USTINOV (Spartacus is the first film I remember the full-out Hollywood blitz treatment. Kirk Douglas, Woody Strode, John Gavin, Tony Curtis, and Sir Olivier!)
TOO TALL – was given to me by a woman friend who is 6’2″, lol.
NICE GUY for mensch seems oddly comical
… more, but I’ll stop. I had fun with this one
NYT didn’t ring my bell so well do tell.
Didn’t enjoy the LA Times very much. The CRIS Carter STCLAIR crossing. Two dubious definitions right next to each other: “stop working” for ACTUP and “illegal payments” for SOPS.
Two mind blocks with todays NYT…TOD and ROE. I’d look ’em up, but where????
Roe is fish eggs, hence future school [of fish]. I don’t remember the clue for TOD.
IMDB yields TOD – voiced by Mickey Rooney
Duh, twice. Thanks guys…..