Sunday, May 3, 2020

LAT 7:39 (Jenni) 


NYT  12:34 (Nate) 


WaPo 11:13 puzzle, meta shortly after (Jim Q) 


Universal 3:57 (Jim Q) 


Universal (Sunday) 8:54 (Jim P) 


Constructor newsflash! Caleb Madison’s been making minis for The Atlantic, and now they’re expanding to include a weekend 15×15 crossword online. If you’re interested in submitting your work, send Caleb your theme query (not a completed puzzle, just the theme pitch) at He promises to respond within a month with either a “yes” or constructive notes. They’re looking for medium-difficulty themes and clean fill, and The Atlantic will pay $350 per puzzle.

Ben Zimmer & Brendan Emmett Quigley’s New York Times crossword, “Shifting Sounds”—Nate’s write-up

Hello all! Nate here, filling in for Amy to cover the Sunday NYT puzzle, which is a NYT debut for Ben Zimmer. Congratulations! Here’s to many more. Okay, let’s dive into the puzzle and its theme:

5.3.20 NYT Solution

5.3.20 NYT Solution

3D: COUNT MISS [Bad shot by Dracula?] (can’t miss)
23A: HOUND SHAKE [Dog’s order at a malt shop?] (handshake)
29A: NED FLOUNDERS [“Game of Thrones” patriarch has difficulties?] (Ned Flanders)
58A: COUNSELED CHECK [Advised a chess player to attack the king?] (cancelled check)
76A: MOUSE MARKETING [Part of Disney’s advertising budget?] (mass marketing)
79D: FAIR COUCH [Comfy seating at a carnival?] (fair catch)
107A: TROUNCE STATE [Decisively defeat a cabinet department?] (trance state)
117A: FUZZY MOUTH [Feeling one gets under anesthesia at the dentist?] (fuzzy math)

When I was a kid, my dad was in the military. That means we lived all over the world, including the panhandle of Florida. That means that my vowel sounds are all over the place. My husband lovingly makes fun of me because I say room temperature as rum temperature, I pronounce the words pin and pen identically, etc. That means I usually don’t enjoy puzzles like today’s, which rely so much on how you pronounce and hear words. And yet, I really enjoyed this one and it worked for me! To my ear at least, the “Shifting Sounds” (a play on shifting sands, I just realized, and with the same vowel shift as the themers!) in today’s puzzle cause a ‘short a’ sound to shift into an ‘ow’ sound. Linguists and folks more in the know, help me out: what are the specific sounds being morphed in the themers and title?

In addition to quite enjoying this puzzle’s theme, it was a quick solve for me (a full 3:30 faster than my average NYT Sunday) and full of a lot of enjoyable non-theme fill (and very little garbage)!
– I love seeing modern celebrities of note like comedian HARI Kondabolu! Per his Wikipedia page, “Kondabolu is the star, creator, and executive director of The Problem with Apu, a documentary about Apu from The Simpsons … The film contextualizes Apu within minstrelsy and other tropes in American pop culture history that have historically stereotyped minorities.”
– I was glad to see the clue for AŇO reference its tilde, lest the answer actually be anus.
– I will never not be excited to see Mahershala ALI, [Academy Award winner for “Moonlight” and “Green Book”] in a puzzle or movie.
– Other favorites: Dr. Seuss’s YERTLE and [Attractive but vacuous guy, in slang] HIMBO.

And, because they’re otherwise underrepresented in puzzles, I love seeing women featured in crosswords. Today’s puzzle included Zora Neale Hurston, Patti Smith, Laura DERN of “Marriage Story,” Mary STUART, and the amazing SOLANGE Knowles (who definitely deserves a seat at this crossword table, even if her sister Beyoncé sadly doesn’t do crosswords). Way fewer women in the grid than men, as is typical for puzzles these days, but it’s worth celebrating the women who were featured and encouraging the inclusion of more women in puzzles, if even via the cluing.

The trickiest bit for me was the NW corner. I’d never heard of SOCKO as [Smashing] and barely knew [Comedian Mort] SAHL from “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel” – I can see a few solvers with a Natick at that first square (and maybe at AVERY/MEDOC), but otherwise a smooth and lovely puzzle. Congrats, Ben & Brendan!

Evan Birnholz’s Washington Post crossword, “Disbanded” – Jim Q’s writeup

Meta time! A music meta at that!

THEME: Something to do with songs and the bands that play them…

Washington Post, May 3, 2020, Evan Birnholz, “Disbanded” solution grid


  • 24A [1968 hit featured in the film “Easy Rider”] BORN TO BE WILD. By Steppenwolf, of course!
  • 42A [2014 death metal song with the lyric “What’s done is done, can’t be erased”] Google tells me that’s by Arch Enemy.
  • 68A [1971 protest song on the album “A Space in Time”] I’D LOVE TO CHANGE THE WORLD. At 21 letters, an excellent find for this meta construction! That is by Ten Years After.
  • 96A [1971 single whose lyrics may remind listeners of “1984”] HEY BIG BROTHER. By Rare Earth. 
  • 119A [1975 song with a 1991 music video featuring a phone sex conversation] SWEET EMOTION. Aerosmith. 

Not a heckuva lot of theme answers, right? Or so it seems. One look at the title, and the solver is tipped off that knowing the songs’ artists is probably key. And it is. I had to look up 3 of the 5, but as soon as Aerosmith came to mind I noticed that I had recently filled in both AERO [Nestlé candy bar] and SMITH [Maggie of “Downton Abbey”]. Wait a second… STEP PEN and WOLF are also entries. And so are ARCH and ENEMY. TEN YEARS AFTER and RARE EARTH all make appearances too! Can’t be coincidental.

The next step is a meta solver’s “go to” step: always look at the first letters of notable entries.

From north to south, the notable entries are STEP ENEMY PEN AFTER RARE ARCH TEN EARTH WOLF AERO YEARS and SMITH.

Or Separate Ways by Journey!

What a cool meta. Extremely tight using all very well known songs and a final answer that suggests “disbanding.” The symmetry of the answers and the north-to-south placement of the band names is just superb. And the fill didn’t suffer in the least, although I got stuck on the USURER/UBER section because I refused to change the CBER that I initially entered (hey, it totally works as an answer to the clue! [Company on the road] for truckers is often a fellow CBER, right?].


Enjoy your Sunday!

And of course, this:



Mark McClain’s Universal crossword — “Double Tease”

THEME: Common phrases with DD in them are changed to TT and clued wackily.

Universal crossword solution · “Double Tease” · Mark McClain · Sun., 5.3.20


  • 17A [Picture-framing hobbyists?] THE MATTING CROWD. The Madding Crowd. 
  • 27A [Company that makes playing cards and poker chips?] BETTING PLANT. Bedding Plant. 
  • 43A [Cause of many bogeys?] HASTY PUTTING. Hasty Pudding. 
  • 56A [Highly intelligent billy goats?] BUTTING GENIUSES. Budding Geniuses. 

One thing I can almost count on in a Universal is that one clue will offer a trivia tidbit I didn’t know. This time it was at 1 Across: [Swiss girl played by Shirley Temple] HEIDI. I had no clue HEIDI was portrayed by Shirley Temple. I’m sure I’m the last to the party on that one.

Anyway, the theme for this is fine. It took me a while to see because I was unfamiliar with many of the base phrases. BU[DD]ING GENIUSES was the only one I has 100% confident in, and HASTY PU[DD]ING rang a vague bell, but I didn’t know what a BE[DD]ING PLANT was and I still don’t know what THE MA[DD]ING CROWD is (googles)… looks like it refers to the rat race of humankind. Also, looks like a Netflix series is coming out that shares the phrase in part of its title.

So, just fine. My own ignorance probably kept me from enjoying a solid click mid-solve. I was left to figure it out post-solve.

3 stars.


Pam Awick Klawitter’s LA Times crossword, “Get Moving” – Jenni’s write-up

I got moving this morning to the tune of three miles around the neighborhood, socially distancing from the other walkers and wearing my mask. All of the theme clues are one word that is a kind of movement; the answers are alternate definitions. The theme clues are all caps because otherwise they’re just – clues.

Los Angeles Times, May 2, 2020, Pam Amick Klawitter, “Get Moving,” solution grid

  • 22a [LEAP] is an ABRUPT PASSAGE. To me, the salient part of a LEAP is being airborne, not being abrupt.
  • 36a [DASH] is a RECIPE AMOUNT.
  • 44d [RUN] is a PANTYHOSE MISHAP. Kids, ask your grandmothers (although I wear pantyhose and I am not a grandmother).
  • 68a [BOLT] is a ROLL OF CLOTH.
  • 98a [HOP] is a FIFTIES DANCE.
  • 118a [SKIP] is an ACT OF OMISSION. That doesn’t seem quite right to me, parts-of-speech-wise.

I prefer my themes with a least a little wordplay. This one does not move me.

A few other things:

  • I think GEEZER is more about age than eccentricity, and not in a nice way.
  • ARRANT is a word you don’t see every day. That’s a shame. It’s a good word.
  • 30d [2/3 of 100?] took me a minute. It’s ZEROES.
  • Does anyone actually say REDIG? I think not.
  • 79d [Animated queen] is for once not ANNA or ELSA. It’s NALA, so my Anna-or-Elsa strategy of dropping in the final A still worked.
  • In addition to PANTYHOSE and FIFTIES DANCE, we have MORLEY Safer and James ARNESS, all of which give this puzzle a slightly musty air.

What I didn’t know before I did this puzzle: I got nothing, which means there was precious little pop culture in this puzzle. I know some of you think that’s a good thing. I think it contributes to the mustiness. This puzzle could be nearly 30 years old; NALA and MISSY Elliot made their debuts in the 1990s.

Zhouqin Burnikel’s Universal Sunday crossword, “Off-Screen”—Jim P’s review

If ever there was a puzzle made for me, this was it. After all, once upon a time I double-majored in computer engineering and English, so a puzzle with computing puns is right up my alley.

Universal Sunday crossword solution · “Off-Screen” · Zhouqin Burnikel · Sun., 5.3.20

  • 23a [Dognapper’s outfit?] RANSOM WEAR. Ransomware. Dog theft isn’t a joke, but I guess it’s a better angle than actual kidnapping.
  • 25a [Picture holder made in Bangor?] MAINE FRAME. Mainframe.
  • 49a [Spiteful wild cat?] MALICIOUS LYNX. Malicious links.
  • 93a [Tail swipe from a sturgeon, say?] FISHING ATTACK. Phishing attack.
  • 116a [Harbor city where lots of grain is exported?] CEREAL PORT. Serial port.
  • 119a [Googling “Dragnet” star Jack, e.g.?] WEBB SEARCH. Web search.
  • 39d [Window shopper’s money?] BROWSER CASH. Browser cache.
  • 45d [Instagram caption for a yawning parent picture?] MOTHER BORED. Motherboard. Or it may be the mother is suffering from a lack of quality sleep.

Fun theme, at least for me. Every base phrase is in-the-language enough (or nearly so) to be recognizable by most people, I should think. And everything flowed so smoothly, I clocked in at one of my fastest times ever for a 21x.

And it wouldn’t be a Burnikel grid without plenty of nice fill: “HERE IT IS!,” EAST ASIA, RAIN MAN, TOP RANK, PARANOIA, LEAVE BE, WARHAWKS, MOSSAD, “TRY ONE!,” “THAT’S ALL,” the preferred with-an-H OOH-LA-LA, and the MARIANA Trench (my home trench, off the coast of Guam, my home island).

My neighbor Roy and Bill the greyhound

When I have a fast solving time, that probably means cluing was pretty straightforward. But that doesn’t mean some aren’t notable:

  • 21a. [One in a cast]. ACTOR. I love a simple clue like this that still provides ambiguity.
  • 31a. [China setting?]. EAST ASIA. Another one with misdirection, but in this case, since the answer is longish, and all the theme clues have question marks, it’s easy to think this might be one, too. I’d consider a more straightforward clue here.
  • 63a. [Mann of “The Other Woman”]. This one seems pretty straightforward, but when you look a little closer, it’s quite fun! First, you have Mann and Woman in the clue, and then, if you didn’t know the answer off-hand, you discover it’s LESLIE, which could be a name for a man or a woman. So which is it? In this case, LESLIE Mann is a Best Supporting Actress-nominated, um, ACTOR.
  • 88a. [Lizard with sticky feet]. GECKO. Hmm. I’m not sure about this. Do we have any herpetologists in the house?
  • 130a. [Greyhound’s growl]. SNARL. I’ve only known one greyhound in my life, and Bill was such a very sweet dog who was the constant companion to my elderly neighbor. I don’t know that I ever heard him bark, despite our daily walks in the forest.
  • 47d. [Battery-free smoke detectors]. NOSES. Another fun clue.

Smooth and fun puzzle. Four stars from me.

This entry was posted in Daily Puzzles and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to Sunday, May 3, 2020

  1. Jeff K says:

    Anyone else not seeing today’s WaPo online? My screen still shows last week’s (26 April 2020) as the most recent puzzle.

    • Yes, I’m aware of that. I don’t know why that happened since I uploaded the puzzle to the server as normal, but I’ve alerted the Post’s tech team to get it sorted out. If you can’t wait for the PDF, though, it can be downloaded in .puz format here from the Today’s Puzzles page. Thanks for your and everyone’s patience.

      • Jeff K says:

        Thanks for the tip about downloading the .puz format. And, FWIW, I really enjoy your puzzles.

        • Thanks, I appreciate that. The puzzle is available on the Post’s website now. Sorry for the temporary inconvenience!

          • Mikem says:

            Evan, at midnight, the daily puzzle for Sunday went up, but not yours. But yours went up within the next half-hour or so, because I did it after I did the daily one. Weird that it disappeared again after that!

            Another tour de force in construction, although I personally had never heard of 3 of the 5 songs, so it was a bit rough going. But they were all gettable through perps, so got there in the end!

  2. Billy Boy says:

    I see BEQ in the (co-)byline and gear up for weirdness, but that NYT today went really fast and as Nate noted with minimal junk. Something to raise my interest in a time when I am actually doing the larger puzzles, and now that I know it was shared with a new NYT constructor, well-done.


  3. JohnH says:

    Just in case anyone hasn’t heard, the Sunday NY Times (at least in print) has a section of just puzzles, lots of them. You’ll remember the addition from December, but they offer some relief for shut-ins. (The print for one page of clues, with the cryptic, is small, but you can’t have everything.)

    I thought the Sunday theme was smile worthy. I enjoyed it. One thing that slowed me up was picking HOME rather than LONG to come before and after “run,” but my own fault.

    • Amy Reynaldo says:

      I don’t think these are repeats in the NYT’s pandemic Puzzlemania section, are they?

  4. David L says:

    I was worried the Sunday WaPo meta would require some obscure musical knowledge, but I was able to solve it (with the help of my assistant Prof. Google) even though I only knew two of the songs in the grid and didn’t know the meta answer either. That’s how it should be.

    NYT: On the great tilde debate — yes, it’s nice that the clue for AÑO acknowledged that it needs a tilde, but then we also have SØREN Kierkegaard at 72D without any hint that he needs a funny O with a line through it. It’s odd that some people seem to make a big fuss about tildes but not about other accent marks. (One of the regular constructors made this observation a while back but I can’t remember who).

    • Nate says:

      Agreed, though the difference between tilde or no tilde in ANO is particularly hilarious / stark!

  5. Peter Lowen says:

    Re: 5/3/20 29-Across
    Ned Stark is a character in Game of Thrones.
    Ned Flanders is a character in The Simpsons.
    Is this too clever or an error?

    • Amy Reynaldo says:

      All the theme entries are clued without reference to the original pre-sound-change phrases. Thus, NED FLOUNDERS uses the other prominent NED of pop culture, Stark, rather than pointing to Ned Flanders. The COUNSELED CHECK, likewise, refers to a check in the game of chess rather than a financial instrument.

Comments are closed.