Grant Thackray’s New York Times crossword—Amy’s review
Definitely a gamer/tech vibe in this puzzle. There’s the Apple products’ LOWERCASE I, video game BOSS BATTLE, arcade game HIGH SCORES, a hacker saying “I’M IN,” online GOING VIRAL, and HTML. Contrast that with a smattering of old-school fill like ELON, ALVA, ESTER, ATRI, and ODIST, and assorted partial-ish entries (ON TO, IS AT, OF ME), and add in the weird grid design, and I dunno, it wasn’t all that fun for me.
Five more things:
- 4d. [Looks the other way], LETS THINGS SLIDE. Great entry here.
- 2d. [Prefix with -gram], HOLO. Meh.
- 38a. [Leader memorialized by the Stone of Hope statue near the National Mall], KING. “With this faith, we will be able to hew out of the mountain of despair a stone of hope.”
57a. [Compressed storage media], MICROFILM. Raise your hand if you have ever loaded microfilm or microfiche into a reader to enlarge the text to a readable size. I think I did this once or twice at the college library, and again at one of the National Archives facilities where you could view old census records before everything was available online.
- 6d. [Auditioner’s hope], PART. I absolutely read this as [Auctioneer’s hope] and wanted SALE. Just me?
3.5 stars from me. How’d you like working through this series of connected rectangles and squares?
Caitlin Reid’s New Yorker crossword – Rachel’s write-up
On the 34526th day of quarantine, Taylor Swift blessed us with a surprise new album, and it is ?. Sometimes we can have nice things! Like this puzzle! (How was that for a transition??). I flew through this puzzle, which was packed full of entries I loved and some fun (easy) wordplay.
Long entries today include the vertical grid-spanner BACK TO SQUARE ONE, the NE stack of 10s ADAM’S APPLE / SOCCER TEAM, and the SW stack of RABBIT HOLE / TOO LATE NOW. All super solid and delightfully clued, particularly [Goal-oriented group?] for SOCCER TEAM and the A+ colloquial translation of [“That ship has sailed!”] for TOO LATE NOW!.
A few other things:
- Love me some RuPaul, the world’s best-known DRAG QUEEN, and as a PSA, you should all know that the finale of RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars 5 is tonight. #TeamJujubee
- I didn’t know the end of ALOHA OE, but the crosses made this gettable and a learning experience (which sent me down a wikipedia RABBIT HOLE about Queen Liliʻuokalani, who wrote the song)
- Favorite Clues
- [Give an organ a tune-up, maybe?] – OPERATE
- [Slangy “Don’t you agree?”] – AMIRITE
- Re: [Bring home from a shelter] – ADOPT, please see this picture of my dog Hazel and then immediately go adopt a pit bull near you
- This puzzle felt pretty light on real people in general, which is appropriate for a lightly challenging Friday puzzle. The folks we did have felt like a nice balance; I appreciated the parallel clues on DERN/PITT, and we also had ELENA Kagan, RuPaul, ALOHA OE. Success!
And now to justify my inclusion of this Taylor Swift video in my post, here’s a paragraph about it that uses entries from the puzzle:
This new album is very much my VIBE, it is GREATER than her previous albums, and once you start listening to it you will end up in a Taylor Swift RABBIT HOLE from which there may be no coming back. If you were hoping to avoid this album but already clicked play on the video below out of curiosity, it is TOO LATE NOW, you are DONE FOR. AMIRITE?!?
Overall, tons of stars from me. The fill is super clean, the clues are fun, and the entries are fun and flashy. Happy Friday!
Jake Scheele’s Los Angeles Times crossword — pannonica’s write-up
Two-part revealer, LIKE SO (4d):
- 17a. [With 59-Across, old English nursery rhyme being investigated by the detectives in this puzzle] WHO KILLED
- 59a. [See 17-Across (and see circles for the solution to the mystery)] COCK ROBIN.
As instructed. the circled squares, read top-to-bottom and left-to-right, in those detectives’ names reveal the killer.
- 23a. [Wealthy TV sleuth Matt] HOUSⓉON (1982–1985) Yeesh. Why not Jules MAIGREⓉ, whom I daresay is significantly more well-known?
- 26a. [Hard-boiled sleuth Mike] ⒽAMMⒺR.
- 39a. [Falcon-finding sleuth Sam] ⓈⓅADE. Though the falcon is not the guilty party here, nor (presumably) was it a dingus related to the investigation.
- 51a. [Twinkly-eyed sleuth Jane] MⒶⓇPLE.
- 54a. [Wisecracking sleuth Philip] MAⓇLⓄⓌE.
I appreciate the consistency of using the sleuths’ last names. Moderately involved theme, executed (ha) well.
I hadn’t heard of—or more likely, long ago forgot—this particular nursery rhyme, but it’s reproduced in Wikipedia. Not much of a mystery, as the murderer confesses in the second line of the poem and there’s a litany of witnesses. This is obviously well before Poe and the conceit of the modern detective story.
There’s a 1935 Walt Disney Silly Symphony adaptation of the ‘story’ but I don’t recommended it, as it’s rife with racial, gender, and sexuality stereotypes, gratuitous police brutality, and gross miscarriage of justice. Also, not unexpectedly, it isn’t particularly entertaining per se.
Anyway, the theme reminded me of Jasper Fforde’s inventive books involving the Nursery Crime division of the police, with Jack Spratt and Mary, Mary (Quite Contrary) as lead investigators. The truly excruciating puns are a highlight—or lowlight, depending on your tolerance. And curiously, the center of the grid features (28d) Chris PRATT crossing Sam SPADE, suggesting a portmanteau strongly invoking (to me) that peculiar Spratt spelling.
- Got off on the wrong foot by trying LAWN for 1a [Need for many outdoor games] when the correct answer was BALL.
- 19a [Coffee mate] DONUT. Speaking of abuse by the police … “Donut Taunt Leads to Jail” (Seattle Weekly)
- 49a [Took the sloop] BOATED, 40d [Left on a sloop] EMBARKED.
- 62d [Tick off] IRK, 45d [More ticked off] SORER.
- 66a [Roman fiddler] NERO. Not to be confused with famous fictional detective NERO Wolfe, who is apparently unconnected to the events here.
- LAO person crossing THAI food in the upper left (3d, 13a)
- 5d [Metaphor for youthful indiscretion] WILD OATS, of the sowing variety.
- 15d [Epidemic-fighting agcy.] CDC. Yeah, not so much these days, under the thumb of the current regime. “New CDC Guidelines Emphasize Reopening Schools in Person” (NPR). VP Pence, earlier: “We don’t want the guidance from CDC to be a reason why schools don’t open.”
- 63d [San Francisco’s __ Valley] NOE.
Peter Silzer’s Universal crossword, “Up and Down”—Jim P’s review
Our theme is SPLIT LEVEL (69a, [Like some houses, and a hint to each set of stacked circled letters]), with supporting revealer STEPS (59d, [What this puzzle’s central black squares resemble]) and theme-adjacent FLOOR PLANS at 17a. Each set of split, circled letters spells out a synonym of the word “level.”
SMOOTH comes out of SMOG and TOOTH, EVEN from EVE and END, and FLAT from FLEA and ATM.
Nice concept here. I like how the circles step down from the left to the right of the grid, but it would have looked cleaner if five-letter words could’ve been used instead of EVEN and FLAT so those circled steps would seem unbroken.
Also, the circled words are synonyms of each other, and they’re all adjectives. I think I would’ve liked it better if each circled word used a different meaning of “level” which can be a noun (like “layer”), an adjective (like “flat”), or a verb (like “raze”).
Lastly, STAIR is at 56d and isn’t clued as part of the theme. I’m not sure why it wasn’t made into STAIN or STEIN.
But these are just ways to improve a solid concept which works just fine.
Fillwise, I think my favorite entry is HOOEY [Malarkey]. The longer TEMPORARY and REPORTERS are solid of course, as is the rest of the fill. In fact, it’s quite a clean grid. If ESS and ESE are the worst bits of fill in your puzzle, you’re doing all right.
Same here. Why is that? Is “Auctioneer” much more common a word than “Auditioner”?
I got my answer as I was typing the above sentence. My system underlined “Auditioner” as a typo. I googled it and got 200K hit vs. 66million for Auctioneer…
The brain is a wondrous thing.
Me too, and I’m an actor so somehow I felt bad that I misread the clue, like I was betraying my profession or something…
Add me to the list.
NYT: It’s definitely an unusual design and a gamer vibe and I surprised myself by really liking it and finding it relatively easy.
Love that STEAMBOAT WILLIE anchors the whole eastern part. The BOSS BATTLE and HALF NELSON are a nice pair occupying equivalent parts of the North and South. And yeah, the internal battle- sometimes, it’s best to LET THINGS SLIDE…
Yup! I enjoyed it for exactly those reasons.
The gamer/tech/male constructor vibe is exactly what I didn’t like about today’s puzzle. Explains why we have only MLK, “nana” and Ness against Alva, Bart, “Erebus, Neil Gaiman, Wordworth, Luca and Arie. I confess, though, I smiled when I wrote “Steamboat Willie.” Could this have been clued via Minnie Mouse? ;-)
NYT – pretty easy, nothing too special here
Amy, 6D: YES YES YES a moi aussi
holograms are now ubiquitous, I remember when they were special
ATRI needed all crosses, no Lit Scholar here
I majored in English and I know ATRI from crosswords, not coursework.
That’s somehow rather reassuring.
Liked the NYT. Yes, too much crosswordese, but the long entries were excellent and the grid was eye-catching.
My first thought about this puzzle was that Amy will not like it. I rarely get involved in the tone of a puzzle, but this one had an overwhelming male constructor vibe. It was very easy for me even though I am not much of a video gamer.
I was shocked that the answer to the wrestling move might be FULL NELSON. Fortunately, it was HALF NELSON. Full Nelson is an illegal move at the high school and college level because it is too conducive to injury.
NYT – cool grid shape. Cluing could have been more interesting, but the long answers were fun.
Inkubator (bonus) – oversized puzzles are certainly an extra challenge, but I’m not sure this one was worth the squeeze.
Agreed on the Inkubator being underwhelming. At 139 words, it’s basically at a themed-puzzle word count, even with the extra column. And the clues were extremely straightforward and easy, the only difficulty coming with “here’s a proper name you probably don’t know.” [Season for skiing] is a kid’s menu-level clue. No wordplay, no cleverness. Entries like Eve Arden and Arlene Dahl and Annette Funicello made this seem like a Maleska-era puzzle, dated in a bad way.
pannonica, and apparently others are too young to remember the rhetorical question:
“Who killed cock robin?”
Growing up this was a very common phrase that most of us never came from a nursery rhyme.
It was something you just threw out there when your group was puzzled about something, like, “Well, then, who killed cock robin” or when you were trying to stump some wise ass.
I would say that 90% of us never knew the answer.
Universal – Jim P, good catch on STAIR. I didn’t notice this as I did the puzzle. As I look at the grid now, STAIR has left/right symmetry with STEPS, which was clued as a revealer. I’d guess the constructor did this intentionally. Maybe an editorial decision was made that linking STAIR with STEPS might confuse the theme?
Why did I like Universal better than average? Significantly so, it seems. Clever.
Sure it was easy compared to most and certainly for a Friday, but it’s a nice construction even if a fill-it-in for good puzzlers.
Anybody do 7/24/20 Newsday and understand the theme? I am stumped
I believe the revealer is incorrectly—or at least ambiguously—phrased. It reads “what each syllable of the answer to each starred clue is” a STATE | CAPITAL | RHYME, but each answer must be taken as a whole. Each syllable rhymes with a corresponding syllable in a state capital.
PAINT BALL ≈ Saint Paul
MANTA RAY ≈ Santa Fe
PLANNING ≈ Lansing
TROUSSEAU ≈ Juneau
As far as I know, the only one-syllable state capital is Pierre.
Thanks, yeah. That’s what I eventually figured. Kinda weak, I thought.