Thursday, December 16, 2021

BEQ untimed (Darby) 


LAT 6:05 (GRAB) 


NYT 12:17 (Ben) 


Universal untimed (Jim Q) 


USA Today 3:32 (Sophia) 


Fireball 8:00 (Amy) 


WSJ untimed (Jim P) 


Joe Hansen’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Wax On, Wax Off”—Jim P’s review

And now for something completely different. Joe Hansen brings us the phases of the moon in rebus form. The revealer is LUNAR PHASE (58a, [What’s represented by each circled space and one black square in this grid]). In those circled squares, the word MOON waxes and wanes as we travel clockwise from the New Moon (the black square above square 60) up through the Full Moon at the top of the diagram then back down to the New Moon. A pretty spiffy set-up if you ask me.

Wall St Journal crossword solution · “Wax On, Wax Off” · Joe Hansen · Thu., 12.16.21

In a bit of elegance, note that MOON is four letters, and in the two instances where we have half-moons, we have exactly two letters in use: the ON in BRONZERS / NICHOLSON and the MO of STEPMOMS / MODERN ART. The full moon uses all four letters of course.

For completion’s sake, here are all of the rebuses and their corresponding phases:

  • Black square above square 60: New Moon
  • N of RISEN / ENNUI: Waxing Crescent
  • ON of BRONZERS / NICHOLSON: First Quarter Half Moon
  • OON of BALLOON / MONSOON: Waxing Gibbous
  • MOO of MOORISH / VAMOOSE: Waning Gibbous
  • MO of STEPMOMS / MODERN ART: Last Quarter Half Moon
  • M of MYERS / MUMPS: Waning Crescent

This is quite elegant and I’m glad to have found an image that matches the grid.

The only nit I’ll pick is that I wish the New Moon black square was separated from other black squares to make it more pronounced. Note that the grid is perfectly symmetrical—as a normal crossword grid usually is—except for that one New Moon square. But it’s not so easy to notice since it’s connected to two other black squares. I don’t know if an alternative configuration is at all possible, but as it is, it took me a non-zero number of seconds to identify exactly which square was meant to be the New Moon.

The rest of the grid is quite nice with BACKORDERS (a timely entry in this holiday/COVID season), MUDHEN, RASCAL, STUPOR, etc.).

Clues of note:

  • 31a. [PX shoppers]. GIS. Once again, the Post Exchange is no longer called the PX but simply “The Exchange.” Officially, anyway. I’m sure there are many patrons who still use that terminology just as I and my Air Force family still call it the BX.
  • 12d. [Jordans symbol]. SWOOSH. That is, the Nike SWOOSH on Air Jordans.

I love the inventiveness of this theme as well as its execution. 4.5 stars from me.

Alex Eaton-Salners’s Fireball crossword, “Routing Numbers:—Amy’s write-up

Fireball crossword solution, 12 16 21, “Routing Numbers”

Unusual theme here. The four longest Down answers need to use a “routing number” to be completed. The last letters in each of those entries happen to spell out a number, and if you go to the square where that number is found, that short Down entry completes the long one:

  • 25d. [Certain school gathering], PARENTS EVEN / ING. SEVEN-Down is ING.
  • 35d. [Hindu-majority province in the Coral Triangle], BALI, INDONE / SIA. ONE-Down is singer SIA.
  • 36d. [Breast that looks like a finger], CHICKEN TEN / DER. TEN-down is DER, the German definite article that is a [Die alternative]. Tough clue, that.
  • 30d. [Big belt owner], HEAVYWEIGHT / CHAMP. EIGHT-Down is CHAMP.

Overall, I didn’t much enjoy the puzzle. So many of the clues seemed more obstinately tough than cleverly challenging:

  • 8a. [D.C. al ___], CODA. I have no idea what this is about. With that tough DER clue, ouch.
  • 34a. [Cut price?], ABSENCE. The price of cutting class is being marked absent?
  • 59a. [Father of Jochebed], LEVI / 52d. [Son of Jochebed], AARON. Jochebed is not what we call a biblical A-lister. To me, these clues were essentially [Random male name from the Old Testament, good luck to ya].
  • 13d. [Singer Stone with the song “Crossword Puzzle”], SLY. It was a 1976 solo single and I don’t think it charted anywhere, so if you’ve never heard of the tine, you’re not alone. I do want to know if he was solving crosswords in the 1970s, though!
  • 55d. [“___! The Genetic Opera” (2008 film)], REPO. The movie’s subtitle and the parenthetical don’t at all provide any hints to work this one out if you didn’t already know it.

Did not know: 48d. [Logician’s propositions], LEMMATA. Who knew that was an allowable plural of lemma?

3.25 stars from me.

Trenton Charlson’s New York Times crossword—Ben’s review

NYT #1216 – 12/16/2021

Trenton Charlson has today’s NYT, and it’s a tribute to a different sort of word game:

  • 15A: Flummox — BEWILDER
  • 17A: Flummox — BEMUSE
  • 55A: Flummox — BEFUDDLE
  • 52A: Flummox…or a classic word game represented by the central grid of shaded squares, in which 15A, 17A, and 55A can be found — BOGGLE

The middle part of the grid (which starts out as shaded squares, but becomes the actual BOGGLE board seen in the screenshot) contains all the letters to make BEWILDER, BEMUSE, and BEFUDDLE, connected BOGGLE-style.  On the app, this also animates out how each of these works, which is cute.  For me, this fell into the camp of being an interesting exercise in fill that I’m not sure was as fun a puzzle to solve as it was to work out.

That BOGGLE board is composed of RELIEF MAPS (“Depictions of lands’ ups and downs”), MAIN ISSUES (“Focal points of a debate”), DEWBERRIES (“Brambles with edible purple fruit”), and HARDLINERS (“Uncompromising sorts”).

Elsewhere: It took me all sorts of staring to realize Twelfth Night takes place in ILLYRIA.

happy Thursday!

Christina Iverson’s USA Today crossword, “Bell Bottoms” — Sophia’s recap

Editor: Amanda Rafkin
Theme: Each theme answer (which are placed vertically in the grid) has a final word that can be preceded by the word “door”.

USA Today, 12 16 2021, “Bell Bottoms”

  • 8d [Question asked near mealtime] – WHAT’S FOR DINNER? (dinner bell)
  • 13d [Rhyming phrase for practicing articulation] – HOW NOW BROWN COW (cow bell)
  • 14d [Rotating entryway] – REVOLVING DOOR (door bell)

Absolutely fantastic puzzle by Christina today. The three theme answers are all fun and evocative (and are 13 and 14 letters long to boot, notoriously annoying lengths to deal with). They all tie in nicely with the title of the puzzle as well.

This crossword to me is living proof that a puzzle doesn’t need to be incredibly difficult or have a complicated theme in order to be interesting and fun to solve. There are 6 across answers that are 8 or more letters long, and not one of them is wasted. The bottom section that includes SANDRA OH, COFFEE RUN, TRUE CRIME? Perfection. The only part of the puzzle that I’m not enamored with is that big stack of 3’s in the middle (oh, and A SET, which is an odd partial), but that’s a minor nitpick on an incredible puzzle.

Other notes:

  • Of the “names clued as wordplay clues”, I was able to get NED (11d [Name that’s a cozy room backwards]) pretty quickly, but it took me a long time to get CROWE (26a [Surname that sounds like a black bird]), not sure why.
  • I didn’t know “Sharice’s BIG Voice”. It’s a kids book about Sharice Davids: the subtitle is “A native kid becomes a congresswoman”.
  • This puzzle has a USE/USER dupe, but I think it’s a good example about why folks don’t need to get up in arms about dupes as much as they do now. The words are spread out in the puzzle, have clues that don’t relate to each other (5d [“___ it or lose it”]// 40a [Person with a password]), and I didn’t even notice that they both existed until I went to recap the puzzle, so clearly the presence of one didn’t make me think the other was wrong. Just my take!

Chris Sablich’s LA Times crossword – Gareth’s summary

LA Times

Today’s puzzle by Chris Sablich features another basic theme, neatly executed. The revealer is STRIPTEASE, and each of four answers loses an initial T. So, we have (T)ABLETALKER, (T)URNSIGNAL, (T)RUEBLUE, and (T)EARJERKER. I personally have no idea what a TABLETALKER is, though Google suggests some kind of advert stand?

I also struggled a bit in the area in the top-right where there were several names, though the choice of clue also played a role. I confess I can never be sure of the vowels of GALLILEO Galilei and then AMELIA is clued as an island, ADAM is clued as a sports person Silver who isn’t NATE, and NAMU is suspiciously similar to SHAMU.


Kyle Dolan and Elizabeth O’Tuam’s Universal Crossword, “Lit From Above”— Jim Q’s write-up

Looks like a debut for Elizabeth O’Tuam! Congrats!

THEME: Book titles with celestial bodies in them.

Universal crossword solution · “Lit From Above” · Elizabeth O’Tuama · Kyle Dolan · Thurs., 12.16.21


  • (revealer) SKY WRITING

Nice, simple and effective theme. And the left/right symmetrical grid never felt crowded. Some nice longer answers made it a bit difficult at times to visually determine where the themers were, but the asterisks in the clues helped keep the solver on track in that aspect.

New for me: Sally HANSEN, RHEA Seehorn.

Fun clue for Wisconsin’s very blunt and succinct MOTTO, “Forward!”

A little side-eye for HBO GO, which I believe is not-a-thing anymore. Looks like the clue sidestepped that? I guess it still exists in some countries! I was a bit bummed when they switched to HBO MAX because whomever was logged in to HBO GO at my house never logged out, so I was able to mooch for years.

Looking forward to more from Elizabeth!

3.75 Stars

Brendan Emmett Quigley’s Crossword #1427, “Imitates Dogs”—Darby’s review

Theme: Each theme answer includes a dog breed after a word that sounds like that breed. This similar sound comes from an exact repetition (imitation) of the consonants in the dog breed.

Theme Answers

Brendan Emmett Quigley's Crossword #1427, “Imitates Dogs” solution for 12/16/2021

Brendan Emmett Quigley’s Crossword #1427, “Imitates Dogs” solution for 12/16/2021

  • 17a [“Do some research on a dog?”] SCOUT OUT SCOTTIE
  • 26a [“Stump a dog?”] BEGUILE BEAGLE
  • 43a [“Disrupt the dog industry with an app?”] UBERIZE BORZOI
  • 57a [“‘Finally, a dog’?”] LAST ONE ALSATIAN

As a dog person, I thought that this was a fun one. It was also super helpful in the rest of my solve, though I spent some time confused by UBERIZE BORZOI and LAST ONE ALSATIAN. For the former, it was because I had not previously heard of Borzoi dogs (they’re cute) while for the latter, I was so sure it was DALMATIAN until I caught 55d [“Snake tooth”] FANG and 55a [“‘Nifty!’”] FAB.

A couple of stumpers for me were 52a [“‘The Day the Earth Stood Still’ alien”] KLAATU and 2d [“Medieval Moor fighter”] EL CID, and I like history and sci-fi, so those were two particularly tough breaks. I did enjoy the two G-forward long Down clue in 29d [“Patience”] GIVE IT TIME, as well as the nod toward the nerdiest fabric in 65a [“Suit material”] TWEED.

Anyway, that’s it for me! Fun puzzle, aside from a few tough ones.

This entry was posted in Daily Puzzles and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

16 Responses to Thursday, December 16, 2021

  1. Matt Gaffney says:

    Very nice NYT and Fireball and WSJ — wow, big day

  2. huda says:

    NYT: It was like a themeless with a reward at the end… A different kind of fun!

    • Lise says:

      I agree; I like themelesses and this one had a nice bonus. Kudos to Trenton Charlson for getting those words into a Boggle board without compromising the fill.

  3. Frank says:

    Never played Boggle but it was a fine puzzle even if you ignored the theme, which I did.

  4. Joe Pancake says:

    Thought NYT was brilliant—such a high degree of difficulty for the constructor, and I found it super fun to solve. It didn’t at all come off as a fun-for-the-constructor-not-the-solver puzzle to me.

    Well done, sir.

  5. Philip says:

    NYT: I only knew the word HODAD only because it was the name of a Montreal band in the 1980s. I assumed it was just a play on hoedown, and didn’t realize it had a completely different meaning. Coincidentally, opened up Facebook this morning to see a poster from a 1980s gig featuring them.

    • Gareth says:

      After learning the word in puzzles, I named a stray dog brought to our shelter that a few years back. He was found stranded on a rock on the beach at high tide and rescued by the NSRI. Like all dogs with a “story”, and unlike most of the 76 we’ve have so far this month, people were queueing to adopt him.

  6. David L says:

    I found the NYT kind of a slog. Some pretty dire fill — SNAFUED, ASSTDA, BRRR, BIS, ABOU, TREEBOA — leading to a payoff that I didn’t find that exciting. I see it definitely as a feat of construction that didn’t make for a fun puzzle.

    WSJ: I was baffled by the circled squares and had to come here to see what was intended.

    Maybe I’m just grumpy and slow on the uptake today.

  7. janie says:

    timeliness (sadly…) of BEREA at 42D in fireball:

  8. marciem says:

    BEQ: I’m hoping to see some explanation of the theme other than “dog breeds at the end.” I’m sure there is another layer in there, relationship to the first part, but can’t quite grasp it.

    • Martin says:

      The first part of the entry is a consonant anagram of the breed. All the consonants of the breed name, and only those consonants, appear. The title is another one.

      • marciem says:

        Thanks! It seemed like there was some kind of anagramming going on, but I didn’t think of consonants only, so I was flummoxed. Big sigh of relief!! :)

      • david glasser says:

        In fact it’s not just a consonant anagram, it’s a full consonantcy: the consonants appear in the same order.

        (But I didn’t understand that until reading your comment!)

  9. Seahedges says:

    Upon consulting the Cruciverb Database I find that Thursday’s Universal marks the first appearance of SKYWRITING in the Crossword Majors. Seeing it my thoughts ran immediately to Earl “Madman” Munt’s celestial coinage of TV to promote his budget television sets in the early 1950s : MUNTZ TV, announced the vapor stream in the sky over Lake Michigan. The term stuck.

  10. Phil says:

    Re BEQ
    How can the reviewer have a problem with the well known figure ‘el cid’ but not say anything about the ridiculous and unfun natnick on the B and U in BIZOUNCE and BRONY.

Comments are closed.