David Alfred Bywaters’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Limited Liability”—Jim P’s review
Theme: Familiar phrases or words that feature an LI bigram, have it changed to LLY to wacky effect.
- 17a. [Chihuahua in Chicago, maybe?] CHILLY DOG. Chili dog. This is the only one that was not one word to begin with. I would’ve liked it better if this one was brought in line with the others.
- 26a. [Time for which hall-decking is scheduled?] HOLLY DAY. Holiday.
- 37a. [Horse-training specialist?] FILLY BUSTER. Filibuster.
- 49a. [Midlife, for some?] FOLLY AGE. Foliage. Hey! I resemble that remark.
- 58a. [Dunce cap?] SILLY CONE. Silicone. Nice one.
I like the wordplay here (especially the last one), I just wish it was consistent all the way through.
In the fill, I like TOENAIL, TROCHEE, FUEL LINE, HIP BONE, and “YIKES!” But we really should be able to make a grid these days without SSR (not to mention SST which is not in this grid, thankfully). SRS at the opposite side of the grid is only mildly better.
Clues of note:
- 24a. [Sentence structure?]. PRISON. Nice clue.
- 40d. [Poetic foot]. TROCHEE. If, like me, you can’t help tripping over your poetic feet, here’s a quick run-down for reference.
Joseph Gangi’s New York Times crossword–Amy’s write-up
This grid’s center is asymmetrical because there’s a duck depicted there. The many theme answers relating to the verb and the noun duck are all over the puzzle. Verb action: AVOID, SHIRK, TAKE COVER, STOOP DOWN (can you stoop any which way but down?), and DODGE. Nouns are “duck, duck, GOOSE” (or maybe the words in that game are verbs?), DONALD Duck, BATH TOY. Other entries with duck mentions in the clues: MAMET and EGG. It’s possible I missed something else. I think the verbs relate to a waterfowl’s habit of ducking under the water, so they pair well with the grid art.
The puzzle might be overloaded with duck words, though. The Down (!) crossings are good, except for the blah HAT PEG. The Acrosses bring us the unexpected SAI ([Raphael’s weapon in “Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles”]). I don’t think I’d ever seen SAI in a puzzle before–Cruciverb’s database shows it in a 2020 Jonesin’ puzzle (same clue but with a comma), a Dec 2021 Sunday NYT clued as a monkey … and two 1994 monkeys. Consider yourself on high alert for subsequent NYT appearances of SAI, my friends. Every 30 or so years, it’s coming to you twice. Mark your calendar for, say, 2050. Prefix URANO– isn’t so hot, and Ethiopia’s Lake TANA isn’t a common midweek entry (source of the Blue Nile, though).
Three quacks from me.
Susan Gelfand’s Universal crossword, “Make and Model” — pannonica’s write-up
It’s a strange marriage that doesn’t make much sense, but the theme here is automobile components that in part share names with articles of clothing. I call shotgun!
- 17a. [Footwear that makes an auto mechanic stop?] BRAKE SHOES.
- 26a. [Casual top that keeps an auto mechanic fueled up?] GAS TANK.
- 37a. [Headwear that helps an auto mechanic stay cool?] RADIATOR CAP.
- 47a. [Waist accessory that transmits an auto mechanic’s movements?] FAN BELT.
- 59a. [Leg covering that prepares an auto mechanic for winter] HEATER HOSE.
We do learn a little about how the various car parts function, which is educational.
- 1d [Moscow moola] RUBLES. Rapidly devaluing of late.
- 6d [Cry of frustration] GAH. Yes! I heartily endorse this entry. An interjection that I frequently employ.
- The longest down clues both have question marks, indicating some word play, which is a good way to keep the solving experience lively over a range of fill. 10d [Will practice?] ESTATE LAW, 33d [Electronic banks?] DATABASES.
28d [Down for the count, briefly] KO’D. This, however, is a kodkod (Leopardus guigna), also known as a güiña, one of the smallest wild cats. They live in southern South America and are listed by the IUCN as threatened.
- 37d [Having the most precipitation] RAINIEST. The complements to Mount Rainier are Mount Rainy and Mount RAINIEST.
- 57d [Word that stops a horse] WHOA. Not WOAH, please (although a horse will not be able to tell the difference).
- 44a [55, say, for a truck] MPH. Weird clue, or just my impression of it?
- 58a [Mid-March date] IDES. Yesterday!
- 52a [Exist] ARE, 65a [“__ that special?”] ISN’T.
Elizabeth C. Gorski’s New Yorker crossword—Matthew’s review
Corner 9s and a stagger stack from Liz Gorski today! Makes for an open and chunky 68-worder.
I particularly like the middle stack of LUNCH ORDERS, GO PAPERLESS, and CAST PARTIES, but each of the corner stacks as well are full of great entries undeniably in my lexicon. This really holds down the fort for any tougher proper nouns – for me MASHA [10d “Three Sisters” sister] and MORT [31d “Mad” cartoonist Drucker].
Some lovely clues in here. [Code broken by Salvatore (Sammy the Bull) Gravano] at 1d (OMERTA) offers nice in with the sobriquet if you don’t recognize the name, and while the misdirection in [36d Accord accelerator] (GAS PEDAL) was actually my first thought, I still appreciate the clue. [Game-show prize, perhaps] for EMMY AWARD at 17a did get me — it’s one of my favorite clues in a while. Into notes:
- 62a [Footwear made by Northern Lites and Yukon Charlie’s] SNOWSHOES. I certainly appreciate the particular brands Liz chose to include in the clue, here.
- 2d [Actress and inventor Hedy who is the subject of the documentary “Bombshell”] LAMARR. A truly remarkable person – I highly recommend the documentary.
- 10d [“Three Sisters” sister] MASHA. Don’t quote me, but seems MASHA is the least common of the three in crosswords. Today she gets her due. When I lived in DC, I attended a play entitled “No Sisters,” which ran at the same time as “Three Sisters” was performed elsewhere in the building, and featured the same cast only onstage when they weren’t needed in the other performance. A real interesting situation.
Malaika Handa’s USA Today Crossword, “Embedded Systems” — Sophia’s recap
Editor: Amanda Rafkin
Theme: Each theme answer contains the letters SYS, spread across two words.
- 17a [Where some artists sell their goods online] – ETSY SHOPS
- 38a [Romantic room in “The Bachelorette”] – FANTASY SUITE
- 64a [Time of year with increased sales] – BUSY SEASON
Busy day at work today so a quick write-up! malaika and I are both software engineers, so it should be a surprise to no one that I really enjoyed the theme of this puzzle. All of the theme answers are solid, with the standout to me being FANTASY SUITE. I also tried to put in “Etsy stores” before ETSY SHOPS, even though that’s not what they’re called.
I don’t mind that the puzzle is asymmetric in order to accommodate different-length theme answers, but I do wish that the SW corner was a little more connected to the rest of the puzzle. That said, all of the longer down answers afforded by the layout choice – LATTE ART, LIME TREE, FESTIVAL, PARSLEY, EDUCATE – are very nice.
Darryl Gonzalez’s LA Times crossword – Gareth’s summary
I spotted what type of theme Darryl Gonzalez’s puzzle was going to be at NIGHTGAMES. That kind of weird compound entry shrieks “both parts of a phrase go with” theme, and sure enough… WINTERENDS (does the clue writer know there is more than one hemisphere?) And so: [WINTER]NIGHT, [WINTER]GAMES. There is also the odd design choice of running the other four theme entries as stacked pairs of tens. So the top is [Winter]ROSE & [Winter]GARDEN; [Winter]GREEN & [Winter]APPLE. The bottom are [Winter]SPORTS, [Winter]PARK; and [Winter]WHEAT & [Winter]BERRY. There sure are a lot of dubiously distinctive [Winter] phrases, and a lot of them are quite similar and repetitive as well.
The theme is very crowded, and the design is mostly short entries and very cut off into sections because of that. There weren’t too many stand out entries, but neither was there too be many outright clunkers. I think I’m OK with NORW? I can imagine it in weird old atlases?
Very insightful, particularly since I don’t know which puzzle you’re commenting about.
NYT: More challenging than the typical Wednesday, but I enjoyed it. SAI and URANO were completely new to me, and I don’t know what ANY of Tolkien’s initials stand for – but crossings seemed fair, and I had no trouble finishing.
Agree with Amy on HAT PEG?!?
I didn’t like the clue for N-TH – “imaginary” doesn’t seem quite right (plus, “imaginary” has a specific meaning in mathematics) – “uncertain,” “indefinite,” maybe?
Agree on all counts, except that I have seen URANO before. I was slow to enter NTH because it just didn’t sound right for the clue. Very much liked the puzzle, though, especially given my usual lack of interest in early-week puzzles. At first I thought I’d never get a foothold, because of all the duck clues mixed with some less obvious answers. But then just going for it made it go quickly.
Oh, and I still hate Shortz’s insistence that C is average. Is he making excuses for his utter lack of interest as a kid (or, for that matter, today) in anything but Harry Potter, Star Wars, and the Simpsons and consequent lousy grades?
I don’t recall where I picked this up from, but I recall from somewhere that A = excellent, B = good, C = average, D = poor and F = fail.
Urania is the Greek Muse of astronomy, if that helps.
Too much theme?
NYT: I was down with the theme … :)
Eider Gree! :D
Safe to assume 52A and 26D (ONE SHOT and NONSTOP) are intentional Hamilton references? In which case ‘duck’ would have been a good piece of advice?
NYT: Every Minnesotan is trying to frantically figure out how to fit “GRAY DUCK” into 67-across.
AVCX: So much fun!
Agree … although I wanted the eight original letters to mean something.
NYT – I think the puzzle was very well constructed. The ballast fill seemed fresh, especially considering the density of the theme material. This may be due to the relatively small number of three letter entries.
About a third of the way through I was growing weary of the theme but by the time I finished I was completely on board. Very nice puzzle!
Interestingly, the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles appear in both the NYT and the WSJ!
Am I the only one that saw a dinosaur in the NYT grid, not a duck?
Ducks, like all birds, are descendants of dinosaurs!
Isn’t 56 Down in the New Yorker puzzle “mow”?
Yes. And your credit score is a FICO score. FICA is totally different.
ha, my bad. thanks for the catch!
LAT: As dupes go, this one strikes me as excessive, since it would have been so easy to clue either of the entries without reference to the computer feature: 5A “Windows navigation aids” for TABS and 22D “Email tab” for SENT. I hope this is leftover puzzle from the old editing regime, not the work of the new one.
I didn’t even understand that clue for SENT. “Email folder”, sure, but “Email tab“?
believe I saw Patti on Twitter say that “her” puzzles will start 4/18