Chris A. McGlothlin’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Cutting the Cord”—Jim P’s review
I thought we just had a puzzle with a “cut the cord” theme, but nope, that was a Universal Sunday joint almost a month ago (good puzzle, by the way).
This one is entirely different and took a fair amount of unraveling. The revealer is UNFRIENDS (36a, [Cuts social media ties with, and what one does to complete the theme answers]). The main theme answers are familiar phrases that are missing certain letters. Those letters spell out synonyms of “friend” and are found elsewhere in the grid.
- 17a. [Absent 59-Down, item on a pretrip to-do list?] GET RENT-A-CAR is Budget Rent-a-car without BUD.
- 26a. [Absent 58-Across, star of the Rome Centurions baseball team?] CAESAR’S ACE is Caesar’s Palace minus PAL.
- 52a. [Absent 24-Across, blow money at an Oman bazaar?] WASTE RIALS is waste materials sans MATE.
- 60a. [Absent 10-Across, performers in a 106.7 Lite FM commercial?] RADIO AD CAST is radio broadcast bereft of BRO.
Impressively done, because there are a lot of pieces to juggle here. It felt like it took a long time to sort out because the missing pieces always seemed to be on the opposite side of the grid somewhere. But I like the premise and execution.
Now, about that fill. There are a lot of pitfalls all around. We had ARENADO crossing ERNIE and NOLAN in the NW, KAMPALA crossing DAKAR and EMIL in the SE, and ZAC crossing ADZES and CIARA in the North. Also not sure that LEGOMAN [One who sticks to his bricks] is a real thing. (The company uses the term minifigure, or minifig, when referring to its little people.) But it is Thursday, and we should be able to handle such adversities (maybe with a little bit of educated guessing). Thankfully, I found my way through.
Highlights include EPAULETS, ARAPAHO, “I’D SAY SO,” ROLLTOP, and BEEFALO. I’ve never seen Marathon Man, so I didn’t know “IS IT SAFE?” (except when Gandalf says, “Is it secret? Is it safe?” in Fellowship).
Clues of note:
- 1a. [Put in place]. LAID. Note that the clue is not [Putin place]. The answer to that one is probably BUNKER.
- 33a. [With 2-Down, three-time National League home run leader]. NOLAN / ARENADO. I certainly didn’t know the name, plus, there’s already a lot of cross-referencing going on in the theme. But if your grid happens to cross both the first and last name of a relatively famous person, you almost have to cross-reference (cross-refer?) them.
- 50a. [Bovine hybrid]. BEEFALO. I had no idea this was a real thing. I only know it from the video game Don’t Starve.
- 54a. [Finnish tennis player Ruusuvuori]. EMIL. Whew. His highest ranking was 66 in 2021. I imagine the only solvers who could get this entry right off the bat are the ones who follow men’s tennis closely.
- 69a. [Farrier’s tool]. RASP. Because a farrier is one who trims horse hooves, not one who uses a RAKE at a gaming table (that’s a croupier).
- 45d. [Capital north of Lake Victoria]. KAMPALA. That’s in Uganda, by the by.
- 46d. [George Sand, George Eliot and George Orwell]. ALIASES. Ha! Come up with something new, people!
- 49d. [Exhibitions covering artists’ careers, for short]. RETROS. Short for retrospectives, I presume?
One of the chewier grids to come down the pike in a while. How did it treat you? Four stars from me.
Peter Gordon’s Fireball Crossword, “Pluses and Minuses” – Jenni’s write-up
This is jumbo Fireball. The theme is clearly described in the title: plus-es and minus-es. Each theme answer has “es” either added or subtracted, and Peter helpfully signals which it is in the clue.
- 23a [What makes one tahini taste better than another? (+)] is SESAME DIFFERENCE (same difference). “One tahini” sounds odd to my ear, but the meaning is evident.
- 27a [Ruffing card in Fiji or Vanuatu? (+)] is MELANESIA TRUMP (Melania Trump). I presume this has something to do with bridge.
- 31d [Figure that’s high when Superman is faster than a speeding bullet? (-)] is CAPE VELOCITY (escape velocity).
- 42d [Chain that doesn’t compete much with Dairy Queen? (+)] is ESCAROLE KING (Carole King). This is my favorite.
- 46a [Online gaming competitions played with soap operas? (+)] is SERIAL ESPORTS (serial ports).
- 58a [Nobleman’s embossed emblem? (-)] is EARL‘S SEAL (earless seal). At least I think that’s the base phrase. I’ve heard of eared seals, which I suppose implies the existence of earless seals, and Wikipedia confirms that they exist.
- 82a [One who praises a golfing prop? (-)] is a TEE LAUDER (Estee Lauder).
- 93a [Stronghold that’s under a spell? (-)] is the ENCHANTED FORT (enchanted forest).
- 109a [Markers that indicate the distance to a toilet? (++)] are JOHN MILESTONES (John Milton). Double the fun!
- 118a [Stayed away from Clotho, Lachesis, and Atropos? (++)] is ESCHEWED THE FATES (chewed the fat).
Wow. That’s a lot of theme material. All the base phrases are solid (earless seals may be a bit obscure, but they’re legit) and the zany answers are amusing. I grokked the theme early on, which helped me solve the puzzle, but the theme answers weren’t obvious. So not blazingly hard or ridiculously tricky. Solid, fun, and worth the solving time.
I was going to grouse about being Natick’ed at the intersection of 6d [Onetime alternative to a Sebring] and 26a [Loser to Dua Lipa for the 2018 Best New Artist Grammy] because I there are lots of more accessible ways to clue HER, so this is Peter being cute in the service of never reusing a clue, and for some reason I thought the Sebring was some kind of racing car. It’s not. 6d is ALERO which should have been obvious to me once I had the other letters, so that one was my fault. So why am I telling you about this? I’m telling you because if you haven’t seen this clip of Dua Lipa and Stephen Colbert, you need to stop right now and watch it.
OK. A few other things.
- We see PEDICABS whenever we’re in NYC. I can’t bring myself to ride in one. I think that’s partly a legacy of having been 200 lbs overweigh for about 10 years, and partly because it seems – awkward.
- When I was a kid growing up in NY, I associated the POCONOS with the cheesy ads for Mt Airy Lodge. Now I live an hour away and yet I’ve never been in a heart-shaped bathtub.
- Could someone explain to me why LIE is a [Concern for a pitcher]?
- Among the many horrors of 2020 was a hurricane season so overstuffed that we Hurricane ETA pounded Central America.
- Does anyone use NORW as an abbreviation for Norway? No? I didn’t think so.
What I didn’t know before I solved this puzzle: that Barry MANILOW wrote the “I am stuck on Band-Aid” jingle. I also did not know that John Travolta appeared in the commercial.
Daniel Bodily and Jeff Chen’s New York Times Crossword — Sophia’s recap
Hi folks! Sophia here filling in for Ben on a tricky Thursday puzzle.
Theme: Each theme answer is a phrase comprised of circled letters and uncircled letters. Read left to right, the circled letters spell a word that means “trash”, while the uncircled letters spell the word that’s hinted at by the clue itself. So in order for the clue to make sense, you need to TAKE OUT THE TRASH.
- 18a [*Secure] – LITTLE ROCK (LITTER + LOCK)
- 23a [*Trick] – WILD ROSES (WILE + DROSS)
- 50a [*Speck] – IOWA STATE (IOTA + WASTE)
- 59a [*Riot] – SHOOT CRAPS (SCRAPS + HOOT)
- 37a [What to do before the answers to the starred clues will make sense] – TAKE OUT THE TRASH
I’m kind of stunned that there are enough phrases that can be made out of a trash word + another word to make any type of puzzle, let alone four symmetric answers that work with a grid spanning revealer. I personally found this puzzle to be pretty hard! I think there’s a few reasons for that:
- The revealer has no clue to the phrase itself, only what it meant to the rest of the puzzle. Not having the clue be, say, “Item on a chore list, or what to do… (etc etc)” meant that I had to puzzle out what the revealer was entirely from crosses, since I hadn’t gotten any of the across theme answers yet, since I didn’t know how to make them make sense since I didn’t have the revealer! An infinite loop.
- Each of the thematic clues is very short/vague, and the answer takes up less than half of the boxes in the answer.
- I didn’t know what DROSS meant. (This may have been a personal issue.)
Combine all that with tricky but great clues like 34d [Popular site for holiday gift orders] for SANTA’S LAP, 53d [What a jalapeño has that a habanero lacks] for TILDE, and 49d [Flip-flop] for THONG, and the bottom half of the puzzle took forever to come together for me. It’s Thursday, though, so I appreciate the challenge.
Finally, congrats to Daniel on his NYT debut! How did this puzzle play for y’all? Sound off in the comments!
Erica Hsiung Wojcik & Kate Chin Park’s USA Today Crossword, “Cracker Boxes” — Sophia’s recap
Editor: Amanda Rafkin
Theme: Each theme answer begins with a type of cracker.
- 19a [Zebra or leopard pattern on clothing, say] – ANIMAL PRINT (animal crackers)
- 36a [Upscale hotel chain] – RITZ CARLTON (Ritz crackers)
- 58a [Salty condiment for bok choy] – OYSTER SAUCE (oyster crackers)
Cute theme! Each answer perfectly fits in, and is an exciting stand-alone answer besides. It took me a while to see RITZ CARLTON, partially because the clue is somewhat unspecific, and also because I attended Carleton College so I always spell the hotel wrong.
So many answers and clues made me smile as I was solving! There were some great longer answers (see: NO FILTER, TOO CUTE, TOP FORTY), some funny clues (see: 3d [Response to “Who wants to run a bunch of boring errands?”] for NOT ME), and I learned some new things (see: that o.b. makes TAMPONs, and that CHINESE encompasses Hakka and Mandarin). I also loved how many food clues/answers were in the puzzle aside from the theme: Smarties DISCs, pie CRUST, PITA, bao, even aquafaba for the VEGANS. Overall, this crossword gave me exactly what I’m looking for in a USA Today puzzle.
Brendan Emmett Quigley’s Crossword #1453, “Wearing of the Green”—Darby’s review
Theme: Each theme answer is framed by letters that, once put together, are a shade of green.
- 17a [“Approximately”] MORE OR LESS / MOSS
- 26a [“Recorded the score”] KEPT TALLY / KELLY
- 31a [“System.out.printin(‘Hello world’); e.g.”] JAVA CODE / JADE
- 42a [“1962 Neil Simon musical”] LITTLE ME / LIME
- 49a [“Relating to smell”] OLFACTIVE / OLIVE
- 59a [“Producing a better result”] FOR THE BEST / FORREST
Happy St. Paddy’s to those who celebrate! This puzzle certainly seems to do so. I figured out the theme based on FOR THE BEST first, wondering also with OLFACTIVE, even though I could only think of OLFACTORY initially. Once I got those two, it was easier to tick the themers into place and that really helped to speed along my solve. As always, I was impressed that BEQ was able to shove six themers into this puzzle. There are few places where I could see the trade off in doing so, such as 18d [“___ acid”] OLEIC crossing MORE OR LESS. However, for the most part, I thought that this was a relatively accessible, if a tad challenging puzzle.
I was amused by the double Y combo doing down in 13d [“Format for entering some dates”] MMDDYY crossing KEPT TALLY and 30a [“Opinionated work”] ESSAY. Plus the double combo of 45d [“Crime investigation necessity”] MOTIVE and 46d [“Crime investigation excuses”] ALIBI crossing OLFACTIVE were both solid and good fun. I also learned about teletypewriters (TTYs) in 62a [“Comm. device for the deaf”] which was really interesting.
Finally, I loved that BEQ slipped EIRE in there via 36d [“Michael D. Higgins’s republic”], and while Higgins is the president of the country, I would have also loved if the opportunity to learn more about a revolutionary Irish woman or person or color who is a little less known, especially since the crosses of ISLES, LITTLE ME, RAN OVER, and OLFACTIVE would have provided support here. Nevertheless, I love the commitment to a St. Patrick’s Day theme.
Julie Bérubé’s LA Times crossword – Gareth’s summary
Julie Bérubé’s theme is tres elegant. I’m a sucker for idiom collection themes, and this one collects X(ON)Y phrases, stacking them in such a way as to imply the on. So we have WALK/EGGSHELLS, STAND/CEREMONY, SIT/THEFENCE and FALL/HARDTIMES.
Stacked theme entries create there own grid-filling intricacies. This is borne out by a high number of very difficult answers – old-skool crosswordese, if you will. Hope you remembered ALGOL, ESSEN, NTEST, and AMAH! YNOT was also quite a deep cut, but guessable. If I were an editor, I’d have sent it back to finesse the grid some more, even if it required some extra “helper” squares.
Taylor Johnson’s Universal Crossword, “I’m Torn!”— Jim Q’s write-up
Little bit of a morbid title, now that I look at it!
THEME: Phrases that satisfy the phrase ______ IN THE ______ where the first word is a body part are presented literally.
- NEPAINCK. Pain in the Neck.
- FASLAPCE. Slap in the Face.
- BASTABCK. Stab in the Back.
- BUKICKTT. Kick in the Butt.
- (revealer) BODY WRAPS.
I’ve seen this type of literal theme several times, but I’m a sucker for it. Fun stuff, made tighter with the body parts surrounding the first word. Also nice that all the body parts are four letters, as are the words inside.
- LOEB Been a while since I’ve seen her name in a puzzle! She used to be in what felt like every other grid.
- DS LITE. New to me. Looks like I missed the boat on that one since it’s retired now.
- OH NO NO. A tad bit of side-eye for me there.
- PET DOG. Erm. I just call it a DOG.
Those nits are a small price to pay for some really nice long entries, abundant in this puzzle. ONE TO ONE, CALLS IT, EXIT POLL, FAB FOUR, etc.
Thanks for this!
I think Teri Garr was in that Band-Aid commercial, too!
Pretty sure the “lie” it’s referring to is the golf term for where the ball is on the course and the “pitcher” is the person “pitching” or hitting the shot.
Probably using a pitching wedge.
Very ho-hum trick for a Thursday NYT, was this another debut or something? Bottom half fill clunky top half very easy. Not very impressive.
WSJ weekend magazine had an ad for a double breasted suit, so they will soon no longer be RETRO. I had half a dozen Hugo Boss back in the eighties, only problem was alwayunbuttoning them to sit. They are a bit formal
Today’s WSJ on the other hand was quite the construction, very impressive. Normally I despise jumping around to related fill(s) but despite not liking that I have ultimate admiration for this puzzle and its construction. It was BLOODY and brutal
One of the more difficult ones I have done in a long while, plus I learned LIMN. Quite the contrast to NYT Thursday LITE today, sheeeeeeesh
NYT: Two themers I got first were IOWA STATE and LITTLE ROCK. I thought we were also tying in the NCAA tournament with college names, but alas, the last two were simply random.
Enjoyable puzzle — very Thursday-esque.
Re yesterday’s Fireball, can someone explain why the answer to 2D (ERE) is clued as “Pound palindrome”? Seems like an attempt to clue a common bit of crossword fill in a novel way, but I’m not seeing it. Thanks!
Peter enlightened me as to the clue – it’s a reference to Ezra Pound, who used “ere” in his poetry.
BEQ – I was derailed by the SE corner; did not know the pop culture references and had to look one up to get the correct fill. I also was unaware that “Oz” was a nickname for Australia – after I filled in “GDay” I looked it up and noticed that Oz is also a town in the Isere region of France – a nice tie in (or at least a raised eyebrow) to 7D.
WSJ The review makes this observation: “1a. [Put in place]. LAID. Note that the clue is not [Putin place]. The answer to that one is probably BUNKER.” Well, BUNKER won’t fit but HELL does.
WSJ–Too many obscure fills for me–glad I didn’t spend much time on it.
Thanks, Jim, for the review! Happy you enjoyed it!