Sunday, May 29, 2022

LAT 10:05 (Gareth) 


NYT 7:49 (Amy) 


Universal untimed (Jim Q)  


Universal (Sunday) 4:51 (Jim P) 


USA Today 4:35 (Darby) 


WaPo untimed (Jim Q) 


Daniel Bodily & Jeff Chen’s New York Times crossword, “A Monumental Centennial”—Amy’s write-up

NY Times crossword solution, 5 29 22, “A Monumental Centennial”

Amy here, stepping in for Nate, who, like any Californian worth their salt, is off making a movie.

I wouldn’t have thought of celebrating the centennial of a national monument being built, but here we are. The grid art dedicated to the LINCOLN MEMORIAL include’s HONEST ABE‘s STOVEPIPE HAT and the Memorial itself. The black squares in the middle sort of look like the SAVIOR OF THE UNION (haven’t heard that epithet before) is sitting on top of his monument with his arms and legs flung high in glee. Lincoln’s BEARD, GREAT EMANCIPATOR and RAIL SPLITTER nicknames, and [what this puzzle’s subject promised in his most famous address], A NEW BIRTH / OF FREEDOM. (He didn’t know that the backlash to Reconstruction would trash that new freedom for Black Americans for decades to follow.) Oh! And the three stranded 3-letter entries between the Memorial’s columns are PRE, SID, and ENT, so that spells PRESIDENT. If you had no idea what letters you needed for 107d. [___ the Kid, rhyming N.H.L. nickname], well, no other letter starts a common (nick)name with the *ID pattern, and if you thought it might be SYD, well, it ain’t PRE/SYD/ENT.

Fave fill: SKINNY-DIP! Lincoln was skinny. You think he ever went skinny-dipping?

Three more things:

  • 12d. [One-eyed giant?], HURRICANE. Great clue.
  • 63d. [Accessory in which this puzzle’s subject stashed important documents], STOVEPIPE HAT. Wait, what?! Is this for real? Like, while the hat was sitting on his desk, or while it was perched atop his head?
  • 72d. [Subject of the seven-letter mnemonic PALE GAS], SINS. That’s helpful! And I’d never seen this before. So that’s pride, avarice, lust, envy, gluttony, wrAth, and sloth? With anger standing in for wrath? That makes it less helpful.

I enjoyed learning that hat trivia, but “a bunch of phrases relating to something historical” doesn’t make for the most amusing crossword. A 21×21 puzzle with no humor inherent to the theme is a lot of squares to solve without wordplay. 3.75 stars from me.

Drew Schmenner’s Universal Sunday crossword, “A Cut Above the Rest”—Jim P’s review

No revealer in today’s puzzle, but a hint comes in the clue to the first theme answer. Combining the hint with the title of the puzzle, we learn that the starred clues’ answers contain a word that is a type of haircut and that word sits atop another entry which contains the letters –REST–.

Universal Sunday crossword solution · “A Cut Above the Rest” · Drew Schmenner · 5.29.22

  • 23a. [*Conclude, as a film (Note the first word of each starred clue’s answer, plus the letters below that word)] FADE TO BLACK atop 27a. [One who brings a painting back to life] ART RESTORER.
  • 50a. [*Pixar toy who said “To infinity and beyond!”] BUZZ LIGHTYEAR atop 57a. [Phrase on old New York license plates] EMPIRE STATE. I’m looking forward to the upcoming BUZZ LIGHTYEAR movie which looks very interesting.
  • 85a. [*Alien attempts at agriculture?] CROP CIRCLES atop 89a. [Where a DIYer might get supplies] HARDWARE STORE. I can’t not mention the Weird Al song of the same name which I only learned about recently. There’s no official video, but a fan-made video is quite good (see below). (The litany of items in the middle of the song is worth the price of admission.)
  • 114a. [*Thick floor coverings] SHAG CARPETS atop 119a. [What a flight attendant asks passengers to find] NEAREST EXIT.

I can’t say I paid much attention to the theme during the solve, and I don’t know that it would’ve helped me a whole lot. After all, I don’t know what a crop haircut is. But the entries themselves are fun and I’m impressed at the execution here with such long entries stacked atop one another.

In the fill I’m liking PIANO ROLL, PREP COOKS, MOHAWKS (clued appropriately as the people, not the hairstyle), “NICE TRY,” SAD SACK, KNEEPAD, and LETS RIP. Not really sure that “CAN’T I?” is something people actually say, but other than that, smooth fill all around.

In fact the fill is so smooth that I racked up a solve time that I’m still not sure I believe. I’ve never solved a 21x so quickly before.

Clues of note:

  • 13d. [Standing order?]. “ALL RISE.” Fave clue of the puzzle right there. Just perfect.
  • 88d. [Name in parliament?]. LIAM. There it is-> parLIAMent.

Solid theme and an enjoyable grid. 3.75 stars.

Zhouqin Burnikel’s USA Today crossword, “Parting Gift”—Darby’s write-up

Editor: Erik Agard

Theme: Each theme answer breaks up GIFT so that the answer starts with G and ends with IFT, literally “parting gift.”

Theme Answers

Zhouqin Burnikel's USA Today crossword, "Parting Gift" solution for 5/29/2022

Zhouqin Burnikel’s USA Today crossword, “Parting Gift” solution for 5/29/2022

  • 16a [“‘Know what I’m saying?’”] GET MY DRIFT
  • 37a [“Wee-hours work period”] GRAVEYARD SHIFT
  • 63a [“Feature of Issa and Molly’s relationship in the fourth season of ‘Insecure’”] GROWING RIFT

This theme was really fun. While I don’t watch Insecure, it was easy enough to start on the crosses with GROWING RIFT and then to fill it in completely as it became apparent. I also thought that GET MY DRIFT was a fun one. I don’t hear people say it super often, but it was still pretty clear and set a nice precedent for the themers to follow.

This grid is asymmetric, and I think that the SW corner ends up feeling a little segmented off from the rest of the puzzle, with its only real opening coming through the themers. The same could also be said for the NE corner, with openings only through 29a [“Body part beneath a necklace clasp”] NAPE, GRAVEYARD SHIFT, and 55a [“Make a blunder”] ERR. However, the middle feels very connected, and it’s easy to flow downward through the grid.

A few things I noticed:

  • 33a [“Tsukemono seasoning”] – Tsukemono are Japanese pickles that are typically brined in SALT. They’re sometimes used in a meal for one to refresh after eating richer foods. There are a variety of types, which you can learn more about here.
  • 42a [“Phillipa who voiced Chang’e in ‘Over the Moon’”] – I first learned about Phillipa SOO when she originated the role of Eliza Schuyler in Hamilton on Broadway, but she also originated the role of Natasha Rostova in Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812. Over the Moon is a 2020 animated fantasy film that decides to construct a rocket in order to meet a mythical moon goddess. It is available on Netflix.
  • 15d [“___ canai (flatbread dish)”] ROTI canai is also known as roti paratha and is popular in Malaysia. They also look delicious!

Overall, such a fun Sunday puzzle!

Evan Birnholz’s Washington Post crossword, “Business Meetings”— Jim Q’s write-up

This puzzle really gets down to business. And across.

THEME: Well known businesses/corporations meet, and their central crossings spell out a word.

Washington Post, May 29, 2022, Evan Birnholz, “Business Meetings” solution grid


  • PROM NIGHTS / MARSALIS. Omni / Mars. M.
  • SAINT ELMO / CUBE ROOTS. Intel / Uber. E.
  • OXFORD BLUE / LASER TAG. Ford / Serta. R
  • INDOLENCE / LIKE A ROCK. Dole / Ikea. E.
  • (Revealer of spelled out word) MERGER

We’ve all had those moments when a word you think or accidentally enter coincidentally appears in the grid later in the solve. But I had one of those moments that was mind blowing just now. When FORD and SERTA met, I thought to myself “They would make an excellent SLEEPER CAR!” Then I uncovered SLEEPER CAR, and I had to pause and wonder if I hit upon another layer of theme. Nope. Just a very wild c0incidence. Anyone else have one of those moments worth noting?

Anyway, this is a breezy over-the-plate puzzle today. The elevator is back on the ground floor and this is accessible to all. This is one of those puzzles that doesn’t seem so complicated but there are a lot of theme answers that need to cross at specific areas, so much more complex than what meets the eye. Some really nice finds to boot! Nothing seems forced (OXFORD BLUE is new to me, but that’s it) and the businesses are all very well known crossword regulars. I did enjoy that MARSALIS made an appearance. That’s personal though: My pup is named after the patriarch of the family, Ellis MARSALIS, who died of Covid complications on the same day my pup was born,.

EGAD clue for the win. [Exclamation that Robin theoretically could have used instead of phrases such as “Holy oleo!” or “Holy bargain basements, Batman!” (he actually said those)] That’s great. Especially because the answer is so short and common. Also, how in hell did they not break character when they said those stupid phrases on set?

Not too much else to say about this one. I liked it! And of course, we are very pampered with the Birnholzian added layer. This one, MERGER, was elegant and apt.

David Alfred Bywaters’ LA Times crossword, “Day Trading” – Gareth’s summary

LA Times

I am going to assume this puzzle theme by David Alfred Bywaters is based on an American abbreviation convention I have never seen. MTW and F stand in for four of the five weekdays, and Th is the odd one out with a two letter abbreviation. Another oddity of the puzzle theme, is the use of four theme pairs: Monday and Tuesday swap to make wacky phases, then Tuesday and Wednesday, Wednesday and Thursday, and finally Thursday and Friday. The weekend disappears and Monday and Friday only appear once.


  • [First the chardonnay, then the merlot, then the cabernet?], T(M)ASTERPLAN and [Invisible walls?], M(T)IMELIMITS
  • [Inept caner’s resource?], W(T)ICKERTAPE, and [Meteorology lectures?], W(T)ALKSONAIR
  • [Bungalow owner’s challenge to a roofer?], TH(W)ATCHTHIS and [Makes doubly sure everyone’s in on the joke?], W(TH)INKSTWICE
  • [Appreciative sound from the alumni luxury box?], F(TH)UNDERCLAP. It took me a while to parse funder as “one who funds”; and [Water cooler?], F(TH)IRSTBASE

While the theme was a bit more tricky than many Sunday LAT’s, being based on wacky phrases, the rest of the grid was fairly straightforward. [Term with a check mark on an airport sign] TSEPRE was pretty opaque to this non-American. On the other hand, [Pills for pets, often], CHEWABLES was firmly in my bailiwick… Not all chewables are very appetizing; Rimadyl, however, is  dangerously delicious though, and has resulted a good unintentional pet OD’s in its time…


Gary Larson’s Universal Crossword, “Mixed Doubles” — Jim Q’s write-up

Before I solved this puzzle, I noticed a typo in my WaPo write-up (I’m typo prone). And I changed “to” to “too.” How timely.

THEME: Phrases with different to’s in them (I don’t know how one spells that word when referring to them collectively).

Universal crossword solution · “Mixed Doubles” · Gary Larson · Sunday. 05.29.22



I’m not entirely sure I have the theme right. It seems paper thin. Is there an element I’m missing? What does the title mean? Oh… ok… like 2 is “double” and there are four different iterations so they’re mixed? But the only one that means “double” is the 2 version… I’m so confused. Gonna stop thinking about it. Why these phrases though out of the plethora that one could find? Ok. Gonna stop thinking about it now.

In the fill, PAIUTES is very new to me. I needed every cross and triple checked to make sure it was right. That’s a pretty long entry for a word that might not be familiar to some. Does anyone say “YUM! YUM!” I know it as the excellent sauce at hibachi. MARLO Thomas was new to me.

Liked the clue for HOAGIES!

All in all, Universal and I didn’t click this weekend. Oh well. Next weekend ain’t so far away!

2.5 stars from me.


This entry was posted in Daily Puzzles and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

24 Responses to Sunday, May 29, 2022

  1. huda says:

    NYT: I don’t usually love tribute puzzles, but I love Lincoln and so I liked this one.
    But I did wind up with an error, which I couldn’t find.
    I had MALT and AVA instead of MELT and EVA…

    PS. When I first looked at the puzzle design, I thought it might be about Charlie Chaplin…

    • zevonfan says:

      Huda, You’re not the only one.

      I had MALT and AVA too!!! I checked the puzzle over twice and could not find why the “happy pencil” didn’t come up.

      I always get my crossword “AVA” and “EVA”s confused unless it’s EVA Peron or EVA Gabor.

    • EricH says:

      Fun puzzle, except for the inexcusable MELT/EVA crossing. Either give MELT a less ambiguous clue or pick an EVA who’s better known (Señora Peron wasn’t doing anything today).

      Maybe I’m just bitter because it took me 10 minutes to find that mistake. Maybe I’m just mad at myself because I’ve seen “Casino Royale” twice and every episode of my series “Penny Dreadful” (in which EVA Green has a major role). Sigh. Maybe next time I will remember her name.

    • Art Shapiro says:

      Add me to the list. Otherwise, an interesting Sunday puzzle. BTW, does ANYBODY outside of the crossword world use the verb AVIATE???

    • JohnH says:

      Same mistake here. I still don’t care for tribute puzzles, where the theme fill won’t entail much in the way of thought or surprises, but I guess I can put up with it for Lincoln’s sake.

      Not sure it’s right to say that his second inaugural is more famous than the Gettysburg address, but no big deal.

  2. Dook says:

    Very surprised that the NYT isn’t rating highly. I thought it was brilliant. Several long answers, all of which are interesting and a good part of the theme. A grid that includes BOTH the building AND Abe himself. Plus the PRESIDENT. And on top of all that, the fill is good with very few clunkers. Five stars!

    • EricH says:

      Impressive construction, yes. Good fill, yes.

      Fun to solve? Maybe. (It’s hard for me to judge given the amount of time I spent finding my error at EVA/MELT. They should have given MELT an unambiguous clue.)

      I’ve noticed that the ratings here tend to skew low. (As I write this, the highest rating for any of today’s puzzles is 3.17.) Maybe it’s only the people dissatisfied with a puzzle who come here to rate it? And keep in mind that the sample size is small.

    • John F. Ervin says:

      I concur. I thought this was exceptional. I think some reviewers are too harsh in their write-ups, Rex Parker comes to mind. I appreciate the time and effort that must have went into the construction of this puzzle. Thank you Daniel and Jeff.

  3. marciem says:

    NYT: I’m with Amy on celebrating a National Monument being built…why? When I saw the theme I wondered if Abe’s birth records had changed or what?

    And I’m embarrassed to admit it took me forever to understand the Pre Sid Ent in the monument , I just couldn’t figure out the purpose of those words. DOH!

    otherwise, sort of a breezy, slog-less Sunday puzzle and I enjoyed it. Not sure why Melt/Eva didn’t hang me up… just luck on that one. I have trouble with Eva/Ava as well as Ana/Ann .

    eta: YAAAY my name is back! :)

    • David L says:

      My name is back too — but now the site doesn’t remember my Spelling Bee result from the previous day, so I can’t see what I missed. Oh well, win some, lose some.

  4. Christopher Smith says:

    NYT: Cluing SCAT, a vocal form typically associated with Black singers, to something from Song of the South that isn’t really scat singing, in a puzzle dedicated to Lincoln, is…interesting.

    • marciem says:

      agreed. I found that bizarre, to say the least. Scat? Not. Song of the South? Oh no they didn’t!! I didn’t see any explanation for that at Wordplay.

  5. John O says:

    I’m feeling extra smug today because I correctly guessed on ‘melt’/’eva’ instead of ‘malt’/ava.

    I don’t know if there’s been a change at the LA Times crosswords, but I feel that its Sunday puzzle has been consistently better the last several weeks or months.

    • Christina says:

      Yes, Rich Norris retired, and Patti Varol is the editor – her edited puzzles have been appearing since April 18.

  6. Patrick M says:

    NYT: If it’s any consolation, John Quincy Adams used to skinny-dip in the Potomac (or maybe it was a tributary) during his presidency.

  7. John says:

    The Lincoln Memorial was dedicated 100 years ago (on Memorial Day). Although blacks were allowed to attend; seating was segregated (according to the news report I heard this morning). Disgraceful.

    I thought the puzzle was really well done. Knew Eva but took me too long to come up with melt.

  8. yrmother says:

    I guessed melt/eva but then changed it to malt/ava. oh well.
    I always understood that skinnydipping referred to swimming in the buff rather than just a brief immersion.

  9. yrmother says:

    P. S. I print the puzzles out and solve on paper rather than online, so I don’t have the happy pencil withholding its approval and hence am not aware of errors of this sort.

    • huda says:

      That’s actually a real advantage. It doesn’t spoil the experience (and the streak…).

    • MarkAbe says:

      I bow to you, mother. Personally, I switched to on-line decades ago just because hitting “Delete” is so much faster than pencil erasing.

  10. Bill Nichols says:

    Bland. Felt like a sixth grade term paper.
    Grade: C+

Comments are closed.