Mike Shenk’s Wall Street Journal crossword, “Jump Cuts”—Jim P’s review
Let’s start with the title. In filmmaking, a jump cut is when a segment of a continuous scene is cut out and the action of the film appears to “jump” from one part of the scene to a future part of the scene, thus giving the film a certain amount of energy. You see this a lot in montages where there are multiple jump cuts in a row. (Here’s an example.)
In today’s puzzle, each theme answer “jumps” across a block to a separate entry. The longer entry clues the entire row (both entries) while the shorter entry is a word that can be a synonym of “cut.”
Wall St Journal crossword solution · “Jump Cuts” · Mike Shenk · Thu., 8.25.22
- 17a. [Oscar-winning producer of “Gone With the Wind”] / 19a. [Cut]: DAVID O. SELZ / NICK.
- 26a. [Cut] / 29a. [Night vision devices]: SNIP / ER SCOPES.
- 47a. [Tree with creamy white blossoms] / 49a. [Cut]: FLOWERIN / G ASH.
- 62a. [Cut] / 63a. [Development influencer]: PARE / NTING STYLE.
Longtime WSJ solvers will recognize this type of theme as one of editor Mike Shenk’s mainstays. It feels like it’s been a while since we’ve seen one, but when I read the title, I thought this might be what was going on.
I wouldn’t say I love this theme type, but it works, especially in this case with a good title. I did have a hard time with FLOWERING ASH since I’d never heard of it, and I had to rely on some really musty gray cells to pull out DAVID O. SELZNICK, especially that S crossing another proper name, WES Studi. (But I appreciate this Cherokee actor being given some puzzle time. You may also have seen him in The Last of the Mohicans and Mystery Men.)
Top fill: DELOREAN, PANCREAS, GLITCH, GAZEBO, and STARKIST. (Aside: We have a Sunkist brand and a STARKIST brand; why is there no Moonkist brand?)
Clues of note:
- 15a. [Some is social]. MEDIA. I would’ve been perfectly happy with an “are” in this clue. If someone wants to explain why “is” is correct here, feel free.
- 25a. [Manhattan setting]. BAR. Where you’d find a Manhattan cocktail.
- 7d. [Gore’s time in the Senate?]. IDES. I’m sure you figured out by now that this is not about Al Gore. Rather, it’s a gruesome allusion to Caesar’s assassination.
- 49d. [Unforeseen setback]. GLITCH. We also would have accepted [___ in the Matrix].
3.5 stars.
Olivia Mitra Framke and Andrea Carla Michaels’ New York Times crossword—Ben’s review
NYT #0825 – 08/25/2022
There was a nice sense of an “aha” once I got the revealer on today’s NYT from Olivia Mitra Framke and Andrea Carla Michaels :
- 20A: Buckeye-Hawkeye-Yellowhammer — OHIOWALABAMA
- 27A: Pine Tree-Cornhusker-Sunflower — MAINEBRASKANSAS
- 47A: Green Mountain-Treasure-Last Frontier — VERMONTANALASKA
- 54A: U.S. geographical grouping…or a hint to 20A, 27A, and 47A — TRI-STATE AREA
We’ve got three TRI-STATE AREAs – OHIO-IOWA-ALABAMA, MAINE-NEBRASKA-KANSAS, and VERMONT-MONTANA-ALASKA, all set up to overlap on top of one another
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WDVOZLKSLRc
65A: Patsy Cline, for one — ALTO
Happy Thursday!
Sara Cantor’s USA Today Crossword, “One Plus One” — Sophia’s recap
Editor: Erik Agard
Theme: Each theme answer includes the string “one” two times.
USA Today, 08 25 2022, “One Plus One”
- 16a [“There’s no going back”] – WHAT’S DONE IS DONE
- 36a [Took a trip after the wedding] – HONEYMOONED
- 59a [Rotary dial successors] – TOUCH TONE PHONES
If yesterday’s puzzle was about group theory, today’s deals with some much simpler math. I really like the theme answers Sara chose here, particularly the grid spanning ones. They all do an effective job of concealing the “ones”, especially the latter two answers where the one is not in a repeated word.
I’ve heard from USA Today constructors that the reason symmetry isn’t required is because of the high standards for fill. Today’s puzzle has both great fill and maintains its symmetry. Impressive stuff. Some random fill/clue thoughts:
- I put in ITEM for the first [Part of a to-do list] clue and was sad when it was TASK instead… but very happy when the same [Part of a to-do list] clue was for ITEM a little further in the puzzle.
- I’m straight up obsessed with the NE and SW corners of this puzzle. They’re big and filled incredibly well. FUN HOME! HOT SAUCE! YEEHAW! I’m in love.
- I also had to love the NE corner because I’ve probably watched “The Parent Trap” more than any other movie ever. ANNIE for [Hallie’s twin in “The Parent Trap”] was an immediate get for me.
- I was on this puzzle’s wavelength for the most part, but 1a [Pro cornhole org.] was a complete mystery to me. Apparently, it’s ACL, which stands for “American Cornhole League”. Seems legit.
Lee Taylor’s Universal Crossword, “See You Around!” — Jim Q’s write-up
THEME: Synonyms for “girl” can be found at the beginnings and ends of common phrases when combined.
Universal crossword solution · See You Around! · Lee Taylor · Thursday. 08.25.22
THEME ANSWERS:
- BELINDA CARLISLE. BELLE.
- MIDDLE CLASS. MISS.
- LATERAL PASS. LASS.
- (revealer) GIRL INTERRUPTED.
A fine, simple, and clean idea here. Unfortunately it suffers from Universal’s inability to utilize the basic, common practice of circling letters to draw solvers’ attention to the correct area, so instead they are asked to interpret instructions like this: [Lead singer of the Go-Go’s (In this answer, note the first 3 letters + the last 2)] then later this [Bourgeois (first 2 letters + last 2)]. I have personally witnessed new solvers interpret instructions like this independently with a 0% success rate. It may seem simple to seasoned solvers, but those instructions are very confusing to newer ones, for whom the Universal puzzle should be accessible. Bummer that he unique-to-Universal “count the letters” concept is still being practiced by the self-proclaimed “[setter of] standards for all daily crosswords.”
Of course, while David is kind enough to give us a “proper” version at this site, the practice of offering a second version appeases the crowd that would be most likely to write to Andrews McMeel with the suggestion that they update their software and bring it out of the late 90s. The masses who solve on paper or on the webapp get confusing directions, and new solvers are left “unhooked” as they feel that the directions are above their heads (from my first-hand experience).
Anyway, the puzzle itself is just fine. Everything here was pretty much over the plate! Nothing to really dislike. Not a lot of longer fill entries, so I was hoping the longer entries would have a lot of zing to them. These ones do the job, but it never felt “lively” to me.
I did enjoy the revealer, and my favorite fun fact was that the MPAA was renamed in 2019. Who knew? Now it’s MPA. They lost an A. Go figure.
3 stars from me with circles.
2 stars without.
Brendan Emmett Quigley’s Crossword #1499, “The Wild Party”—Darby’s review
Note: This is a rerun from BEQ, but he updated some of the clues.
Theme: Each theme answer is a term for getting drunk, and each clue refers to a guest at this “Wild Party.” Together, the answer is a specific play on who the guest is.
Theme Answers
Brendan Emmett Quigley’s Crossword #1499, “Wild Party” solution for 8/25/2022
- 8a [“Last night at the party, everyone was so drunk, the garbageman was ___”] STINKO
- 17a [“…those carpenters were ___”] HAMMERED
- 21a [“…that guy who works at Jiffy Lube was ___”] WELL-OILED
- 30a [“…Patrick Mahomes was ___”] BLITZED
- 35a [“…Frosty the Snowman was ___”] OUT COLD
- 40a [“…the guest of honor was ___”] TOASTED
- 42a [“…those UFO abductees were ___] FAR GONE
- 48a [“…Mr. Magoo was ___”] BLIND
- 53a [“…the mason was__”] PLASTERED
- 59a [“…that guy with strabismus was ___”] COCKEYED
There are so many theme answers here! It sounds like a wild party! As I was solving, it also felt a bit like a MadLib, especially in that 8a kicked off the narrative and the ellipses continued it. I could’ve done without COCKEYED since it feels a bit teasing, but I thought that BLITZED, OUT COLD, and TOASTED were amazing.
Generally, with this much theme content, I thought the fill was pretty smooth. It’s definitely a little tight in each of the corners feeling cut off around the plus sign in the middle, and TER, SCAG, and ULAN all in the middle right section weren’t my favorite. However, the cluing was really fresh, and, as is apparent, there were a lot of themers.
Some other faves:
- 39a [“Steep object?”] – It took me a bit to get there with this answer, but it’s SUCH a clever way to clue TEABAG.
- 44a [“‘Everything Everywhere All at Once’ star”] – I still haven’t seen this Michelle YEOH movie, but I’m always happy to see her pop up in different settings. Such a badass.
- 54d [“‘Twenties’ creator Waithe”] – I’m always happy to see LENA Waithe pop up in puzzles, and this was certainly no exception.
Overall, definitely a fun puzzle that is bananas packed with theme content.
Hoang-kim Vu’s LA Times crossword – Gareth’s summary
LA Times
220825
The theme of Hoang-kim Vu’s puzzle is kind of difficult to pin down. The four long across answers are job-related predicates. They are clued whimsically as though to apply to a different job using alternative interpretations.
So:
- [Part of a DJ’s job description?], KEEPRECORDS. LP’s not data.
- [Part of a matchmaker’s job description?], PLANMEETINGS. Pleasure, not business.
- [Part of an umpire’s job description?], WORKFROMHOME. The sports term.
- [Part of a squire’s job description?], DELIVERMAIL. Mail as in a suit of chainmail.
I found this puzzle quite difficult to close out. There were, as has been common of late, several tricky / different clues for shorter answers:
- [Pop-folk singer Williams], DAR. New person to me.
- [“Hadestown” Tony nominee Noblezada], EVA. New person to me.
- [Greiner of “Shark Tank”], LORI. The various people with vowel, [R/N], vowel, I can never keep straight.
On the other hand, these were gimmes for me, but I can see others struggling:
- [Tricky soccer moves], NUTMEGS. Kicking between another players open legs.
- [“__ Mubarak”: holiday greeting], EID. Have been saying for a while it’s bizarre how much more TET shows up than EID in puzzles, given the relative numbers of celebrants in the US and the world.
- [Sacred text read during Tarawih], QURAN. The more common transliteration I’ve seen of late.
Gareth
WSJ – 15a. [Some is social]. MEDIA. I would’ve been perfectly happy with an “are” in this clue. If someone wants to explain why “is” is correct here, feel free.
From dictionary.com:
USAGE NOTE FOR MEDIA
Media, like data, is the plural form of a word borrowed directly from Latin. The singular, medium, early developed the meaning “an intervening agency, means, or instrument” and was first applied to newspapers two centuries ago. In the 1920s media began to appear as a singular collective noun, sometimes with the plural medias. This singular use is now common in the fields of mass communication and advertising, but it is not frequently found outside them: The media is (or are ) not antibusiness.
I’m sympathetic to the cause of “media” as plural and stick to it in my own writing, but then I refuse to give up “data” as a plural. Fortunately, “media” in plural as not halfway as lost a cause.
Still, I do understand the contrary temptation. Who does not want these days to think of the mainstream media as an unfortunate block, led by the NY Times and Washington Post and ever susceptible to false balance and to pickup on claims that get a free ride in the well-funded right-wing media. After all, it’s sensationalism (which sells), it’s only a claim from one party (so not open to the objection that it isn’t already out there, and anyway the press loves horse race coverage), and it has the extra benefit for lazy editors of then giving them a slew of follow-up stories (who supports the claim, what is the contrary claim, and then, in a “balanced” news “analysis,” which is right, with “Trumpsters are lying” a foregone conclusion, but still, newsworthy in this unfortunate scheme).
I’m a statistician who had two years of Latin in high school. I held on to data as a plural for years. Then I realized when I made a point of doing so I sounded like a pompous ass.
Good perspective. Thanks.
The NYT seemed so familiar to me. Have they used the state sandwich theme before?? Or am I just misremembering?
Not sure about “a state sandwich” [nice coinage], but the 7/15/12 Sunday had places beginning and ending with overlapping at A — like ALGERIALABAMARCADIA.
There was also a theme only days ago of theme entry phrases bracketed by two-letter state abbreviations, one at each end. The overlap today is, no question, an interesting variation, even if I’m not a fan.
Maybe this one:
https://www.xwordinfo.com/Crossword?date=3/2/2022&g=38&d=A
It had overlaps of three world capitals, three U.S. states, and three countries.
That was it! Thank you. That was less than six months ago. It feels very weird they would run this theme again so soon. (I’ve had puzzles rejected because the theme was too similar to one that was run six years ago!) The OHIOWA beginning is even a dupe! The previous puzzle segues into WASHINGTON and this one uses ALABAMA as the end though.
The March puzzle I also think was superior because there were no letters that were used *only* in the “sandwiched” name. OHIOWASHINGTON, for example, has IOWA in the middle, with IO from OHIO and WA from WASHINGTON. OHIOWALABAMA leaves out the W from IOWA from either of the “sandwiching” states.
Finally, the March puzzle ran on a Wednesday, supporting the comments from some others that this wasn’t a Thursday-level theme.
You’re welcome.
I agree today’s puzzle is more of a Wednesday theme. If I hadn’t zipped through it and made two or three typos, I’d’ve finished it about as quickly as I usually do with Tuesday NYT puzzles.
NYT for a Thursday was too easy.
I found it easy only if I ignored the clues entirely, since who in the world knows or cares about state nicknames, apart from some that one might have encountered without seeking them out? Of course, that strategy made catching onto the idea slower, but in due course it went ok. On balance, then, seems right for Thursday. Just no fun. OTOH, very well executed.
I know lots of state nicknames. I like geography trivia, and I’ve done a few jigsaw puzzles that combine a US map with illustrations touching on nicknames, state birds, state flowers, etc.
Amy, I’m sure that’s how I picked up the nicknames I know, way back in my elementary school days. Or maybe off a diner placemat.
If I had to list the state nicknames off the top of my head, I probably couldn’t get more than a dozen or so. But give me a multiple choice test on the same material and there’s a good chance I’d ace it. The puzzle, with the crossings, was sort of like a multiple choice test.
And actually, for the one nickname I couldn’t associate with any state — “Yellowhammer” — I initially went with ALASKA, off the A in IOWA.
I could probably get 25 or so nicknames off the top of my head – many known because of sports teams (Golden State, Badgers, Hoosiers, Gophers, Buckeyes, Hawkeyes, Sooners, Tar Heels, Wolverines, Volunteers) or license plates.
This played more like a Wednesday puzzle for me. I was a little surprised to see Andrea Carla Michaels in the by-line – I usually think of her as a Monday/Tuesday constructor.
I liked it – theme was fine, fill seemed solid. The only brand-new entry for me was DOG ROSE – need to look that up. I liked the two “Greek letter” clues.
Yeah, I’m a little surprised this didn’t run on a Wednesday.
The sort-of nonsensical theme answers take it out of Tuesday territory, but it’s not quite tricky enough for Thursday.
Boring, once the first overlap was discovered, and too easy.
NYT: So, to sum up …
• Not really up to Thursday-level expectations
• Rehash of a very similar recent theme
• Not enough Roomba-riding cats to outweigh awkward entries like ICAL
Okay, that last one might be only me! But I can see why this one’s the lowest-rated Times puzzle so far this week. And after the past couple of days, that’s saying something.
I winced a bit when I entered -ICAL. I see a lot of those iffy “prefixes” and “suffixes” in NYT puzzles from the 1990’s, and I’m glad such junk is less common now.
There will never be a superior video to this one. It’s archetypal and functions as a metaphor for whatever you please.
I don’t have the words.
LAT: I enjoyed seeing NUTMEGS clued to association football; as far as I can tell, that’s the first time it hasn’t been clued as a spice. I’m not a big sports fan, but I sort of follow the World Cup, and I actually know what nutmegging is.
The theme was fine, although some of the theme answers are a bit green-painty, especially KEEP RECORDS and DELIVER MAIL.
Found a couple:
https://crosswordfiend.com/2015/07/29/thursday-july-30-2015/#ny
https://crosswordfiend.com/2014/11/26/thursday-november-27-2014/#fb
Thanks.
The BEQ one seems like a pun on the spice, but the Peter Gordon one is definitely soccer.
Oh, I didn’t read closely enough and thought it was an unfamiliar character, not realizing it was just dressing up Meg.
No problem. I appreciate your looking.
I forgot that your website allows for word searches; I used crossword tracker.com, which doesn’t cover BEQ or Peter Gordon’s puzzles (unless they’re in a major paper).
I forget too, instead using Google’s site search function.
WSJ–not familiar with anorak–I got stuck on parka and it was all downhill from there,
A word I learned from crosswords – file it away; y0u’ll use it again.
thanks