Sunday, October 23, 2022

LAT untimed (Gareth) 


NYT tk (Nate) 


USA Today untimed (Darby)  


Universal (Sunday) 11:51 (Jim P) 


Universal tk (norah) 


WaPo 6:13 (Matthew) 


Daniel Bodily & Jeff Chen’s New York Times crossword, “To Be Continued”–solution grid

Huge thanks to Amy for getting a Sunday post up when life got in the way for me. Tremendously appreciated! Rightfully so, my post will be a sort of “To Be Continued” of hers…

NY Times crossword solution, 10 23 22, “To Be Continued”

1A: ANTI [Shops]
5A: QUEST [Peddling]
10A: ORES [Collectibles]
ANTIQUE STORES [Shops peddling collectibles]

35A: MIRA [Historic]
36A: CLEO [Hockey]
37A: NICE [Upset]
MIRACLE ON ICE [Historic hockey upset]

54A: GARB [Waste]
55A: AGED [Disposal]
56A: UMPS [Locations]
GARBAGE DUMPS [Waste disposal locations]

63A: BET [Read]
64A: WEE [Here]
65A: NTH [To]
66A: ELI [Understand]
67A: NES [23 answers in today’s puzzle that don’t seem to match their clues]
BETWEEN THE LINES [Read here to understand 23 answers in today’s puzzle that don’t seem to match their clues]

76A: KALE [Dazzling]
77A: IDOS [Pattern]
78A: COPE [Generator]
KALEIDOSCOPE [Dazzling pattern generator]

92A: DRAM [Classes]
93A: ALES [For]
94A: SONS [Actors]
DRAMA LESSONS [Classes for actors]

115A: MART [Home]
116A: HASTE [Decorating]
117A: WART [Guru]
MARTHA STEWART [Home decorating guru]

Each of these puzzles theme entries is broken up into three- to five-letter words (with seemingly unrelated clues) who stand on their own right, but who spell out a larger theme answer (and relevant clue) after you combine the entries (and clues) reading across. Ignore the black squares separating those smaller words to get to the larger answer. That said, I need help understanding the revealer. Which lines are we supposed to be reading between? If the black squares are the lines, aren’t we reading around them instead of between them? I feel like I’m missing something obvious here, so please help! (The constructors’ own notes at xwordinfo also seem to voice skepticism about seeing the black squares as lines, so I’m struggling to figure out how solvers are supposed to buy into an interpretation of the all-important revealer that the constructors themselves aren’t fully sold on?)

Overall, my sense in solving this (and in checking out the online reaction to this puzzle) was that this felt like a frustrating solve (so much short, choppy fill accompanied by short, choppy clues, a grid without much flow between sections) until the aha! moment. From there, many solvers’ opinion on the puzzle did a 180, becoming one they quite enjoyed. Others (myself included?) ended up maybe more torn on whether the juice was worth the squeeze.

I think what keeps me fully from the first group is that many of the non-theme related sections of the puzzle also felt heavy on short, choppy clues, which made it hard to get footholds. Also, the first few sections of the grid were weirdly tough for me, perhaps because of the Arachne, ENOCH, ODIN, “Aeneid,” “Iliad” region paired with outside the box (but fun!) clues for entries like TSHIRTS, OCTOPUS, and TAXI that made it hard for me to plunk in any entries. I guess I wish there’d been more variety and stretch in the non-theme clues to balance out the themed sections of the puzzle, but I know there’ll be plenty who don’t agree. I’m glad at the very least that this puzzle will get folks talking, and we can hopefully agree that the themed sections at least were a pretty nice payoff.

My only two ooooofs of the puzzle were NAG (which strikes me as quite gendered) and the incredibly awful radio personality Don IMUS. IMUS / SEEN could have easily been changed to IM UP / PEEN, so it’s baffling to me why he was left in given how much damage he did over his professional career. On the other side, my favorite clue is almost certainly [Xmas, for Justin Trudeau] for BDAY – super cute.

Amy’s original review: Theme revealer is 63A through 67A: [Read] [Here] [To] [Understand] [23 answers in today’s puzzle that don’t seem to match their clues], BET WEE NTH ELI NES, or between the lines. The first three Across answers in row 1, for instance, are ANTI QUEST ORES, [Shops] [Peddling] [Collectibles], or antique stores. No idea where the rest of the themers are, as I revealed the solution and didn’t do the puzzle. (It’s bedtime and I wanted to get the post up for the gang! Thank you to Caitlin Lovinger at Wordplay for pointing me towards the theme.) Looks funky, hope you enjoyed it!–Amy

Ross Trudeau’s Universal Sunday crossword, “Ours to Share”—Jim P’s review

I do enjoy when a puzzle breaks a rule to good effect. In this case, we have a central entry unchecked by any crossing entries. It’s clued simply [(CONFIDENTIAL MATERIAL)], but what does that mean?

Universal Sunday crossword solution · “Ours to Share” · Ross Trudeau · 10.23.22

My first thought—even before I saw the clue—was that that central entry sure looks like an Oreo cookie, albeit with some extra nubbins. But there’s nary an Oreo in this grid. I had no idea what was going to go in the middle until I got to the revealer at 116a BETWEEN YOU AND ME [“Confidentially …,” and a phonetic hint to where a letter of 67-Across is located in each starred clue’s answer]. AHA! So, we look to the starred clues’ answers, look for a U and a ME, and see what’s between them.

  • 23a. [*Fruit which may keep as late as Christmas (hence its name)] SANTA CLAUS MELON. Never heard of this melon. It originated in Spain but is also grown here in the States.
  • 34a. [*”Yellow Submarine” antagonists] THE BLUE MEANIES.
  • 38a. [*Golden State sch. whose buildings are all environmentally certified] UC MERCED. I know of all the UC schools except this one. It’s the smallest at only around 7,000 undergrad and has a dismal 4-year graduation rate of 38% as of 2020.
  • 58a. [*Playful feline] BURMESE CAT.
  • 74a. [*Discount fare?] VALUE MEALS. Good clue.
  • 99a. [*Bridge or arch support] ABUTMENT.
  • 101a. [*Gold and silver, but not bronze] PRECIOUS METALS.

Very impressive. As I said, I was in the dark for the entire solve and I even got the revealer through crossings and not via the clue, so I had to purposefully read the clue and then go back and find the missing letters. I didn’t mind because this was such an impressive theme expertly executed. (I still wanted it to be about Oreos though.)

Let’s see…plenty of evocative long fill like PANIC MODE, UNION-MADE, ITALIAN ICES, NBA JAM, CAMISOLE, BARWARE, L-BOMB, “I’M LISTENING,” and COMEDY DUO. Didn’t know the book or the author TARTT [“The Goldfinch” novelist Donna], but the novel won the 2014 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction, so that’s my own failing.

Clues of note:

  • 30d. [Dart-blasting hammer maker]. NERF. A projectile-launching hammer? Oh, it’s a Minecraft thing.
  • 66d. [Dubious assertion to make while staring at your phone]. “I’M LISTENING.” I like the modern angle to the clue, but the phrase sounded somewhat familiar to me. Then I realized it was the on-air catchphrase of Frasier Crane.
  • 69d. [Trinity Rodman’s Olympic team]. USA. At only 20 years of age, she is the highest-paid player in the National Women’s Soccer League and has won all sorts of accolades in only two years. Oh, she’s also NBA star’s Dennis Rodman’s daughter.

Impressively-executed theme with a nifty gimmick. 4.25 stars.

Zhouqin Burnikel’s USA Today crossword, “From Last to First”–Darby’s review

Theme: Each theme answer begins with Z and ends with A, going from the last letter of the alphabet to the first.

Theme Answers

Zhouqin Burnikel's USA Today crossword, "From Last to First" solution for 10/23/2022

Zhouqin Burnikel’s USA Today crossword, “From Last to First” solution for 10/23/2022

  • 16a [“Place to see giant pandas in Georgia”] ZOO ATLANTA
  • 26a [“European capital on the Sava River”] ZAGREB CROATIA
  • 61a [“Actress in ‘Avatar’ and ‘Avengers’ movies”] ZOE SALDANA

This was a really fun theme, and it was useful as I was filling in ZAGREB, CROATIA since I wouldn’t say that geography is an area that I excel (but this was a great review, especially since I learned that ALASKA is the 9d [“Only U.S. state whose name can be typed on one row of a keyboard”]!). I got ZOO filled in first in ZOO ATLANTA and then came back after filling in enough off the crosses to get the city. In retrospect, this felt really obvious. ZOE SALDANA was an easy get for me, especially since the new Avatar is coming out and I’d recently be thinking about how she returned for the second (and might for the third?).

It’s fun to see the number of Zs in this puzzle as a result of the theme. It also appears in 1d [“Nickname for Elizabeth”] LIZA (though I had BETH for a bit at first). ZEROS was a fun answer in 26d [“Six in 1,000,000”]. I also thought that 10d [“Ingredient in some vegan bacon”] BANANA PEEL was interesting. I definitely want to try making some myself (I’m going to use this recipe, if you’re interested).

Overall, a great Sunday solve. I’m keeping it short since I’m at my parents’ today, but I hope y’all have a good week!

Evan Birnholz’ Washington Post crossword, “Seasonal Downturn”–Matthew’s review

Evan Birnholz’ Washington Post crossword solution, “Seasonal Downturn,” 10/23/2022

It’s sunny where I am today, but Evan brings us a precipitation-themed grid this week. We’ve got two revealers…

  • 25a [Changed direction like lightning (or like five answers in this puzzle)] ZIGZAGGED
  • 69d [Autumn conditions, and a hint to reading the answers to the starred clues] FALL WEATHER

And a series of starred clues that don’t quite make sense while intersecting down clues refer to 69d:

  • 28a [*Bygone alternative to Teen Vogue] COS. This doesn’t make sense, but pair it with 29d and 48a:
  • 29d [Example of 69 Down?] SMOG
  • 48a [“The ___ on the Train” (Paula Hawkins novel)] GIRL. Connecting these three, we get COSMO GIRL, a better answer to the first one.
  • 36a [Courtroom hotshots] LEGAL EAGLES, with GALE in the down entry.
  • 61a [*”Mother of the Blues” played by Viola Davis in a 2020 film] MA RAINEY, with RAIN in the down entry.
  • 84a [*”It can’t be done!”] THERE’S NO WAY. SNOW.
  • 92a [*Method of reading someone’s fortune on their hand] PALMISTRY. MIST

We also have a few theme-related entries fleshing out the grid:

  • 3d [Climate change topic?] METEOROLOGY
  • 117a [Predictions about seasonal changes] FORECASTS

An intricate theme with gentle cluing and two revealers, as well as some bonus answers make for a friendly grid. The theme demanded a relatively tight passage through the middle of the grid, and the resultant long acrosses on the left and right sides of the grid are an unusual place for bonus answers in a 21x.

Pam Amick Klawitter’s LA Times crossword, “I Needed a Change” – Gareth’s summary

LA Times

“I Needed a Change” is the type of theme that is popular in Sundays. The sound “aɪ” in eight entries is altered to “æ”. Spelling changes as needed. This kind of theme has a vast number of options, so you can make a Sunday set while still choosing some pearlers. Today we have:

  • [Parliamentary official overseeing strollers?], BRITISHPRAMMINISTER.
  • [Brave showing at the bug zapper?], ONEGNATSTAND
  • [Clean halfheartedly?], BATTHEDUST. A strong image.
  • [Guy who invented tiny nails?], FATHEROFTHEBRAD.
  • [Excellent reason to avoid a career as a milliner?], FEAROFHATS
  • [Evidence that leads to identity thieves?], HACKINGTRAIL
  • [How one kisses a famous rock at Blarney Castle?], NOSETOTHEGRANDSTONE. Another strong image. Here’s Tyler Childers...

Fast five:

  • [Brand of sport sandals], TEVA. Never heard of it. Do know the pharmaceutical company. They make my vincristine.
  • [Vegetable in red flannel hash], BEET. That… does not sound edible.
  • [Parking lot siren], CARALARM. Do these achieve anything other than noise pollution?
  • [California town whose name means “the river”], ELRIO. Population 7,000… Although the translation makes the clue easy anyway.
  • [“I Try” Grammy winner], MACYGREY. Whatever happened to her?


This entry was posted in Daily Puzzles and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

27 Responses to Sunday, October 23, 2022

  1. Josh M says:

    Wow. That sucked. Just a total slog. I will never get that half-hour back.

    • Mister [Very] Grumpy says:

      Should have saved it for Sunday, April 1, 2029. I might have liked it as an April Fool’s Day prank. Not today.

      Oh … and you’re not reading BETWEEN the lines; you’re reading ACROSS [or ignoring] the lines, so even the “revealer” fails. I vote 1 on this puzzle. Ugh.

  2. Alex says:

    NYT: I actually really enjoyed this one. Took me a while to put Martha Stewart together at the bottom to get the trick, and then the rest fell easily; fave clue set: historic hockey upset

    • Tony says:

      I figured the theme with Garbage Dumps.

      Miracle on ice was nice too. It’s my favorite sports story of all time and 2004′ “Miracle” is one of my favorite movies.

  3. Tony says:

    I actually enjoyed the NYT. I hope I’m not the only one. I assumed going in that some of the entries would be clued as “-” indicating that the rest of the entry would follow across the black squares. I thought it was nice that some of the clues didn’t match the entries and liked that the revealer was presented in the same way.

    I didn’t like some of the cluing for the full. I don’t say “Hold the rocks” at a bar. It’s either “on the rocks” or “neat.”

  4. Gary R says:

    NYT: Took me quite a while, but I finished the puzzle with no errors. Could not, for the life of me, grok the theme. I finally gave up and looked at xwordinfo. Now I have a dilemma – didn’t really enjoy the solve, but I’m impressed as hell with the theme.

  5. David L says:

    Struggled with the NYTY for a while but once I got the trick it was easy to complete. And the theme answers are nice finds.

    I don’t understand the revealer, tho. What are the lines that we’re reading between?

    • Mr. [very] Grumpy says:

      There are none. That is one of the most stupid parts of this poor excuse for a puzzle.

    • Eric H says:

      Rex Parker wrote on his blog that the “lines” are the diagonal pattern of blocks in the middle.

      I’m not sure I buy that. Maybe the revealer just plays on the metaphorical meaning of “read between the lines.”

      I found the title to be a better description of the the, than the revealer.

  6. JohnH says:

    Count me in with the NYT enjoyers. Obviously something was going on with the peculiar grid of so much short fill (although not TOO heavy a burden of 3’s as opposed to 4’s and 5’s). That alone was intriguing and meant work ahead. There are a few long down clues at the edges that seem ill-placed (poorly integrated into the rest of the diagram) for themers, which could be a hint, a waste of time, or a rabbit hole, but at least it balances the short entries a bit.

    After that, there was nothing to do but get going, although I might have done better looking at the clues more for in retrospect the obvious. So the aha took me a while, which I appreciate, and then things went really fast, so not TOO much of a slog. (I did have Noel for Justin Trudeau’s Xmas, guessing it was about a bilingual nation.)

    At first something seemed way, way wrong, and some of the fill reminded me that I’m not a Jeff Chen fan, too mechanically filling out a puzzle with someone else’s idea. That is, with so uniform a grid, why the theme entries in this row and not that? But then realizing that they break down into legitimate crossword fill, real words, made up for it. So not a dazzling puzzle, and I don’t like hockey, but not as bad as other solvers found it.

  7. huda says:

    NYT: I started off disliking this puzzle and ended up loving it! I think the reading between the lines refers to reading across the lines of the clues, and the title “To be Continued” means to continue reading within the puzzle answers to figure out the theme answer.

    So: the clues across 3 lines and their answers:

    Shops Peddling Collectibles: ANTIQUE STORES
    Historic Hockey Upset: MIRACLE ON ICE
    Waste Disposal Locations: GARBAGE DUMPS
    Home Decorating Guru: MARTHA STEWART
    Dazzling Pattern Generator: KALEIDOSCOPE
    Classes for Actors: DRAMA LESSONS
    And the revealer, as described by Amy: (Read) BETWEEN THE LINES.

    It definitely was unusual and took a while to work out, but I thought it was very creative and fun.

    • Mr. [very] Grumpy says:

      Between and across are not synonyms. One of the many reasons I hated this puzzle. I wish I could give it a ZERO.

    • Dallas says:

      I was in this camp too; when I first saw all the short fill ahead, I was a bit surprised for a Sunday. And I wasn’t too far along before I saw the lines of clues stacked up. I was completely delighted, and running through the clues to find the theme answers; even showed it to my 7 year old with the broken words and full sections. I thought it was a really fun Sunday, and came together very smoothly.

  8. Jim G says:

    Too much short fill in the NYT for my tastes.

    Also, I’d swear that I saw either IM NOT A ROBOT or I AM NOT A ROBOT in a recent puzzle, but I can’t figure out where. Xwordinfo doesn’t show anything for either (aside from today’s puzzle), and I can’t find any mention of it here, so maybe my memory is playing tricks on me. Evan, this wasn’t in one of yours recently, was it? NYT and WaPo are the only puzzles I usually do.

  9. Alison Lawrence says:

    I thought it was great! I really enjoyed it. Very creative and totally different than any other puzzles I’ve done previously.

  10. Mr. [Not Always] Grumpy says:

    Just so you don’t think I’m a total grump, I loved the LAT. I’d nominate Boris Johnson for BRITISH PRAM MINISTER, since he’s not qualified for anything else — although maybe BRITISH PRAT MINISTER would work.

  11. David and Heather says:

    I could tell from the looks of it that many people were not going to enjoy the NYT puzzle because it would strike them as too CHOPPY. My wife and I solve them together, and this one was baffling until we got to MARTHA STEWART, at which point we were able to make sense of it and quickly solve the rest. The result was a minor slog that turned into a real joy. And we like that sort of thing. It’s like comedians who purposely gets the audience against them and then suddenly turn things around and get people on their side. Masterful.

  12. Duke Danbury says:

    WaPo: Fantastic puzzle Evan! The moment I grokked it was a nice smile moment.

    NYT: I don’t do the NYT for various reasons but reading the review above made me happy I don’t and also appreciate Evan’s Sunday puzzles even more. With all these tricky for tricky sake fills and esoteric metas lately (I think metas jumped the shark in the past year or so), I’m just thankful for those that are good yet somewhat challenging.

    • Thank you, I’m glad you liked my puzzle … but I don’t understand your comment about metas. I write metas on occasion and today’s NYT didn’t have one.

      • Duke Danbury says:

        Just lumping them in with the ones that have overly tricky fills is all. I know I’m in the minority though. I used to like metas on occasion, but once I started seeing them almost every day I got tired quickly.

  13. My 2 Cents says:

    There is no revealer in the NYT because it’s part of the gimmick so it doesn’t matter if it makes sense or not. However, you’d think it would be more fitting, something not hard to do even if you wanted to use a known phrase. Just off the top of my head, something like Jump to Conclusions, Make The Connection, Hop To It, etc.

    • My 3 Cents says:

      Just realized those phrases can’t be broken into constituent words, but I’m sure phrases more fitting could. I suspect they were set on what they used which is baffling since it doesn’t appear to make sense.

  14. Pilgrim says:

    Interesting that Sarah Hughes, Viola Davis, and Ma Rainey were all in both the WaPo and LA Times puzzles. Coincidence? I think not!

Comments are closed.